3 ms·
The cycle life isn't too bad given that this is still at the "it works at all" stage, not the "refined to be commercially viable" stage. Remember that 20 years
by taneq 7y ago
The cycle life isn't too bad given that this is still at the "it works at all" stage, not the "refined to be commercially viable" stage. Remember that 20 years ago the only practical bulk storage battery was lead acid and that had a similar cycle life. We're just spoiled these days with LiIon and LiPoly being so cheaply available.
Also the per-kilogram energy storage is far less important given the price difference between iron and lithium. There's a huge market for stationary battery storage where weight and even (to a lesser extent) size are non-factors compared with cost per kWh.
- mc32 7y agoThis is pretty cool. While lithium isn’t that scarce iron is plentiful. Also would be even nicer if it used fewer heavy metals and rare earth elements.
- nine_k 7y agoLithium is also quite plentiful, not rare at all. It's also not poisonous the way lead or cadmium are. Lithium batteries are a fire hazard, though, even if we learn to produce them 10x as cheap in the future. Iron batteries are most likely not.
- klyrs 7y agoStationary storage sounds like a killer app. 150 charge cycles doesn't sound like much, but if you're using these in combination with solar power, the batteries could serve for almost half a year.
- D_Alex 7y agoYes, for some stationary storage applications 150 cycles would be completely adequate, and would last for many years. Eg: replacement of emergency generators, or some peaking power stations which only operate for a few days per year (we have lots of these in Australia).
- rohan_shah 7y agoThe zinc-bromide batteries are doing good work in Australia, aren't they? They seem to have >5000 complete battery cycles. I think that's the best one can get for stationary applications.
- taneq 7y agoYou mean the Redflow ones? They do look interesting, I haven't heard much about them for a while but here's a review from 2016: https://www.solarquotes.com.au/blog/redflows-zinc-bromide-zcell-battery-may-have-the-edge-over-lithium-ion/ https://www.solarquotes.com.au/blog/redflows-zinc-bromide-zc... Ah, it sounds like they went quiet while setting up manufacturing facilities in Thailand and have recently started marketing again: https://redflow.com/redflow-on-growth-trajectory-after-emerging-from-a-two-year-turnaround/#more-9137 https://redflow.com/redflow-on-growth-trajectory-after-emerg...
- ac29 7y agoLead acid batteries are lousy with a full depth of discharge, but for partial discharges, such as car starter batteries, or solar powered telemetry stations, they can easily have 1000+ cycles of lifetime. If an Iron-ion battery could replace these applications economically, that would be a huge market. Lithium iron-phosphate batteries are great for these purposes, but cost nearly 10x more than lead acid.
- taneq 7y agoWhen you say "1000+ cycles" do you mean 1000 discharge-a-bit / recharge-a-bit cycles, or an equivalent total energy storage to 1000 full cycles? If the latter, then it's a bit misleading to discuss "cycles". You're actually getting 1000 cycles to 10% depth of discharge, which is equivalent in terms of total stored energy to 100 cycles at 100% depth of discharge.
- ac29 7y agoAnecdotally, when dealing with lead acid batteries, 1 100% discharge is much worse in terms of cycle life than 2 50% discharge cycles or 10 10% cycles. Other chemistries dont have this problem, or are less affected.
- ksec 7y ago>Also the per-kilogram energy storage is far less important given the price difference between iron and lithium. There's a huge market for stationary battery storage where weight and even (to a lesser extent) size are non-factors compared with cost per kWh. Excuse my ignorance, so what is this Iron-Ion battery good at even if we discount Per Kilogram Storage? Iron / Lithium isn't even the 10% of Battery BOM cost. Am I missing something here?