4 ms·
The US might benefit from some investment in Nickel-Iron batteries. These were invented by Edison in 1901. They have a basic service life of 20 years (as oppo
by stcredzero 16y ago
The US might benefit from some investment in Nickel-Iron batteries. These were invented by Edison in 1901. They have a basic service life of 20 years (as opposed to 3-5 for Li-ion) and can be stretched to 50 years with electrolyte replacement. The battery tech is worked out, but investments in manufacture and economies of scale would enable market access to a technology with lower cost than Li-ion. (Also, the materials used in NiFe batteries are cheap and available domestically. They are a bit challenged with regards to high currents, though.)
Wind and solar plants “introduce some additional variability that you don’t have with traditional thermal units,’’ Mr. Zaharuncik said. With a system that has a lot of renewable energy generators, he explained, “you need some other kind of resource that complements it. ‘’
I'm surprised that flywheels aren't a bigger deal because of wind and solar power. Why doesn't someone make a flywheel unit the size of a major appliance, incorporating inverters and regulating hardware, for home wind and solar?
- khafra 16y agoPerhaps safety issues[1]? [1]http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=309413 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=309413
- stcredzero 16y agoFlywheel safety isn't such a big deal if you can bury the flywheel chamber in your backyard. Decades ago, there were fiberglass flywheels whose fibers simply unraveled when they failed, becoming a mass of very hot fuzz.
- yardie 16y agoFlywheel technology were an area of research over a decade ago when battery research was still in its infancy. IIRC, GM had an electric car concept that had a huge fly wheel behind the cabin. But your options were slow, heavy (thus inefficient) flywheels or light, fast flywheels. And by fast I mean 100,000 RPM. At those speeds they were using Kevlar to keep it from flying apart, making it impractical because of the price of kevlar.
- AaronM 16y agoAt the last company I worked for, which was a manufacturing facility. They installed a giant flywheel as a line conditioning device. (We manufactured NAS, and it is terribly costly when a power outage interrupts 5 days worth of testing forcing you to start over). I think it gave us about 17-18 seconds of power, in the event of any brief interruptions in power (Most of the outages we received were 1-2 seconds in length)
- aristus 16y agoSome datacenters (eg the Miami IPX/NAP) use flywheels the size of large trucks to provide failover until the generators kick in. They are seriously scary machines up close.
- Symmetry 16y agoIf you're doing these on an industrial scale a liquid salt battery might be worth while.
- coryrc 16y agoNickel is not a cheap metal and NiFe batteries are not efficient[1]. Nickel is much more damaging to the environment to extract. LiFePO4 batteries have lifetimes exceeding 15 years (no one really knows how long yet -- they were invented in 1996). Their efficiency is well above 90%. Its raw material costs are less than NiFe. [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nickel-iron_battery http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nickel-iron_battery