5 ms·
I basically agree with you. The 4 Hour Body is chock full of a bunch of stuff that isn't scientifically proven, which I'm always suspicious of. But, the science
by SwellJoe 16y ago
I basically agree with you. The 4 Hour Body is chock full of a bunch of stuff that isn't scientifically proven, which I'm always suspicious of. But, the science is solid on a lot of the stuff he really pushes hard.
The slow-carb diet is an excellent diet for weight loss and does avoid some of the problems of other rapid weight loss diets; it controls calorie intake without forcing you to count calories. I counted calories for the first week or so I was on it (in vegetarian form, which is a little bit of a challenge, to get enough protein without resorting to soy and wheat gluten products), and found I was eating about 200-300 below my resting metabolic rate every day, while eating enough to never feel hungry or get snacky. There's no way I could avoid losing weight if I'm eating significantly fewer calories than what I burn just sitting at my desk, and there is pretty solid science that the ingredients in the diet encourage loss of fat rather than loss of muscle...you're getting plenty of the stuff you need to maintain muscle mass, and adding some things to increase burning of fat for fuel.
As an aside, I've found the easily testable bits (particularly the "boost testosterone and libido" chapter) to have very evident results. That may be just because I was deficient in a few of the vital nutrients, and returning to nominal made things better, but I definitely saw a change. I plan to keep Brazil nuts in the house at all times, henceforth, regardless.
- dkarl 16y agoNothing related to libido and sexual performance is easily testable for an individual. Libido and sexual performance are strongly affected by psychological factors as well as physical ones.
- SwellJoe 16y agoThat's true. Nothing to do with the human body or mind is testable with scientific rigor on an individual basis. You have no control, and you have no way to prevent placebo effect. That doesn't make it entirely worthless, however. I know my own body, and I know what it's historically capable of. Without getting T-levels and other indicators tested at several intervals during the trials, I only have gut feelings. But, well, as with software, if it Works For Me(tm), I'm gonna keep using it.
- Retric 16y agoIt depends on what your studying. Much of the early research into how high G's effect the body is based on a single test subject (John Stapp). http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_Stapp http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_Stapp When he began his research in 1947, the aerospace conventional wisdom was that a man would suffer fatally around 18 g. ... In one of his final rocket-propelled rides, Stapp was subjected to 46.2 times the force of gravity."
- hni 16y agoWhy do you try to avoid gluten products? Just curious as I rely on them for a significant part of my protein intake (being vegan myself).
- Evgeny 16y agoThere's an article, incidentally, on Tim Fenriss' website www.fourhourworkweek.com/blog/2010/09/19/paleo-diet-solution/ it's a chapter of the book "The Paleo Solution" by Robb Wolf which basically answers the question "what is wrong with gluten".
- SwellJoe 16y agoI'm pretty suspicious of Robb Wolf's stuff, because it's almost entirely anecdotal and based on microscopic studies rather than actual data about what's going on inside a human body. He criticizes studies that disagree with his assertions (like The China Study), while promoting studies that are far less convincing that happen to support his opinions. Several of the studies he cites about "leaky gut syndrome" seem to be based on watching chemical reactions in a petri dish, which is nearly nonsensical when trying to understand a system containing billions of organisms. "Leaky gut syndrome" is, historically, an alternative medicine diagnosis, and conventional medicine doesn't really have much science on the subject. That's not to say it's completely fabricated, just that whenever someone is a "leaky gut syndrome" expert, as Robb Wolf is, there will be tons of people who will go see him, get his "treatment" and feel better for a while because of placebo effect. Everybody in the chain believes in the disease and the cures, so it tends to work a lot of the time, at least long enough for it to be considered a successful case study for Wolf's purposes. That said, where there's smoke there's often fire, and there does seem to be a lot of smoke around grains in the human diet, and some of the fire may be caused by gluten. So, in the interests of keeping things simple, I've cut gluten out of my diet during the week. On "cheat day" I eat plenty of grains, mostly brown rice, as it's a food I love (with curry and such), but also pastries and breads and beer. I don't really buy the leaky gut syndrome argument, as wheat has never caused me intestinal distress, while numerous other foods have due to always having had a sensitive stomach, but I'm willing to take a chance on the idea that wheat and gluten might have negative outcomes. Also, eggs are shown to help burn fat and build muscle, so I eat a lot of organic eggs from free range chickens (4-6 per day), and I've also added mussels and shrimp back into my diet (the first meat I've eaten in 17 years, and the only meat I can feel ethically comfortable eating).
- hni 16y agoWhy do you try to avoid gluten products? Just curious as I rely on them for a significant part of my protein intake (being vegan myself).
- alinajaf 16y agoI have to second the brazil nut recommendation. I've been chomping through three before sleep and three on waking and the difference in appetite is... pronounced. That plus the butter fat/fermented cod liver oil and extra kimchee.
- jokull 16y agoDoes he explicitly recommend fermented cod liver oil or just any cod liver oil?
- alinajaf 16y agoYes, he hit me with this one as well. It's a specific supplment, fermented cod liver oil with added butter fat (from cows who have grazed on rapidly growing grass). Its an actual thing that exists: http://www.greenpasture.org/retail/?t=products&a=display&i=1100 http://www.greenpasture.org/retail/?t=products&a=display...
- andrewl 16y agoAre the brazil nuts shelled or unshelled? I read somewhere that there are a lot fewer nutrients in the shelled nuts. But the unshelled are harder to find.