3 ms·
> If we put ethnicity ahead of national origin America can’t claim anything to its name. Period. It's silly to put ethnicity ahead of national origin, though,
by BalinKing 7y ago
> If we put ethnicity ahead of national origin America can’t claim anything to its name. Period.
It's silly to put ethnicity ahead of national origin, though, since one of America's biggest qualities it that it is a melting pot.
This feels like saying "If we put learning curve ahead of type safety Haskell can't claim anything to its name. Period." It's true, but kinda vacuous.
- asveikau 7y agoBut that particular super-famous German who lived in Princeton, NJ is also recognized as a German physicist. To say he was already quite accomplished when he left Europe would be an understatement. Personally, I think if an immigrant of descendant of immigrants invents something prominent, it is fair for both countries to be proud of the accomplishment, and share that enthusiasm. It doesn't, or shouldn't hurt anyone. If anything, you are affirming accomplishment, not putting other people down.
- usrusr 7y ago> it is fair for both countries to be proud of the accomplishment Depending on the reasons for emigration, it might be fair to replace most of that pride with "dann, could have been 'ours'".
- asveikau 7y agoRight, well, Germany for thankfully temporary reasons wasn't exactly kind to that particular guy when he needed to flee to Princeton. But other than not repeating those horrible conditions, the next step is to simply be proud of the accomplishment. In this case of algebra, Baghdad isn't the Baghdad of back then, nor Persia the Persia of then, all the people of the era are no longer with us, so what does it matter really? But hey, algebra is pretty cool. And Arabs/Persians happen to feel good about it. Good for them.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]