4 ms·
But how much of the economy can be truly competitive? I mean, from autos to laundry detergent there seems to be very mature products and little room for innovat
by chiefalchemist 7y ago
But how much of the economy can be truly competitive? I mean, from autos to laundry detergent there seems to be very mature products and little room for innovation. The result is either compete on price (that has limits) or assume a sense of parity and coast (in a way where you don't muck it up).
I'm not claiming all is discovered. We've reached the end of history. That's foolish. But for a fair amount of the economy competition/innovation is simply not possible.
- gpresot 7y agoI would disagree. Conditions keep changing. keeping to the sectors you mentioned. Tesla and electric cars are clearly examples of innovation that was favoured by external elements (e.g growing concerns for climate / environment, increase of pollution in urban areas). In laundry detergents (and also personal care) , the big companies are racing to acquire small brands that were faster than them to go to market with more natural cleaning products (less chemicals, no parabens, traceable / sustainable ingredients...). Large Consumer Goods (P&G, Nestle...) companies are facing a backlash by consumers that are shifting to more local / smaller companies. This is more difficult in the automotive industry (there are some massive investment in assets that are simply impossible for companies that are not well funded). EDIT: I can not think of one segment where there are less products today than there were 30 years ago. Even when companies become fewer, they don't stop expanding and innovating the portfolio. The penalty for doing so would be either some competitor selling the same for less or selling something better.
- NeedMoreTea 7y agoThe problem with many of the consumer brands, particularly cleaning and laundry, is the sheer amount of pointless innovation. Convincing a generation that liquid soap is better than a simple bar, despite being vastly more wasteful in both product and packaging. Same for laundry in working to replace a cardboard box full of powder with all sorts of tablets, sachets and gels in plastic boxes. Or new recipes that replace original ingredients with super cheap palm oil or HFCS - sold for the same price. It's endless, and brands have burnt 95% of their former goodwill by being too damn clever for their own good. Unless consumers are, in aggregate, entirely idiotic, buying up dozens of small brands won't pay off as they hope. We've had decades of large companies buying up brand and niche leaders and completely ruining the product in just a year or two. Leaves them cynically trading on the name only and damn near profiteering. Surely people are wising up to this finally? Success of discounters like Aldi and Lidl against major brands says they are.
- chiefalchemist 7y ago> "Surely people are wising up to this finally? Success of discounters like Aldi and Lidl against major brands says they are." Right. But the products themselves are essentially the same. And as mentioned, there can be competitive pricing, but that has its limits. So back to my originsl question: What percentage of the economy can be fully and truly competitive? Or, have we, for a fair amount of the economy "maxed out"?
- rukittenme 7y ago> What percentage of the economy can be fully and truly competitive? You need to give us your definition of competitive. The grand parent already answered the examples you provided. The competing products being "essentially the same" does not detract from their competitiveness.
- mises 7y agoThis is especially true. In fact, a "perfect competition" actually specifies homogeneous goods. Technically, differentiation (i.e. no longer just powder in a cardboard box) is what enables all the screwiness being discussed.
- NeedMoreTea 7y agoI'd say a good part has passed its limit and the results we see are proof of that. To stick with laundry, of all the brands seen in a supermarket, they are all made by just two multinationals. Washing isn't better or easier than when I lived with my first partner, in our first flat in the eighties. I can't ever remember anyone in all that time expressing a wish for better detergents, or struggling to get things clean enough. They've worked, essentially perfectly - or at least well enough, for nearly the whole time since WW2, maybe 50s or 60s on. Washing machines, thanks to chasing low water and temperatures, have got markedly worse on the other hand. Nowadays overfilling a machine, even slightly, results in the wash deteriorating - machines didn't used to care in the slightest about that. Keep packing stuff in while it still fits and get perfect results. I have to wonder how many extra "eco" loads are run in order to wash the same household's weekly wash with a modern machine compared to an older, "wasteful" one. I wonder if per lb of washing if it is actually more wasteful. It lasts perhaps 10%-20% of the life of a machine made in the 70s or 80s. How does that impact per wash? We've had a lot of fake brands and competition just to move balance in the markets from 50:50 to 51:49. More complexity, higher pricing, less competition and less for the consumer. Billions advertising these fake innovations to achieve, well, nothing but a hair's movement in favour of P&G or not. Back handed arrangements in the way supermarkets sell premium shelf spots, end of aisle displays and supplier priority again takes away from real competition and just leaves the appearance of it. The simple soap, from the decades old small maker, becomes harder and harder to find despite working just as well, being popular, and generating perhaps 1% of the waste of a year's bottles of shower or hand gels. Eventually it disappears because of Tesco/Walmart and P&G/Unilver shelf selling arrangements not because it was wasn't selling, crap or superseded. Car manufacture still has dozens (just) of manufacturers. There is still real competition and differentiation, despite no end of emissions and safety legislation. Most categories today are like detergents, selling us fake innovation, differentiation and disruption and forcing us to more profitable but profligate and wasteful ways, not like cars where there actually still some real choices. Even down to the commodities like vegetables - we're sold a 1kg bag, rather than loose buying just the few we might need for a week, there's infinitely fewer varieties but so many more (fake) options. We're all markedly worse off as a result.
- chiefalchemist 7y agoBut. Remove electric and its the same car. And yes. Tesla. But again, what % of the economy is that? I'm not saying there isn't change and innovation here and there. There is. But on the whole what percentage of the economy can be fully and truly competitive?
- gpresot 7y agoIt depends on what you consider innovation. There are the big leaps, certainly (combustion engine, electric engine), but also the small increments: seat belts, automatic gears, runflat tyres, ABS, traction control, speed control... And these smaller innovations contribute to people picking one model or brand instead of another. Innovation also means producing the same thing at a lower cost (different process, better equipment, automation...). All this is competition. The Toyota quality management process was a revolution that led to japanese car companies becoming world leaders, with the same cars that everybody else were selling. Autonomous driving may be doing the same for some brands now.
- majewsky 7y ago> Remove electric and it's the same car. What's your point? "Remove all innovations and nothing has changed for the better" is just tautological.
- tonyedgecombe 7y agoJust take a look at the poor broadband provision in the US to see the effects of low competition. Given a chance companies will become fat and lazy and disregard their customers.
- adamsea 7y agoOn the other hand companies in competitive markets often become fat and lazy and disregard their customers as well.
- Ididntdothis 7y agoNot if there is competition. Otherwise they would lose market share quickly. Or not?
- chiefalchemist 7y agoI have Comcast and Fios in my market, I can't say they are competitive. They are like airlines. They operate with a sense of parity. There's no incentive for them to be competitive. In fact, if one of them had too much market share might find themselves in legal heat. That said, my original question is: But how much of the economy can be truly competitive?
- flerchin 7y agoFios and Spectrum in my area. The price is about half what coworkers pay less than 10 miles away where only one has built out. It's interesting that you think airlines aren't competitive. IMO, they're super competitive. New upstarts like Spirit don't show up everyday, but watch what happens to prices when a new market is opened up by Southwest, for example. No one knows what percent of the economy can be truly competitive, but it's probably something like half. I'm hard pressed to find a single area of the economy that doesn't have competitive private entities.
- majewsky 7y ago
- seer 7y agoI would think that this comment could have been made in any point in history and a lot of people would agree. I just watched a documentary on Henry Ford - in his time making cars was a “solved” problem - you’d have various highly trained and talented teams of craftsmen that would build a car using simple but versatile tools. It all worked rather well in europe and america, and is a model that has been around throughout most of human history - a “proven and reliable way” to do things. And here comes Ford and invents mass production as we know it by applying principles already present in the military to the civilian sector. Not precisely new but applied and perfected in a different area. Changed the world. Today I can see similar changes - people from the software world disrupting traditional industries by applying new methods learned in a different field. Sure a lot of the time they fail spectacularly and get the “I told you so” treatment, but there are some notable winners. Look at what Elon is doing for example. So I’m rather hopeful to be honest - there is so much stress, unhappiness and efficiency problems present in the world, that I really doubt we’ll run out of things to do anytime soon.
- chiefalchemist 7y agoPlease re-read my question. I'm not doubting there are pockets of change, innovation, etc. That exists. The question is: What percentage of the economy can be truly competitive? And how much is closer to commodities wrapped in some semi-fancy marketing? How many investors / VCs are willing to solve the problem of (say): How to make a better kitchen chair? And improve the manufacturing there of?
- majewsky 7y agoFWIW, you just described Ikea. Their whole business model is shaving pennies off of each item by iterating on the manufacturing, shipping and selling processes.
- chiefalchemist 7y agoFine. But who else? Or have they cornered their market? And again, that % of the economy is this; is truly competitive??
- davidivadavid 7y agoWhen there seems to be little room for innovation it generally means we need to "refactor the tech tree", i.e. find a technology that qualitatively replaces the incumbent ones instead of making marginal improvements. The current narratives for autos is self driving cars and more walkable/bikable urban design. For laundry detergent there's probably textile innovation that makes them require less/no washing. Etc. What parts of the economy do you think can't innovate?
- harimau777 7y agoFor sake of argument, I'd argue that most innovations in textiles since automated weaving have been steps backwards in the name of cost. The only fabrics that I can think of that are clear improvements over natural alternatives are ballistic nylon, kevlar, nomex, elastic, and maybe synthetic fleece (although I'd still argue that boiled wool is a superior alternative). I guess it just seems to me that a lot of the "innovation" is really just sacrificing quality in the name of price.
- ghaff 7y agoNatural fibers are great--including ones like Merino Wool that aren't modern innovations although a lot of the way it's used mostly is. But if I look through my outdoor gear and clothing, there have been huge strides in just the past few decades. Not all of the new stuff is great. And some definitely trades durability for light weight (or cost). But overall, what I can buy today is pretty great compared to what I had in Boy Scouts even if some of the older clothing fabrics (like boiled wool as you say) still work quite well.
- jnordwick 7y agoFinding the balance between quality and price is innovative. It is extremely difficult. But in the end it means more people across the globe get more and better quality clothes. You can always go pay for higher end clothing. Nothing stops you expect... price. Lol
- harimau777 7y ago
- thomascgalvin 7y ago> I mean, from autos to laundry detergent there seems to be very mature products and little room for innovation. Telsa would beg to differ. They popularized the idea that an electric vehicle was even possible, and now you can but not only a Tesla, but other EVs like the Hyundai Kona. Then you've got things like self-driving, which automakers are scrambling to be the first to crack. Or consider the various safety features. My car will yell at me if I get too close to the vehicle in front of me, or if I try to back out of a parking spot and the radar detects someone coming my way, or if what my hands are doing to the steering wheel makes the computer think I'm starting to doze off. All of these are relatively recent innovations.