8 ms·
Ever since the infamous "diversity memo," (which I disagree with,) I've gotten the impression that political discussions at Google turned toxic. A well run com
by gwbas1c 7y ago
Ever since the infamous "diversity memo," (which I disagree with,) I've gotten the impression that political discussions at Google turned toxic.
A well run company includes people with diverse political views points. A workplace that's hostile to anyone who leans right or leans left ultimately hurts diversity.
- nailer 7y agoMost of the memo was citations of studies of sex differences. People can either agree with the studies or disagree with the research used (it's totally cool with me if you do disagree with the research), but the idea that someone should be punished for talking about research at a company that extols "data driven decision making" as one of it's principles baffles me.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- gwbas1c 7y agoThe memo made some very poignant points, but then the author expressed some strange opinions that I would never attempt to defend. (Even worse, there was no reason to put some of these opinions in the memo.) But what's more scary is Google's official response to the diversity memo. (For context, Google instituted certain hiring policies to increase diversity, which the "diversity memo" questioned.) If you have the time, I suggest that you go reread the diversity memo and Google's response. Try to read them without taking sides. (It's hard.)
- manfredo 7y agoI read the memo before reading the media coverage. I was very surprised at how controversial it was. It's claims were pretty modest: it did not claim that women were any less capable than men at technology, and it repeatedly stated that innate differences likely do not account for all of the disparity between men and women in tech. All it argued was that just because a disparity exists we should not assume that it is evidence of discrimination, and that policies designed to engineer an outcome closer to 50/50 are likely creating discrimination rather than reducing it.
- gwbas1c 7y agoOk, now go re-read Google's official response. Note that they did not respond to "we should not assume that it is evidence of discrimination, and that policies designed to engineer an outcome closer to 50/50 are likely creating discrimination"
- manfredo 7y agoRight they cited "perpetuating harmful gender stereotypes". From which we can infer that Google believes that claiming that absent any discrimination or social pressure women would not work in tech at the same rates as men as "perpetuating gender stereotypes".
- threeseed 7y agoYou are misrepresenting their point. There are many reasons why women don't go into IT. And whilst you can look at at it holistically it is ultimately a personal decision. And so if you take that personal decision and instead make it about some gender stereotype e.g. they aren't physically suited then it discourages women from entering IT.
- manfredo 7y ago> And so if you take that personal decision and instead make it about some gender stereotype e.g. they aren't physically suited then it discourages women from entering IT. The memo did not claim this. The references to innate differences were only in reference to women's choices. At no point did the author claim they women "aren't physically suited" to IT.
- bduerst 7y agoHe says it right here: [emphasis added] > I’m simply stating that the distribution of preferences and abilities of men and women differ in part due to biological causes and that these differences may explain why we don’t see equal representation of women in tech and leadership. He's saying that women lack the ability to work in engineering and leadership because they are biologically different. His argument isn't limited to preference. And this is ignoring the fact that his supporting data used the Big5 psych method, which has been debunked as not being scientific in identifying biological differences due to it's lexical nature. Edit: Damore says that women more having extraversion and empathy, which "leads to women generally having a harder time negotiating salary, asking for raises, speaking up, and leading." Saying they are having a harder time is saying they lack the ability.
- ntnxw 7y ago>The memo made some very poignant points, but then the author expressed some strange opinions that I would never attempt to defend. Yeah but why have a discussion group about politics if you can only defend the mainstream points of view?
- bcrosby95 7y agoThe memo had mainstream views. It's just a mainstream view that the majority of Googlers don't like.
- lacampbell 7y agoYeah but why have a discussion group about politics if you can only defend the mainstream points of view? Because people typically don't discuss politics to be persuaded or to have their mind opened. They do it to circlejerk, flame, and re-inforce their own existing beliefs. Whether they are on the left, or the right.
- seph-reed 7y agoIt still seems strange that it's okay to be wrong sometimes, but not about a few very specific things. Like, it's probably no biggy if people say totally false and indefensible things going the other way. I don't think that's a good sign.
- UncleMeat 7y agoIt was not just a lit review. It drew conclusions from the synthesis of the citations and advocated for specific policy changes within Google. That was the part that pissed people off. Lots of people don't believe that the studies support the conclusions that he drew.
- manfredo 7y agoThis was the reaction at my company (at the time of the memo) as well. The psychology claims were not as big a deal as much as the fact that the author alleged discriminatory hiring policies. This led an exec to publicly state that our diversity policies "isn't code for favoring women over men" and that "being an equal opportunity employer is a commitment to following anti- discrimination laws and maintaining a workplace where everyone matters, everyone has a sense of belonging, and everyone is held to the same standards." This was in stark contrast to our diversity hiring policies which include giving larger bonuses for hiring diverse (women and URM), giving diverse candidates two chances at passing the phone screen instead of one, setting "outcome-based goals" for hitting specific % of diverse tech employees, and even setting up a system of reservations for diverse tech workers (though this last one wasn't established until after the memo). I guess the exec might not be lying if he is speaking from the point of view that anything less than 50/50 is discrimination and that balancing this out with discrimination in the other direction is how to create an equal hiring process.
- apta 7y agoEquality of opportunity vs equality of outcome. The far left wants the latter, without realizing what they're getting themselves into.
- lagadu 7y agoPeople observe data points, draw conclusions and then expose them to other people. This is a good thing, this is how we start talking about things, by exposing our conclusions to the outside and refining them based on that. Not liking someone's conclusions doesn't give them the right to silence them.
- jcranberry 7y ago>Damore cited two studies, three Wikipedia pages, and an article from Quillette, a contrarian online magazine that often covers free speech on campus and alleged links between genetics and IQ. Quote from the recent WIRED article on Google culture, easily verifiable but I'm too lazy right now. But that's hardly 'most of the memo was citations of studies'.
- Izkata 7y agoAn intentionally misleading quote. The memo has over 30 references, looks like about half of which are either to a research paper or reporting about some research. Even the Wikipedia links are either to a general definition, or a well-referenced section that cites research papers, not to baseless claims.
- ocdtrekkie 7y agoMy impression has not been that the memo is when political discussions turned toxic, but merely the first time it very publicly breached the sacred wall of non-disclosure with the outside world. Prior to that, most everyone seemed content to be upset with each other internally.
- gwbas1c 7y agoShortly before the memo, there were stories and comments in HN about problems inside Google. I vaguely remember a story about someone in HR getting fired because they didn't pull a white male out of the running for a job. (The details are too fuzzy at this point.)
- threeseed 7y agoIf you are going to bring up controversial anecdotes like this the onus is on you to actually have clear facts behind it.
- gwbas1c 7y agoThis isn't that kind of message board
- barbecue_sauce 7y agoI think Hacker News is probably the only message board that IS that kind of message board.
- panda88888 7y agoThis one? https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16500974 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16500974
- fortran77 7y agoAnd they never punished the woman who leaked that internal memo. I thought that memo was foolish and short-sighted. I don't agree with it. However, it would have been better solved by a manager first asking him "do you really think it's a good idea to post this at work?" and having him tone it down than trying to publicly shame him and get him fired. Google picked the wrong side on that. They should have made an example of the leakers.
- commandlinefan 7y ago> diversity memo Are you referring to James Damore's memo?
- gwbas1c 7y agoYes