3 ms·
>If he feels bad, that's the point of guilt tripping and shaming. At least you're open about the fact that guilt tripping and shaming is not about trying to ch
by BeetleB 7y ago
>If he feels bad, that's the point of guilt tripping and shaming.
At least you're open about the fact that guilt tripping and shaming is not about trying to change behavior.
Feeling bad about it usually has the outcome of avoiding the person making them feel bad about it, not changing behavior. And while I don't have any hard scientific data, the consensus in the world of negotiation is that overt guilt tripping is often less effective than not discussing the topic at all (i.e. guilt tripping increases the chance the undesired behavior will occur).
>If you don't want to be political, there are plenty of other companies to work at where people won't force politics on you for working there.
Putting the particular case of Facebook aside, my recommendation is always to avoid people who force politics onto you because of where you work. They are usually the least objective.
- daveFNbuck 7y ago> At least you're open about the fact that guilt tripping and shaming is not about trying to change behavior. That's only true if you didn't read the next two sentences. My point was that feeling bad is the mechanism that guilt-trippers and shamers are trying to utilize. I'm sure guilt and shame don't work well in negotiations. I don't know whether that translates to shaping society or influencing your friends. Personally, I don't do it because that's not how I want to treat my friends.
- BeetleB 7y ago>That's only true if you didn't read the next two sentences. I understood it well. What we both agree on is that it will make them feel bad. What we disagree on is this statement of yours: >This will tend to make them more interested in leaving the company. Now I don't want to claim 0 correlation. There sometimes is a weak correlation. There is also often a negative correlation (they'll stay longer at Facebook with guilt tripping than with no peer pressure at all). I'm not an academic, so I don't have the studies at hand. >I'm sure guilt and shame don't work well in negotiations. I don't know whether that translates to shaping society or influencing your friends. It's a fallacy to treat negotiations as distinct from friendship. I think you're confusing bargaining with negotiations. You engage in negotiations with almost every person you interact with - friends, spouses, children, parents, coworkers, charities, etc. Want to have dinner with a friend? When and where? That's a negotiation. An ordinary person will negotiate a few times a week at a minimum. The discipline of negotiations encompass these interactions. Negotiations courses/books often spend time on how your negotiation strategy will impact your relationship with the other person, and which strategies may help or harm the relationship. They don't suggest one never use guilt tripping - they merely suggest not to use it if you want to maintain a relationship with the other person.