3 ms·
I used to know someone who worked on missile guidance systems. He rationalised it as "I only care about the code." Then there was a war in the middle east and
by TheOtherHobbes 7y ago
I used to know someone who worked on missile guidance systems. He rationalised it as "I only care about the code."
Then there was a war in the middle east and there were TV images of dead and badly injured people being pulled out rubble on the news. They'd been put under the rubble by the missiles he had helped design.
He changed jobs not long after.
But it would be misleading to reduce this to a moral binary. He wasn't a bad person in most ways, and like most people who aren't bad people in most ways he ended up in that situation through a disinterest in anything outside of his domain, and also because he was allowing economics to do his moral thinking for him.
He was doing work that interested him, paying his bills, and keeping on top of the mortgage. What more can you ask of someone?
- smt88 7y agoI suppose the moral question here is, how much do you trust your employer (or country) to use your code only for good? If you're guiding missiles, I think you're naive to think you'll never guide missiles into innocent people. If you're working on Facebook, the question is whether you trust Zuckerberg's moral leadership. It was plausible to be unsure in the past, but at this point, you know he's going to do something unethical and post another "sorry-not-sorry" message online when he gets caught. You know your code will be misused, and that's on you now.
- wpietri 7y ago> What more can you ask of someone? To take responsibility for the effects of their actions? That doesn't seem like too much.