3 ms·
Meta: Where's the manual for administrating Moscow's elections? What portion of election administration was this applied to? Thru recurring embarrassment, I've
by specialist 7y ago
Meta: Where's the manual for administrating Moscow's elections? What portion of election administration was this applied to?
Thru recurring embarrassment, I've learned that you start with the jurisdiction's laws, rules, procedures, manuals.
Update: Julia Krivonosova, cited by this OC paper, appears to be doing excellent work, and does cover some of the context, assumptions. She'd definitely a better election integrity advocate than I ever was.
Internet voting in Russia. How? https://medium.com/@juliakrivonosova/internet-voting-in-russia-how-9382db4da71f https://medium.com/@juliakrivonosova/internet-voting-in-russ...
The Dizzying Whimsy of Russia’s Electoral Laws
https://medium.com/@juliakrivonosova/the-dizzying-whimsy-of-russias-election-laws-761449a7495a https://medium.com/@juliakrivonosova/the-dizzying-whimsy-of-... https://www.ridl.io/en/the-dizzying-whimsy-of-russias-election-laws/ https://www.ridl.io/en/the-dizzying-whimsy-of-russias-electi...
--
It's possible (however unlikely) that a voting system built on top of Etherium is perfectly reasonable for Moscow, Russia, where ever.
Even in the USA, where the Australian Ballot (private voting, public counting) is the gold standard, there are many, many exceptions (compromises made). For very good reasons. For instance, postal balloting. Originally implemented to enfranchise soldiers kept away from their homes for long durations.
Further, even in the USA, YMMV. Local variations impact election administration. For instance, how "voter intent" is adjudicated (when a mistake is made by the voter).
If we don't start with the context and assumptions, we end up talking past each other, and getting no where.
--
Though I am a blockchain skeptic, for voting and tabulation, there are other exciting potential applications. Election administration is a big, complicated problem. While tabulation is the most important step, it's also relatively minor.
Since blockchain is just a shared ledger, it could help with pretty much every other step: candidate filing, political boundaries (GIS), voter registration (eligibility), reporting campaign contributions and expenses, publishing reports (certification), audit of material handling. Etc.