3 ms·
The maximum interest rate at which the bank is (nearly) guaranteed to make profit off my account balance can be calculated by an algorithm. Running that algorit
by wongarsu 7y ago
The maximum interest rate at which the bank is (nearly) guaranteed to make profit off my account balance can be calculated by an algorithm. Running that algorithm once a month and using it to set the bank's interest rate would be an interesting model that doesn't directly involve humans.
- JumpCrisscross 7y ago> The maximum interest rate at which the bank is (nearly) guaranteed to make profit off my account balance can be calculated by an algorithm This is a good way to blow up a bank.
- wongarsu 7y agoI'm not saying the algorithm is trivial, as it has to take long-term factors into account, as well as the reaction of the market to the new interest rate, and of course add safety and profit margins. It would be quite a bit of work, but it's well aligned with the core-competency of banks.
- JumpCrisscross 7y ago> It would be quite a bit of work, but it's well aligned with the core-competency of banks It is, and it’s difficult. Perhaps fundamentally impossible, given it would have to predict consumers’ tastes and preferences to estimate B2C companies’ creditworthiness. Rates are negotiated instruments, a combination of the return on safe assets today, the risk of that rate changing tomorrow, and the credit profile and availability of borrowers. There is no known algorithm which can robustly balance these variables. If it were discovered, it would be worth billions, perhaps more, and fundamentally change finance. Pretty much every crisis has a story about smart people thinking they’ve solved this problem in some narrow niche of the economy and then being shown disastrously wrong.
- big_chungus 7y ago> Perhaps fundamentally impossible It can't be done by one individual for the whole market, but the invisible hand does a pretty good job. The principle of a market as a whole establishing prices, rates, etc. is widely accepted.
- QuesnayJr 7y agoIf you calculated that interest rate, it would be negative. Ten-year German bonds have a negative interest rate. Cash savings pay less than bonds, so money in a cash account pays an even-more negative rate. The only way banks could pay a higher interest rate would be to bear more risk, but that's how you get a banking crisis.