4 ms·
One thing that gets people in the US is medical problems. Just as an anecdote, I got a couple of sinus infections back to back on my recent trip to the US. Tw
by davidw 16y ago
One thing that gets people in the US is medical problems.
Just as an anecdote, I got a couple of sinus infections back to back on my recent trip to the US. Two doctor visits plus antibiotics cost me more than 250 dollars out of pocket.
And that's for a relatively trifling problem. Imagine getting hit with serious medical bills at the very same time your ability to work has been seriously diminished.
- michaelchisari 16y agoI had my appendix out a couple years ago, and it cost me around $2000, and this was with some really fantastic insurance. If uninsured, I would have gotten a bill for around $25,000. Had I been in a different point in my life, I would have been ruined financially.
- yummyfajitas 16y agoThis is widely believed, but only due to a deeply flawed study which got a lot of press. New statistics following the publication of that article have shown this pretty conclusively. http://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2010/12/will-health-care-reform-reduce-medical-bankruptcies/68304/ http://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2010/12/will-hea...
- michaelchisari 16y agoAll that shows is that Massachusetts system is flawed. For instance, there are zero medical bankruptcies in Switzerland, France, or Germany.
- yummyfajitas 16y agoEven if it were flawed, you'd expect some effect. Also, you are simply wrong with your international comparison. If we apply the standards of Warren's study, any bankrupt citizen of France who spent $1001 or more in taxes on France's national health care system was a "medical bankruptcy".
- michaelchisari 16y agoEven if it were flawed, you'd expect some effect. Why? If you improperly implement a system, you don't have to have any reasonable expectation of success. If I recreate a system incorrectly, I can't say, well, I should expect at least a 5% success rate. Often, poor implementations can cause negative results. any bankrupt citizen of France who spent $1001 or more in taxes That would be incorrect, because medical bankruptcies are the result of medical costs directly. For instance, being in a car accident or being diagnosed with HIV, neither of which directly result in a bankruptcy of any kind due to medical costs in those countries.
- yummyfajitas 16y agoWhy? If you improperly implement a system, you don't have to have any reasonable expectation of success. So you truly believe that forcing everyone to purchase low deductible medical insurance is so deeply flawed that it will not reduce medical bankruptcies at all? Good to know. That would be incorrect, because medical bankruptcies are the result of medical costs directly. According to Elizabeth Warren's criteria, anyone who spent $1001 on medical expenses in the 2 years prior to their bankruptcy is classified as a medical bankruptcy. So for example, Michael Vick's bankruptcy was a "medical bankruptcy" by the criteria of the study we are discussing. (For those unfamiliar, other contributing factors to Vick's bankruptcy were spending wildly on consumer goods like mansions and boats, going to jail, and losing his job as NFL quarterback as a result. But nevertheless, Elizabeth Warren believes this was a medical bankruptcy.)
- michaelchisari 16y agoso deeply flawed that it will not reduce medical bankruptcies at all? Yes, which is why I support a national health care system, like France or Germany. A public option, which Massachusetts lacks, has also been shown to work better, although I don't consider it ideal by any stretch. According to Elizabeth Warren's criteria First off, we don't need to use Elizabeth Warren's criteria to recognize how medical bankruptcies affect people. There's plenty of studies out there which use different criteria, but none of which conclude with Zero.