12 ms·
Californians can buy cheap rocket parts from Alabama without worrying about exchange rate risk just as Germans can buy cheap olive oil from Greece. However fis
by gumby 7y ago
Californians can buy cheap rocket parts from Alabama without worrying about exchange rate risk just as Germans can buy cheap olive oil from Greece.
However fiscal transfers between the two states (I.e. taxes -> welfare payments, labor standards etc) mean that the cheaper goods are more likely to be up to standards and that Alabamans can buy California almonds and Roku boxes. (This is one way cutting welfare hurts capitalism). The EU has no such fiscal mechanism thus the process drifts out of a crisis.
Germany’s Länderausgleich is actually more extensive than the US’s, which has made its economy so strong for so long, yet the country is loath to extend its benefits (much of which would flow back to Germany!) to the rest of the EU.
- benj111 7y ago"labor standards" These exist EU wide you know. Additionally money is allocated to poorer regions to develop industries, not welfare payments but still wealth redistribution.
- gumby 7y agoIndeed that’s why I explicitly said “The EU has no such fiscal mechanism...” Edit: oh I see that poor editing on my part implied that labour standards were part of fiscal transfers, a nonsensical connection. My apologies) As a former EU resident of two different countries I have benefitted from EU labor laws. Regional development funds are practically below the noise floor as a part of the Zone’s GDP (and are in fact EU-wide, not just eurozone-wide). Most of the money is squandered (not necessarily through corruption, just lack of macro efficacy) as it’s such a small amount it gets little attention.
- Despegar 7y agoI'm amused that we're getting downvoted when our comments should be at the top of this thread.
- gumby 7y agoI know, it’s not like I wrote anything unorthodox. Most criticism of the Euro from both right and left come from claims that it is not an optimal currency area primarily due to lack of fiscal integration. I assume the downvoting comes from economics being a popular topic on which people like to opine whether or not they understand it (insert joke here about economists being subject to this rule as well)
- samsonradu 7y agoIt has been proposed indeed, the Surplus Recycling Mechanism: https://www.yanisvaroufakis.eu/2011/02/09/what-is-a-surplus-recycling-mechanism-an-idea-going-back-to-bretton-woods/ https://www.yanisvaroufakis.eu/2011/02/09/what-is-a-surplus-...
- michaelt 7y agoSeems to me it'd be tough to sell Germans on Länderausgleich to Greece without much greater European integration. After all, the US is a single country, with common news reporting, a common language, common political systems and parties, common tax enforcement and so on. I mean, if an Alabamian thinks that Californians are all surf bums he can find employment statistics for both states gathered under identical standards, read press coverage in his language, and even move there if he feels like it, as he already knows the language. It seems unlikely the EU will ever achieve that level of integration.
- gumby 7y agoRemember that over the past couple of centuries the US went through several explicit processes of integration specifically to overcome the barriers (including linguistic!) you correctly describe for the EU. > It seems unlikely the EU will ever achieve that level of integration. I disagree but it's unlikely to happen in my lifetime.
- JetSpiegel 7y ago> Seems to me it'd be tough to sell Germans on Länderausgleich to Greece without much greater European integration. Hopefully this threat of recession will light a fire under the correct asses.