3 ms·
I would imagine one of Amazon's defenses is going to be that, actually, they are required to do this by the ADA? I imagine various blind organizations will be
by jrochkind1 7y ago
I would imagine one of Amazon's defenses is going to be that, actually, they are required to do this by the ADA?
I imagine various blind organizations will be filing friend of the court briefs.
- maire 7y agoJohn Scalzi posted this article on twitter - and I made the same point that it was likely to comply with the ADA. The whole thing seems like a tempest in a teapot given the relatively poor quality of speech to text. Text to speech is actually useful - but that has been around for years and publishers are not complaining.
- amyjess 7y agoYou mean deaf organizations, right? In any case, I agree with you. Some people would say "If you're deaf, just buy the regular book, it's cheaper", but there's a significant use case that's not covered by that: imagine if you bought a large collection of audiobooks and then due to some medical problem, you lose your hearing (and yes, I have heard of people suddenly losing most of their hearing in their 30s). Amazon could be sued if they didn't have an accessible option. Edit: Here's another use case: Someone who's HOH and can understand most of the audiobook but needs assistance with a few passages here and there.
- 6gvONxR4sf7o 7y agoI'm not even what people usually describe as hard of hearing, and I need to go back and rewatch a couple lines of TV with subtitles to get it. It's useful for all kinds of people.
- acomjean 7y agoIf the publishers prevail it probably would end non profits that "read newspapers and magazines" for the blind. e.g.: http://gatewave.org/ http://gatewave.org/
- tzs 7y agoDoes the ADA cover publishing formats? Considering that most books in the US are published in regular print only, with no braille edition or audio edition or even a large print editions, if the ADA applied I would have expected lawsuits to have ended that long ago.
- fortran77 7y agoWhy would a blind [advocacy] organization be fighting for Speech-To-Text? Please explain.