3 ms·
Hang on, the problem Goodman has is not that she's not needed where she is: she has a job. Her problem is that there are literally no houses there that she can
by carapace 7y ago
Hang on, the problem Goodman has is not that she's not needed where she is: she has a job. Her problem is that there are literally no houses there that she can afford to rent or buy.
- esotericn 7y agoThe free market 'economy' answer to this is that if she can't afford to rent a house or flat, she's not needed. Absurd? Of course. If that were true, then there would be no supermarkets or corner shops or petrol stations or chicken shops or.... etc, in the entirety of London, a city of 10 million. Because no-one wants them right, there's no demand, the workers aren't needed. Hang on...
- randomdata 7y ago1. Why is that absurd? A company that can only find customers for a widget at $1, that costs $2 to make, continuing to produce that widget because it is 'needed' is the only absurd idea I see here. Clearly the widget isn't needed, even if people are willing to buy it at below cost of production. Doing a job that costs more to do than what is paid back in compensation is no different than our hypothetical widget. 2. Most people in low-wage jobs are subsidized by someone else with a higher income (spouse, parent, etc.). They don't need high wages in order to afford to live. Thanks to that subsidization, they can afford to work for much less than someone who would have to live unsubsidized, while still maintaining a comfortable lifestyle. Those who are not fortunate enough to be subsidized have to compete against them. The mere fact that there is competition means that someone is going to lose, which means someone isn't needed. 3. Price is, as always, a function of supply and demand. If more people were needed for the jobs you mention than is currently being supplied, price would fundamentally rise, shrinking the affordability gap that exists for those who are unsubsidized in low-wage jobs. The jobs are low-wage quite simply because there are more people willing and able to do the job than there are jobs. Which, again, means that people aren't needed. Finally, this is not an all or nothing situation. Not needing some people does not equate to not needing all people. The role of the economy, and price by extension, is to find that balance.
- randomdata 7y agoI'm not sure I understand the distinction you are trying to make? Having a job is not the same as being needed in an economy. As we know from economics, demand decreases when price increases. Conversely, demand increases when price decreases. Goodman is able to find a job at below the cost of production, so to speak, but if the price were to rise to a sustainable level, nobody would be willing to hire anymore. After all, if people were willing to hire at a higher price, the higher price would already be paid out. Any business can find customers producing widgets for free. Guaranteed. The hard part is finding customers willing to pay the cost of production + tidy profit in order to show that the market is actually in need of said widget. All Goodman is proving is the former; not brining in enough money to cover the actual cost of providing the job.
- carapace 7y ago> Having a job is not the same as being needed in an economy. Well, you have to define your context. In Communist Russia there were a lot of un-economical jobs, eh? To me it seems clear that there is demand for housing that the economic & political system in which Goodman finds herself is failing to supply. You seem to be saying that there is a dearth of jobs that pay enough money to cover the actual cost of providing the jobs. In that context, I'm saying, let's reduce that overhead. Rather than paying more we could reduce the actual cost of providing the job by building more houses. That's the whole point of the OP: we stopped building houses that people could afford and now there are people who can't afford housing. To me the question is why? Why don't we build more housing? Many folks point to "NIMBYism" but I suspect (IANAEconomist) that the real problem is just the tension between cities-as-living-places vs. cities-as-investment-vehicles. BTW... > As we know from economics, demand decreases when price increases. That's merely dogma. It's a common mistake to set prices too low. When I worked for an online marketplace we saw this all the time: people could raise prices and sell more volume. The same piece of jewelry that gathered dust at $15 would sell right away at $45.