7 ms·
San Francisco Bans Cashless Stores
- crb002 7y agoSo they install one self pay cash box? Not a big deal, and probably required for ADA. Not all seniors have access to electronic payment.
- mamon 7y agoSeniors or not, the most important thing to me is this: cash is issued by the government, and can be used without incurring any additional cost. Credit cards require you to sign contract with a bank, which is a private company, that makes money on every transaction. Government should never force you to sign a contract with a private entity, for any reason, so if they ever want us to go cashless, then I would expect they provide government-issued, free of charge credit/debit card for everyone first.
- comex 7y agoBut the law in question isn’t about the government requiring people to go cashless; it’s about whether private businesses (stores) are allowed to require their customers to go cashless.
- chelovek89 7y agoReceiving cash does have a cost, it requires you to either have an employee to handle it or a machine, someone to install and do maintenance on your register or cash machine, and armored cars to transport your cash to the bank.
- athms 7y agoOnly coins are issued by the government. Paper notes are issued by the Federal Reserve.
- kozak 7y agoI pay electronically almost everywhere, but I do recognize that cash payments are a basic human right. Going 100% cashless opens doors to all sorts of monopoly/distopia scenarios.
- conanbatt 7y ago> , but I do recognize that cash payments are a basic human right Is it a human right to be able to pay with any kind of cash, or just from some governments?
- ploika 7y agoNot a human right as such, but it's the law pretty much everywhere in the world. A shop refusing to accept legal tender seem pretty brazenly illegal to me.
- crazygringo 7y agoIt may seem illegal to you but no, it's actually generally not illegal. E.g. in the US specifically, US bills say "legal tender for all debts", which means it's illegal not to accept cash once a debt is incurred. But in most places a business owner is perfectly free to not create the opportunity for customer debt in the first place, i.e. not sell something -- whether based on form of payment ("We don't accept Amex") or quantity ("limit 5 per customer") etc.
- athms 7y agoYou are wrong about US legal tender. You have to know about the history of currency in the United States to fully grasp why those words are there. The simple explanation is the Coinage Act of 1965, Section 31 U.S.C. 5103[1], entitled "Legal tender," states: "United States coins and currency (including Federal reserve notes and circulating notes of Federal reserve banks and national banks) are legal tender for all debts, public charges, taxes, and dues." Coins are issued by the US Mint (Treasury Department). Paper money is issued by the Federal Reserve, not part of the US government, but the paper itself is printed by the Bureau of Engraving and Printing (Treasury Department). This statute means that all United States money as identified above are a valid and legal offer of payment for debts when tendered to a creditor. There is, however, no federal statute mandating that a municipality, organization, or person must accept currency or coins as payment for goods and/or services. Businesses are free to develop their own policies on whether or not to accept cash unless there is a state law which says otherwise. There was a time in the United States when different forms of currency were available and considered legal tender, including some issued by the states, both individually and via the Confederacy. The original Coinage Act of 1792 made both silver and gold forms of legal tender, and people could come to any US Mint and have their bullion turned into coins.
- _uy6i 7y agoUsually laughing at SF regulations - but this is eminently sensible - wish they had added a printed receipt as well
- aplummer 7y agoThe problem here is that there isn’t a non-private-enterprise privacy sensitive (although accessible with appropriate warrants etc) cashless money system IMO. Cash enables so many problems in the world I’ll be happy to see the end of it.
- tinus_hn 7y agoAll that darned privacy! If you have nothing to hide, you have nothing to fear.
- aplummer 7y agoI’m saying it would need to be private, but still able to prevent money laundering, payments for sex trafficking, drug trade, weapons trade. I’m aware such a thing doesn’t exist and may never, but this would be the ideal state IMO.
- throwaway34241 7y agoI agree. I understand the motivation to not have un-banked people locked out of the economy (although I don't know how big a problem that is in San Francisco yet - if it's only a couple experimental checkout-less stores it doesn't seem like a huge deal). But maybe a better eventual solution to that would be for everybody to have access to some basic banking services (and some sort of electronic payments). I think many countries provide it at post offices.
- paulddraper 7y ago> it would need to be private, but still able to prevent money laundering That's like the big screen TV that is small enough to for in your purse. Let's not pretend both these things are possible.
- aplummer 7y agoI’m an optimist that it’s possible. There are systems that are private but for legitimate government requirements with sensible public oversight. Maybe not in your jurisdiction, that would vary more than just about anything.
- ummonk 7y agoNow can we please also stop the cops from confiscating cash if they find more than a certain amount in a person’a vehicle? People shouldn’t be penalized for using legal tender.
- CaptainZapp 7y agoI really don't mean to be glib, but really: Only in America. Sure, you may have a hard time opening a bank account with half a million unexplained cash, but just confiscate somebody's life savings, especially when poor, unbanked and possibly black is a very American concept. In any other civilized place the onus is on the authorities to prove that the money is dirty. Not the other way 'round.
- erikpukinskis 7y agoNot just America: Columbia, DRC, PRC, Saudi Arabia... lots of places!
- CaptainZapp 7y agoWell, yeah, but civilized countries. While you could argue that Columbia and PRC fall into those brackets, those are nevertheless countries with a high occurrence of corruption.
- Pinckney 7y agoThe UK does it too: https://www.theguardian.com/society/2010/apr/25/prostitution-police-ecp-gangs https://www.theguardian.com/society/2010/apr/25/prostitution... > In November 2008, 20 police officers broke down Finch's front door and searched her house, taking £700 from her purse that she says had been put aside to pay the mortgage. Her laptop computer, mobile phone, driving licence and passport were also taken. No receipt was given. > Under the Proceeds of Crime Act, the police keep 25% of any assets confiscated from raids, the Crown Prosecution Service keeps another 25%, and the Inland Revenue the rest. http://prostitutescollective.net/wp-content/uploads/2017/07/Prostitution-What-You-Need-to-Know.pdf http://prostitutescollective.net/wp-content/uploads/2017/07/... > The burden of proof is reversed so people have to prove that any money they have was not earned through “criminal activity”
- ben_jones 7y agoI disagree that every store must accept cash. Life-impacting transactions such as grocers and transportation sure, but if a ritzy boutique or Apple store wants to make things more streamlined by only accepting card so be it. It’s better as a customer. I’m also wary of what I would consider to be ADA-styled protections for the Homeless by forcing businesses to accommodate them in increasingly fringe ways (IMO the rally cry for cash accepting stores WAS that it would hurt the homeless otherwise). Already in San Francisco the homeless are not prosecuted for petty crimes and receive free health services via frequent use of emergency care facilities. I worry the increased privileges for the homeless will attract more homeless to San Francisco, a city which has already proved it cannot alleviate the problem.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- guelo 7y agoThank goodness for the homeless for preventing at least some of the people that don't like looking at poor people from moving here.
- closeparen 7y agoThis comment is perfect San Francisco. We welcome the homeless as props that reinforce our moral superiority for welcoming them. More extreme or visible distress, behavior further outside social norms, etc. suits us even better. But God forbid we make any tradeoff whatsoever to actually improve their situations or bring behavior within norms. Please, let's bring in as many migrants as possible who don't like looking at poor people, then we might actually do something about poverty.
- guelo 7y agoI was responding to a comment that had the idea that we shouldn't do anything to benefit the homeless because it might attract more homeless. But I'm the one that doesn't want to improve their situation.
- beatgammit 7y agoCan we get sales tax to be included in the price on the shelf? The main reason I don't use cash is because I have having change, and sales tax always ends up with me having odd change. In Oregon, I use cash a lot more often because prices tend to avoid weird change. Some restaurants include tax on the shelf price ($3 for hotdog instead of $2.99 + tax or whatever), and if that were more common, I might forgo credit/debit cards.