2 ms·
To be fair, I don't think humans have any way of verifying that you're trustworthy. Anyone can send email from your email address. Anyone can fake a driver's
by jrockway 7y ago
To be fair, I don't think humans have any way of verifying that you're trustworthy. Anyone can send email from your email address. Anyone can fake a driver's license. Anyone can get a phone number that meets their criteria. Knowing who someone is on the Internet is nearly impossible. Knowing whether or not to trust someone once you know who they are is nearly impossible.
There is no system of human <-> corporation trust in the real world. The best we have, maybe, is some record of how often you pay bills on time.
Tech companies kind of have to have these automated bans, because it's easy to create new identities on the Internet and the government doesn't care that you're defrauding a tech company. If you defraud a bank, the government pays the full cost of prosecuting and incarcerating you. If you spam Discord... nobody cares. It's Discord's problem, not the taxpayers' problem. So they really have no choice here. The world sucks. Get a helmet.
Having said that, banning people with a valid authentication token because of their IP address is simply the wrong algorithm. I can see why you might rate limit authentication attempts over Tor... but if you get your username/password right on the first attempt and provide the correct second factor... you should probably rate limit that valid session with a per-session rate limit key, rather than a per network endpoint key. (The era of IP address based rate limiting dies with IPv6 anyway, so they'll need a better plan someday.)
- vageli 7y ago> To be fair, I don't think humans have any way of verifying that you're trustworthy. Anyone can send email from your email address. Anyone can fake a driver's license. Anyone can get a phone number that meets their criteria. Knowing who someone is on the Internet is nearly impossible. Knowing whether or not to trust someone once you know who they are is nearly impossible. American banks seem to have no issue with this.