10 ms·
Tell HN: Oracle now requires you to login when you try to download JRE
Oracle now requires you to create an account and login when you try to download JRE from the JRE download page at https://www.oracle.com/technetwork/java/javase/downloads/jre8-downloads-2133155.html
- faeyanpiraat 7y agoThey have put the newest mysql server behind registrationwall aswell. Really annoying
- mirimir 7y agoAnd they spam you incessantly for months afterward.
- clouddrover 7y agoCan't you just download it here: https://java.com/en/download/manual.jsp https://java.com/en/download/manual.jsp
- ghostbust555 7y agoYeah not sure what the problem is. Google "download java" and this is the first link.
- slenk 7y agoIts not in the first few links on my Google search. Same with someone else in this post
- facorreia 7y agoGoogle results are influenced by your search history.
- Bartweiss 7y agoOracle has two different links up, one of which requires a login. Searching "jdk download" on a clean machine brings me to the technetwork page which requires a login.
- ryandrake 7y agoMaybe the title should be modified to: “Tell HN: It’s now slightly harder to find a Java download link in a few seconds of searching”
- taftster 7y agoThis gives you a download of the JRE (the runtime components), not the JDK (the developer components). So if you're an end user of Java with no desire to compile your own Java projects, the java.com site will give you what you need. Note also, java.com will only give you the latest short-term support version, which is currently Java 12. So if you want a LTS version, you will have to go elsewhere.
- severino 7y ago> This gives you a download of the JRE But the post title says JRE, not JDK.
- slipwalker 7y agothey are making it easier and easier to decide to switch to https://adoptopenjdk.net https://adoptopenjdk.net ...
- Bartweiss 7y agoBrew and apt will both get you openjdk, which is nice. Since that also sets up JAVA_HOME and avoids the ludicrous Ask.com adware Oracle has been bundling, it's become a pretty easy choice.
- taftster 7y agoI don't think the Oracle bundling of Ask.com adware has been part of the distribution for a long time now. Like 5-7 years or so? Can't remember exactly. But to your point, the whole fiasco of including ask.com sure gave Java a black eye. This was the worst thing that Oracle could have ever done for the adoption of Java. So dumb. But anyway, all downloads of Java regardless of source (to my knowledge) are free from that adware now. Definitely all the OpenJDK distributions are, which you should likely be using anyway.
- Bartweiss 7y agoThanks, I didn't realize how out of date I was on that whole Ask debacle. Shows how long it's been since I downloaded the Oracle JDK by hand, I guess... In any case, I'm impressed that OpenJDK manages to be a clear winner on all of access (no login needed), convenience (package managers set up paths), and principle. FOSS doesn't usually have a reputation for being faster and easier to set up than its owned alternatives.
- Someone1234 7y agoThat's not a website aimed at consumers though. All the questions they're asking should be hidden in "Other Platforms" with one giant link saying "Latest Release." I don't care about the politics or niche between HotSpot Vs. OpenJ9, and reading the descriptions it sounds like 99% of people who don't know better want HotSpot and JDK 12, so why even ask these questions? That website is a perfect showcase of why OpenJDK isn't popular. Oracle's consumer experienced is ten times better: https://www.java.com/en/ https://www.java.com/en/
- drinane 7y agoYeah I think there is a work around.. but it will take this comment board to bubble it up
- bhaak 7y agoIs the workaround downloading a newer version? Because this works for me. Not that I would do this unless I'm prevented from downloading OpenJDK.
- jplayer01 7y agoThis is annoying. https://java.com/en/download/ https://java.com/en/download/ will give you the download without signing in. But if you happen to be directed to https://www.oracle.com/technetwork/java/javase/downloads/ https://www.oracle.com/technetwork/java/javase/downloads/ instead, say through a google search (which is the top search result on Google for me), you have to login.
- taftster 7y agojava.com will give you a JRE distribution only. e.g. all the parts that you need to run java, not the parts that you need to develop it. The oracle.com link that you refer to is the source for the Oracle JDK, which includes the compiler, etc.
- jplayer01 7y agoNo, scroll down. It gives you the option to download the JRE as well, and that's the one that requires a login. If this were some obscure link you had to go out of your way to reach, it wouldn't be a big deal. However, depending on the alignment of the moon and the sun, the link might be the top of the Google search or it might be second or third. I refreshed a couple of times and got slightly different results, it was always near the top though. https://www.oracle.com/technetwork/java/javase/downloads/jre8-downloads-2133155.html https://www.oracle.com/technetwork/java/javase/downloads/jre... This is the direct link Google gives me and it's the one that requires a login.
- metalliqaz 7y agoSo are they trying to kill the platform?
- meddlepal 7y agoNo.
- mumblemumble 7y agoNo, they're trying to make money off of it. I assume they're looking to figure out how to make a lot of money off of it, to make up for shrinking enterprise software revenues. It may be that their efforts to increase profits right now also inhibit Java's pre-eminence in the open source community over the long run. I doubt that's a major concern for them. Oracle is a Fortune 500 company, not a nonprofit foundation.
- oblio 7y agoIt's still sad, though. Java got where it is thanks to Open Source. Java's push onto the web failed (applets), Java's push onto desktops failed (AWT/Swing), Java's push onto mobiles failed (Java ME; Android doesn't count, Google did it despite/against Sun/Oracle). The only truly successful Java domain is Java backends, which was rescued from Java EE hell by Apache, basically.
- rubinelli 7y ago.Net Core, on the other hand, looks better and better. It's expected to hit 3.0 next month. If I were making a stack decision today, barring some very specific library/integration requirements, I'd rather pick it or Go over Java.
- pjmlp 7y agoHow is that Xamarin.Form GUI designer doing on .NET Core for Linux? Focusing on .NET nowadays, but there are definitely a few areas where .NET Core fails short of Java offerings.
- 7y ago
- tyingq 7y agoProbably not a bad idea since the Oracle JRE/JDK is not free to use. It helps push people to OpenJDK distributions.
- Bartweiss 7y agoI'm proof of that happening, actually! I ran into this login page a few days ago when setting up a new machine. It was enough friction to make me think "wait, what am I doing?", and use brew to get OpenJDK instead. That's a better decision all around, so in a weird way I'm grateful.
- Someone1234 7y agoHow does that work in practice? If I google "Java Runtime" I get Oracle's site, mirrors of Oracle's site, then very sketchy sites claiming to offer similar (which I can only assume are malware). That's the first page of Google's results. How are people meant to find and use these alternatives?
- taftster 7y agoAgreed. It's going to take awhile for the search indexes to start offering better OpenJDK sources. As Oracle has moved its version of the JVM to a paid/registration model, the marketing and awareness of other alternatives are somewhat catching up. So here you go: AdoptOpenJDK - supported by a number of commercial companies and individuals committed to keeping the OpenJDK environment easy to use and integrate. Get your Mac, Windows and Linux JVMs here. https://adoptopenjdk.net/ https://adoptopenjdk.net/ Redhat - Maintaining the JVM long term support versions for their distributions, which includes inclusion by CentOS, etc. Apt/Debian/Ubuntu - I'm not totally sure who is maintaining the Apt version, but Ubuntu and others have the LTS version of the JVM available as well.
- tyingq 7y agoAlso, Amazon Corretto, supports Windows, Macs, and Linux. https://aws.amazon.com/corretto/ https://aws.amazon.com/corretto/
- PedroBatista 7y agoGood for them, with some luck they'll even pull some Open Solaris to Solaris to Death move. Meanwhile: https://adoptopenjdk.net/ https://adoptopenjdk.net/
- Krasnol 7y agoTIL! Thank you it worked out pretty well for the application with which I've been using it the most. Never seen it starting so fast. Are there any downsides to this?
- taftster 7y agoThe Oracle JVM and the OpenJDK JVM (as provided by AdoptOpenJDK and friends) are for all practical purposes identical. There was a time when OpenJDK was still young that you'd probably prefer the Oracle JVM. But since maybe 5-7 years now, the Oracle JVM is basically composed of the OpenJDK plus some additional Oracle licensed features that don't affect many/most applications. In short, use the OpenJDK for your project. There are no real downsides for 98% of applications. AdoptOpenJDK is a great source, or likewise vendors like Redhat who are also maintaining OpenJDK distributions.
- Krasnol 7y agoThank you. I'll keep it :)
- vbezhenar 7y agoOr https://www.azul.com/downloads/zulu-community/ https://www.azul.com/downloads/zulu-community/ which claims to be TCK-tested (whatever that means)
- zsrxx 7y agoMy only experience with OpenJDK is trying to run Minecraft with it at much worse performance than Oracle's JRE
- chaz6 7y agoThere are alternative JRE/JDK distributions, including Coretto (Amazon), Zulu (Azul), OpenJ9 (IBM), AdoptOpenJDK (jClarity/Microsoft).
- techie128 7y agoYou can completely avoid this by using a package manager - Homebrew on macOS, apt on Debian/Ubuntu, yum on Redhat/CentOS. I don't use Windows but I am sure there should be something similar. You also don't need to use Oracle's distro any more. AdoptOpenJDK is a great alternative.
- dzhiurgis 7y agoI install mine via brew, but IIRC https://sdkman.io https://sdkman.io should easily solve this too.
- butz 7y agoGood thing that Android Studio includes its own JRE.
- aitchnyu 7y agoSo does all its Jetbrains bethren, like Pycharm, Rubymine, PHPStorm, Idea.
- taftster 7y agoThis was part of the master plan and roadmap for Java for a long time now. This should not be a surprise or cause any outrage. The roadmap was: 1. Oracle starts to relicense as open source most parts of the JVM, spinning off OpenJDK in the process. 2. Oracle provides support, patches, community and endeavors to help get OpenJDK self-sustaining. 3. Once OpenJDK is maintained by the open source community and generally healthy, Oracle starts working on proprietary value-add additions that can benefit their customer base (and bank accounts). We're entering phase 3. Oracle, beyond what you might think of them, has done a pretty decent job of following the overall plan. They have helped get the OpenJDK community off the ground and are still invested in its success. Without doing the above, there was real risk that Java would succumb to other more open platforms or be splintered off by companies like IBM, Redhat, etc. Instead, the above plan allowed for Oracle to keep the core of Java in one piece, conceding that other companies would help with its evolution, and still reserve their ability to make a buck later. It's a little shaky right now with all the hubbub about Oracle's licensing of the Oracle JVM. The messaging could have possibly been better. But if you haven't been aware of the OpenJDK and following along with it - if your sole source of all things Java has been Oracle - then it's definitely time for a wake up call. Oracle is now a member of the Java community, not necessarily the driver.
- fierarul 7y ago> Oracle is now a member of the Java community, not necessarily the driver. I agree that, all in all, Oracle told the world what it's going to do and now is executing on the plan. It's no surprise really, and it makes sense that they want to make money somehow from Java considering how much they are putting into it. Still, Oracle is most certainly the driver still. If you look at a chart like [1] you see that Oracle has an order of magnitude more commits than the 2nd company which, surprise, is SAP. Also, if you read the OpenJDK bylaws [2] the OpenJDK Lead will forever be from Oracle as will the Board Chair. Oracle will never lose under a Two-Thirds Majority rule when they have 2 of the 5 seats. Note how AdoptOpenJDK could not run the TCK on the JDK builds which included OpenJ9. 1. https://blogs.oracle.com/java-platform-group/building-jdk-11-together https://blogs.oracle.com/java-platform-group/building-jdk-11... 2. https://openjdk.java.net/bylaws https://openjdk.java.net/bylaws
- zokier 7y agoOnly old versions of Oracle binaries require login, the current version (12) does not, either on https://www.oracle.com/technetwork/java/javase/downloads/jdk12-downloads-5295953.html https://www.oracle.com/technetwork/java/javase/downloads/jdk... or https://jdk.java.net/12/ https://jdk.java.net/12/
- taftster 7y agoI wouldn't quite say "old versions" - it's possibly better to say LTS versions (long term support). The LTS versions are what Oracle is requiring registration/payment for now; so if you want to stay on the "Java 8 Oracle JVM", you'll have to pay for that privilege. Or alternatively, you can get a LTS version from another vendor based on the OpenJDK source. For example, AdoptOpenJDK or your Linux distribution.
- ocdtrekkie 7y agoBasically, Java is suffering from the Windows XP problem right now. Nobody supported anything above Java 8, so everyone's still trying to use it, and Oracle's done with giving it out for free.
- toyg 7y agoIsh. This move would have eventually happened even if the community had jumped on Java 9+ from day 1. Oracle is all about monetizing and reducing costs, doing that with Java was always on the cards. It just so happens that it comes at a time when there is also an upgrade issue from a technical perspective.
- ternaryoperator 7y ago>Oracle is all about monetizing and reducing costs, doing that with Java was always on the cards. You might not like Oracle, but let's be fair here. They completely open sourced the JDK and encouraged other vendors to ship compatible versions. They charge only for support. You can get the identical product with no support absolutely free.
- spullara 7y agoOracle Java 8 is no longer freely supported. Switch to OpenJDK and move on if you don't need their support.
- turk73 7y agoI am at a Fortune 500 co. and they require OpenJDK only and I'm sure that has to do with positioning the company for upcoming licensing fees from Oracle. Thing is, if push comes to shove we could just migrate off of Java completely because with containerization, do we really even care about the JVM? We get excellent portability via Docker containers now. Modern CI/CD and containerization can easily kill Java, having Oracle start charging would just be the final nail. I would be pretty happy if that happens, I'm sick of Java.
- cpach 7y agoWhile we’re at it, is there any sane way to run Java applets these days...? I know applets are obsolete a.f., but some legacy systems from large/important vendors still require them.
- vbezhenar 7y agoInternet Explorer should work with JRE 8.
- squirrelicus 7y agoIt never ceases to amaze me how the JDK and dotnet core have flipped in their relationship to the software engineering community. What was once open is closed. What was once closed is open.
- taftster 7y agoJava is as open as ever. Oracle is not in charge of Java and is not taking it closed source. They are a huge supporter of open source Java, contributing the most patches to the open source version. Oracle happens to have a paid subscription model as well, that helps to fund continued open source contributions. No doubt other companies will have (or have now) similar subscription models surrounding the open source platform.
- kelnos 7y agoJava is just as open as it always was. Oracle has been gradually moving itself away from being the sole source & driver of Java. OpenJDK is open and free, and is both community-supported and driven by several companies prominent in the Java ecosystem. Oracle JDK is based on it, and Oracle is adding proprietary features so they can make a buck. Honestly, I'd say the new situation is better than the old. Oracle no longer has the stranglehold over Java that they had since they bought Sun.
- badrabbit 7y agoCould be wrong but this has always been the case if the jdk/jre is not the very latest download?
- pjmlp 7y agoYep, since Sun days already, but lets not let that stand in the way of releasing some Oracle hate.
- pjmlp 7y agoUsual anti-Oracle FUD. Already during Sun days one needed to login for EOL versions of Java. JRE was EOL as per Java 9 release.
- severino 7y agoThis has always been like that. You can download the current version JRE, either from java.com or https://www.oracle.com/technetwork/java/javase/downloads/jdk12-downloads-5295953.html https://www.oracle.com/technetwork/java/javase/downloads/jdk..., where you can get the binaries just by accepting the license agreement. The same holds for the current version JDK. For older versions, login has always been required. So please, don't spread FUD like this.
- heelix 7y agoThe only JDK you might be able to download from them without needing an extended support license is JDK 12 - and that is only until October 16th. Every other JDK/JRE version, from 6u211 to 11.0.4 only has the patched versions available with a login. They might have had older releases still public, but those were a huge source of grief. 7u80 was the last public version, but 7u231 (if I remember right) is the latest release. You really, really don't want to be using those unpatched versions. Adopt OpenJDK has a great long term support release for v8 and v11 of the JDK/JRE. Free as in beer.
- pron 7y agoThat is because that version is intended for support customers. To get the JDK with a free, open-source license, download it here: http://jdk.java.net/ http://jdk.java.net/ (I work at Oracle on the JDK)