3 ms·
Slippery slope being a thing, a ruling here has the potential to affect YouTube as well, since they run automated captions on videos. I’d be surprised if Google
by falcolas 7y ago
Slippery slope being a thing, a ruling here has the potential to affect YouTube as well, since they run automated captions on videos. I’d be surprised if Google didn’t step in an offer up an opinion in support of Amazon.
- la_barba 7y agoHmm.. has anyone ever been sued for adding captions? I don't see how they would.. as far as the end user is concerned, the captions are embedded into the video, are not a separate performance or a product. Not exactly analogous to audiobook vs ebook.
- falcolas 7y agoCaptions is exactly what's being offered though. Amazon is not providing an ebook, they're providing captions in-sync with the audiobook. The difference between an audiobook and a video is pretty small in a significant portion of YouTube content.
- la_barba 7y agoThe difference is that audio-books is a separate product category with its own pricing. Embedding text in a video is quite different IMHO...
- DuskStar 7y agoIf Amazon added an animation to the existing audiobook content - making it a video - and then added captions would that be OK? As the GP said, there's quite a few youtube videos with a completely static background where the content is the speaker's words.
- la_barba 7y ago>If Amazon added an animation to the existing audiobook content - making it a video - and then added captions would that be OK? AFAIK, they would have to obtain prior permission from the copyright owner before re-distributing a modified version of the copyrighted work.