3 ms·
Indeed, although in this case it seems it was not fabricated. According to the Guardian article, the idea came from Geologist Scott Bryan: Bryan said the raft
by ddeck 7y ago
Indeed, although in this case it seems it was not fabricated. According to the Guardian article, the idea came from Geologist Scott Bryan:
Bryan said the raft will be the temporary home for billions of marine organisms. Marine life including barnacles, corals, crabs, snails and worms will tag along as it travels toward Australia and become a "potential mechanism for restocking the Great Barrier Reef".[0]
This was then more widely reported as "Scientists say..."
It appears Bryan is a geologist specializing in volcanology who has expertise in pumice rafts, but not in marine biology[1]. One would have hoped he would know better than to make such statements to the media.
[0] https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2019/aug/25/massive-pumice-raft-spotted-in-the-pacific-could-help-replenish-great-barrier-reef https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2019/aug/25/massive-...
[1] https://staff.qut.edu.au/staff/scott.bryan https://staff.qut.edu.au/staff/scott.bryan
- krisoft 7y agoI'm afraid your second link is not supporting your claim. He has expertise in pumice rafts and their effects on marine biology. Check out "Rapid, long-distance dispersal by pumice rafting" from him. I'm not an expert on the topic, but seems to be a widely cited work. Do you have some reason to disagree with his work or his conclusions?
- JohnJamesRambo 7y agoBut is that really going to “replenish the Great Barrier Reef?” That implies that the reef is just waiting for seeding by organisms for it to flourish and that is very likely not the case.