3 ms·
I find the argument that 5G is at all unsafe on a pole to be a bit silly. I think there are a couple of much more serious issues: 1. Is a millimeter-wave trans
by amluto 7y ago
I find the argument that 5G is at all unsafe on a pole to be a bit silly. I think there are a couple of much more serious issues:
1. Is a millimeter-wave transmitter in a phone safe? The power output is moderately high, and these wavelengths are absorbed near the surface of your skin or your cornea. Cellphones are held near faces all the time. So I’d be much more concerned about using a 5G phone than about living near a 5G tower.
2. The 5G wavelengths May interfere with weather radar. I think that good weather forecasts are generally more important than cat videos.
- stefan_ 7y agoNo one is even putting millimeter-wave transmitters in phones right now. But the more obvious point is that millimeter-wave 5G can only work with beamforming, and a beam that is going through your head where it is fully, entirely, fucking completely absorbed not a millimeter in, well, that's not going to yield a lot of throughput.
- sipjca 7y agoUm... Yes they are. The Galaxy S10 5G has a mmW radio in it that’s transmits mmW waves for the uplink. The 5G spec also requires certain protection when the UE (phone) Tx wave might go through tissue. But you’re correct that it doesn’t make a whole lot of sense to attempt to Tx/Rx on a beam pointed at your head since it will lead to drastically lower SNR
- EdwardDiego 7y ago> these wavelengths are absorbed near the surface of your skin or your cornea And they'd cause a... slight heating effect. That's about it. So yeah, if you held your voice transmitting phone directly to your face for several decades, you might create enough tissue damage to up the cancer risk. But then the radio engineers I used to work with climbed radio towers with microwave emitters putting out far far far more energy than a cellphone, and their only rule was "don't stick your head or crotch in front of a microwave transmitter as you're climbing up".
- 420codebro 7y agoI hope that was a long time ago (RF safety). Now a days most places I have seen (towers and the like) have very clear marked boundaries of "DO NOT STEP PAST THIS POINT WHEN RF EMITTER IS IN OPERATION" type warnings. I believe these are all certified by a RF site survey analysis AFTER the site is dialed in (positioned) to understand the exact radiation pattern and drop-off points. While the energy is pretty much harmless even 5 or 10 feet away from the initial radiation point, you definitely don't want to risk it by potentially cooking yourself when only a few inches away...
- PGenes 7y agoI find your argument a bit silly. Are you suggesting that if A is less safe than B we should not worry about B? Seems we should worry about both!