4 ms·
The explanation is more simple: 1. Russia 2. Kazakhstan Both charge Chinese trains many times more than their own rate. All those mind boggling subsidies bas
by baybal2 7y ago
The explanation is more simple:
1. Russia
2. Kazakhstan
Both charge Chinese trains many times more than their own rate. All those mind boggling subsidies basically translate into handing out free money to them for hauling air.
And even if they were to be billed fairly, both Russian and Kazakhstani railways are both living from bailout to bailout themselves as:
1. Rail infrastructure is falling apart without a single major upgrade since the collapse of the Union
2. Rail is a patently bottomless watering hole for the bureaucrats running it
3. Most of money on the rail is spent on maintenance of unprofitable, and deeply underused routes god knows where in order to solicit more bailout money
4. Everything on Russian rail is done in the most inefficient way possible, also in order to solicit more bailouts. It is 2019, and Russia still uses human signallers, wooden ties, and sand ballast. Even passenger cars are still heated with firewood.
- magicsmoke 7y agoIsn't another branch of the rail system supposed to run south through Iran? What are the conditions on that branch like?
- kposehn 7y agoThey’re ok. Iranian rail is in rough shape. Most locomotives are older US-built EMD engines that they’re maintaining with smuggled or home-grown parts, or newer Siemens or Alston engines that are less reliable but also not worn down. China does want to have a standard gauge line through Afghanistan, Iran and Turkey. But it is proving hard to accomplish and the terrain is very rough. It would eliminate break of gauge as a problem though, but introduces lots of political and security issues as well.
- kposehn 7y agoEhhh. They do put a lot of money into the Russian network and same in Kazakhstan, but it is by no means efficient or well used capital. It’s the primary lifeline in Russia for goods/bulk as they don’t have sea lanes or major rivers through major agricultural areas (like the Mississippi). The state of the main trunk lines (moscow-Vladivostok, Baikal-Amur, etc) is actually quite good. But lots of secondary and “state-interest” lines are either in poor repair, wastes of money, or both.
- jcranmer 7y ago> as they don’t have sea lanes or major rivers through major agricultural areas (like the Mississippi). Russia does have major rivers (Don, Volga, Ob, Yenisei, and Lena), but the problem is they all go in the wrong direction--they're all north-south instead of east-west. In addition, they don't exactly lead to good port facilities, with the Don being the only one with an ice-free port connected to the world's oceans.
- kposehn 7y agoThanks - you explained it better than I :)
- Gustomaximus 7y agoWith point 4, while I'm assuming it's just inefficient, is it credible this is strategic? In the event of war and EMP or cyber attack their supply lines can function as normal type thing?
- kposehn 7y agoRussia looks more to the railroads for national security and employment, not profitability. They do work well enough, but in a war would not be nearly as effective as if they’d been properly managed in the first place.
- LargoLasskhyfv 7y agoThey have https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Russian_Railway_Troops https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Russian_Railway_Troops Beat that!
- Spooky23 7y agoPerhaps that’s true, but don’t give them that much credit. I did an internship in a state capitol in the 90s. One of the bizarre things were the elevator operators. The elevators were new, so these guys pushed buttons and accepted Christmas gifts for a living. They also eavesdropped and told people about interesting conversations... but their presence was patronage, not some grand scheme.