4 ms·
> Electric cars are poor, even counterproductive stand-ins for long term solutions such as public transportation and the elimination of the suburban commuter li
by izacus 7y ago
> Electric cars are poor, even counterproductive stand-ins for long term solutions such as public transportation and the elimination of the suburban commuter lifestyle. They hide a multitude of externalities forced on the public and not paid for directly by owners or manufacturers.
Sure, but that's the solution you get from people who've never really experienced a well designed public transportation system. It's essentially a "faster horse" solution to traffic pollution issue which doesn't address the reasons behind the insane amount of tarmac space in modern US cities.
- lonelappde 7y agoPeople aren't dumb. Building a city requires decades of coordinated action by thousands to millions of people, and it only works if rich people volunteer or are coerced to give up the disproportionate amount of real estate they enjoy, and no one gets a luxurious amount of space. It's not a matter of individuals seeing the light.
- wbl 7y agoNYC billionaires did not stop nyc from being a city.
- timerol 7y agoIt's also a matter of the government allowing a city to be built. This sounds trivial, but is actually the biggest component to the lack of affordability in SF and NYC. There are places where a lot of people want to live, but the gov't is actively preventing housing being built there. Instead of allowing the next increment of development (SFH -> missing middle -> mid-rise apartment buildings -> high rise apartment buildings), many US cities do their best to block development wherever possible. The only developments that can make it through the process are 1) huge, 2) well-backed by capital, and 3) hugely profitable. We need less Hudson Yards, and more of https://twitter.com/mnolangray/status/1163863367439802369 https://twitter.com/mnolangray/status/1163863367439802369
- JamesSchriver 7y agoThat kind of mentality makes me cringe every time. Public transportation is not a solution to anything and is even far more inefficient and wasteful, even if many people don't understand that because a typical communist/socialist/academic fraudulent sleight of hand is used. Sure, public transportation is "better" once you sufficiently curtail and negate and ignore sufficient number of factors; but if you do an honest and objective analysis, it's not at all efficient or better. Intentionally hidden and fraudulently ignored factors include things like: * the convenience factor public transportation would need to be evaluated against for 24/7, high frequency availability for everyone that does not infringe on people's lives. * the indignity and risks of public transportation that causes people to be forced to be exposed to people against their will, whether that's their odors or behaviors or criminality or even diseases. Partial responsibility for the "Spanish Flu that killed somewhere near 100 million people was public transportation. * the systemic risk of systemic failure in a racked. For example you can look to Washington DC right now for an example of how after months of a rolling partial shutdown of the whole system, a whole leg of the public transportation system had to be totally shut down for several months now due to emergency repairs that had compounded over decades of mismanagement and malfeasance * which brings me to the collectivist, authoritarian nature of public transportation, especially when it is in the hand of government that can, again looking to DC, lead to several decades of malfeasance, mismanagement, negligence, corruption, and outright embezzlement all due to the SJW factor of putting poisonous communist ideals of subversion ahead of merit based leadership and performance. * there are also the hidden/obscured corruption factors that can be observed in Europe, where the wonderful world of "good public transportation" is really a seedy den of corruption and subsidies to wealthy industrialists that is propped up on the backs of the population as a kind of make work industry, while the population grinds its teeth in agony because outside of very few urban centers, the public transportation system only runs every hour and then only from 0700-1900 during the week an all other times every two hours on even more curtailed schedules. on a side note: the "cheap" and "good" public transportation in Europe that newly hatched college juveniles gush about on their first venture out from mommy and daddy's nest, is only so on the backs of Europeans who are forced against their will to subsidize the "cheap" public transportation with their lower wages and higher taxes. The result of which is that to Europeans that wonderful public transportation system the children gush about in tourist cities they visit, is not at all as useful and reliable outside fo the tourist centers, and is not at all as affordable to the average European that makes even less than most of the green eared American juveniles living off mommy and daddy's purse stings.