3 ms·
Wow. I had a '91 Saturn sedan until 2015. Despite my model being out of production for decades, and Saturn having closed up shop for years, I could still find
by paulddraper 7y ago
Wow.
I had a '91 Saturn sedan until 2015. Despite my model being out of production for decades, and Saturn having closed up shop for years, I could still find aftermarket auto parts.
How common of a problem is this?
Any other manufactures/models notorious for poor part availability?
- RickJWagner 7y agoBut they made a lot more Saturns than they did Tesla Roadsters. That's got a lot to do with the strength of the parts market. BTW-- congrats on the Saturn! I had a '94 SC1, first car I ever bought brand new. Good car.
- paulddraper 7y agoMine was an SL2. I wish I knew how many miles I had on it; the odometer broke at 186,000 in 2003.
- pmorici 7y agoPretty big difference between a model that sells 2,500 total units and one that sells millions over 2 decades. A better comparison would be to look at what parts availability is on a limited run sports car.
- paulddraper 7y agoYou're right; that's a good point. The are specialized vehicles akin to a rare sports car; it's unfair to compare it to mass market vehicles.
- mbreese 7y agoNot only the limited run nature, but part of this has also got to be the big supplier network that is available for other cars. How many custom parts are there on a Tesla Roadster compared to other cars? There are large supplier networks that can supply many (most? all?) of the internal parts required to build a complete car (sport or otherwise). I’ve got to think that the ratio skews heavily to the side of custom for any of the Tesla. This is where Tesla’s intense vertical integration starts to be a detriment. I was just reading an article about how the vertical integration of Tesla was amazing in that it made it possible for custom components to be used that saved space and weight by performing more than one job [0]. This is great - until you need to replace that one specialized part and you can’t seem to find it. I laughed when I was looking at the cup holder for my new car. It’s a 2018 Audi A3. The rear cup holder is the same junky design that I had to replace multiple times in an old 2000 Jetta. It’s not a great design, even-though it saves space. However, because of all of the available suppliers for that part, I know I’ll be able to find a replacement of this for years. This type of parts availability is a blessing (you can find one cheap) and a curse (you are limited in how you can design the car by the parts that are already available, thus you can only have a barely functional cup holder). [0] https://www.teslarati.com/tesla-model-3-superbottle-disruption-video/ https://www.teslarati.com/tesla-model-3-superbottle-disrupti...
- userbinator 7y agoThis is great - until you need to replace that one specialized part and you can’t seem to find it. ...or when that multifunction part fails and renders much of the car inoperable. Odd that that article about the Superbottle mentions "increased modularity" as an advantage, when it clearly decreases modularity to integrate so many functions into one monolithic part.
- johncalvinyoung 7y agoYup. Try a first gen Jaguar XK8. Not crazy rare, many small towns have one or two. Gorgeous cars. But despite Ford owning Jag for a while, and some shared parts, you’d better hope you don’t need repairs. Only ~50k made in the whole world across the whole ten years of production. And that’s not even partitioning for body style or revision. Some critical parts are scarcer than hens’ teeth.
- jandrese 7y agoMost of the parts on your car are just GM parts. Auto manufacturers don't design a new pump/bearing/condenser/etc... for every make and model of their vehicles, they take one off of the shelf. When it breaks you can find a replacement because there are dozens or hundreds of cars that used the exact same part and supplying one supplies them all. Even when the manufacturer stops making that part (because the last car they used it in is 15+ years old) there's a healthy market of people making knockoffs just for people like you. I gave plenty of money to companies like Dorman to keep my old 90s truck alive. With something like those early model Teslas there is a lot of custom one-off parts that are near impossible to find. The problem is a lot harder.
- userbinator 7y agoGM and the Big Three in general have a huge aftermarket and good parts availability likely due to the prevalence of the modding/tuning culture at the peak of the "car era" (1950s-70s). In fact you can still buy all the parts for the running gear of the stereotypical American car (V8, 3-speed auto/4-speed manual, RWD, IFS) entirely from the aftermarket, and they'll perform just as well if not better than the original parts. Auto manufacturers don't design a new pump/bearing/condenser/etc... for every make and model of their vehicles, they take one off of the shelf. ...unless it's a German car. Or so the stories go...
- mschuster91 7y ago> ...unless it's a German car. Or so the stories go... VW has extremely decent availability for spare parts, speaking from experience here. That, and I am not joking here, even extends to sausages - try ordering part # 199 398 500 A ;)
- paulddraper 7y ago> With something like those early model Teslas there is a lot of custom one-off parts that are near impossible to find. I guess the question becomes why did Tesla have so many one-off parts? Is it all attributable to being electric rather than gas?