3 ms·
Ridership is up, but is traffic down? It doesn't matter how many people are using this service. What matters is which people are using it. Cities are realizi
by sandworm101 7y ago
Ridership is up, but is traffic down?
It doesn't matter how many people are using this service. What matters is which people are using it. Cities are realizing that most new transit schemes aren't getting people out of their cars. They are leeching people away from other forms of mass transit. Getting someone out of a bus and into a van is not a win.
What is needed is an actual competitor to the private car, something that can truly replace it. The buses in my area stop at 11pm, and the nearest passenger train is a hundred km away. Until that changes, if want to keep my job, I need to keep driving my car. Offering me a shuttle between my door and the bus stop means literally nothing if there is no bus to get.
- chrisseaton 7y agoLeeching people from busses into trains seems good, though?
- sandworm101 7y agoThat's an interesting question. The head of Ryanair used to talk about how air travel was sometimes lower carbon than the equivalent train journey (Ryanair flies to the smaller airports, and highspeed rail is far from zero carbon). There is certainly a tipping point where the train clearly wins, but there are also a great many areas where the slower and more direct bus service is probably best. This is doubly true in places like Vancouver that have been using electric buses for literally decades.
- cagenut 7y agoFirst of all, there is no chance outside of some absurd contrived scenario for a jet to have lower co2 emissions than a train. When a CEO says something that transparently bullshit they are obviously lying in their interest you really shouldn't do their lying for them by parroting it. Second, carbon dioxide (which I assume you were shorthanding as 'carbon') is not even half of the greenhouse-gas/radiative-forcing effect of air travel: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Environmental_impact_of_aviation#/media/File:Radiative_Forcing_in_Aviation_1992.png https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Environmental_impact_of_aviati... So even if this CEO was technically right, he'd still be wrong in terms of what actually matters.
- sandworm101 7y agoNo. He did not say that the jet burned less fuel. He was commenting that a highspeed rail journey, with the necessary connecting car/bus/light rail legs on each end, can sometimes require more carbon than a more direct aircraft flight. There are breaking points where an all-economy flight can be the most energy-efficient option. My home town (on an island) is a good example. I could take a direct flight to another city, or drive the 100's of KM by car+boat to the nearest passenger rail. And then I'd have to rent a car and drive several hundred more KM after stepping off the train. In such circumstances the direct aircraft connection is the lower-carbon option.
- cagenut 7y agoI see what you're doing even if you don't. This level of nitpickery and contrarian noise is the functional equivalent of denying reality. All you're doing is sewing doubt and throwing sand in the gears to make it harder for everyone else. You cannot continue to apply marginal optimization tactics to a solve for zero problem. It is simply a failure to understand and address reality.
- rayiner 7y agoBuilding HSR lines is extremely carbon intensive and only extremely busy lines will offset the cost of their construction: https://www.citylab.com/transportation/2011/11/how-green-high-speed-rail/492 https://www.citylab.com/transportation/2011/11/how-green-hig.... You basically need a line to be as busy as the northeast corridor in the US, otherwise you’re underwater carbon wise.
- redis_mlc 7y ago> there is no chance outside of some absurd contrived scenario Well, in the USA, any train that is interstate is required to be built as if it was a freight train, even if it's only carrying passengers 1 mile. And jet engines get 1% more efficient per year. So it is possible that a jet airplane will be more fuel-efficient for interstate travel than a train at some point.
- 7y ago
- MithrilTuxedo 7y agoSeattle mass transit usage is up. I ride the bus where these vans are operating, to/from the Rainier Beach light rail stop. There are a slew of neighborhoods in this area underserved by buses where these vans fill the gap. What is needed, to my mind, is a lowered expectation of what a private car is going to be able to do for you in a densely populated city. I got picked up from work Friday to go on a trip and after an hour we'd only gone eight blocks.
- ijidak 7y agoIsn't Uber pool accomplishing this? The Uber pool model seems to be the most realistic gap filler between mass transit and an individual automobile. Rather than mass transit buying vehicles specifically to fill this gap, using the spare vehicular capacity of the car driving public seems like an efficiency. For example, my wife and I, in Las Vegas, now have only one car because Uber fills those rare moments where a second car is absolutely necessary. And Uber pool is even more cost effective, while also being a higher utilization of the car the Uber driver is driving.