3 ms·
Why were you taken aback? From TFA: > "For many years, database users did not have to simultaneously understand the concept of isolation levels and consistency
by the_af 7y ago
Why were you taken aback? From TFA:
> "For many years, database users did not have to simultaneously understand the concept of isolation levels and consistency levels. Either a database system provided a correctness/performance tradeoff using isolation levels, or it provided a correctness/performance tradeoff using consistency levels, but never both. This resulted in a blurring of these concepts to the point that many people --- even experts in the field --- confuse isolation levels with consistency levels and vice versa. For example, this talk by a PhD student at Berkeley (incorrectly) refers to causal consistency as an “isolation level”. And this paper from well-known researchers at MIT and Harvard --- including a Turing Award laureate --- (incorrectly) call snapshot isolation and serializability “consistency” levels. I am confident that all these well-known researchers know the difference between isolation levels and consistency levels. However, as long as isolation and consistency could not be tuned within the same system, there has been little necessity for precision in the parlance around these terms."
So I wouldn't say it's uncommon or unexpected of non-experts to confuse the two concepts...
- cwojno 7y agoThis experience pre-dates the publication and my knowledge of the existence of this article. #timeTravelImpared
- the_af 7y agoHaha, but seriously. I didn't mean why you were taken aback given this article; I meant why you were taken aback given most developers do not understand this distinction, seldom have the real need to, and even experts are fuzzy on the details. Maybe I misread your tone, but to me it was like "programmers don't know how to program" (like in the FizzBuzz anecdotes).