5 ms·
About the appeal - it depends on your cultural background. Here are some other ways people from different backgrounds think about this (not necessarily consiste
by einpoklum 7y ago
About the appeal - it depends on your cultural background. Here are some other ways people from different backgrounds think about this (not necessarily consistent with each other):
* A private car is bulky and noisy, bicycles and pedestrians aren't.
* Lazy people drive in cars, healthy people walk or cycle.
* A private car removes you from society, while using public transport/walking puts you with a group of peers, and cycling is a bit more singular but you're still surrounded by your peers with no physical barrier. So using a private car is somewhat disdainful towards the rest of society.
* A car is either a truck for people who need it to move things around, or if its a private car - it's probably some young man wasting his money to feel macho.
- dsfyu404ed 7y agoThe cultural background you're describing isn't a "background", it's an attitude/viewpoint (I'm not sure what to call it) that is only popular among people mostly of/above a certain wealth threshold (poor people wish they could have cars) living in certain urban areas (the ones that have a high cost of car ownership and good alternative options) mostly located in the US and Europe. For everyone else in the world driving around in a luxury car in the city is a symbol of wealth. There is also no "back" to it. If you traveled back in time to the 90s with that opinion you'd be lucky to encounter anyone other than the most die hard public transit proponents sharing it even in the aforementioned urban areas. Just because you and the people around you hold an opinion today does not make it a cultural background. Edit: Is my opinion wrong or have I just struck a nerve?
- tenpies 7y ago“A developed country is not a place where the poor have cars. It's where the rich use public transportation.” - Gustavo Petro Although I much prefer the adaption: "A prosperous country is not a place where everyone has a car, but one where everyone meets in public transit". After all, prosperity is more than development, and there is something very accurate about meeting in public transit. When your richest person and poorest person are both around each other, it is a huge empathogenic.
- myvoiceismypass 7y agoHow realistic is that for a big country (USA) that is really big & sparsely populated in lots of spots outside of major metro areas? (Disclaimer: I’ve drive only 5k miles a year, and actually just sold my car, since I prefer walking & PT... but I live in a giant city where that’s a legit option)
- baby 7y agoIt's not ultra realistic for less populated areas. But large cities have no excuses.
- scruple 7y agoOkay, but you have to define large, don't you? What is the population size you have in mind?
- tathougies 7y agoThe united states only has a handful of 'large' cities. Most cities with larve populations are only populated because they encompass large geographies. A large city shouldn't be defined by population but by density and the united states has very few dense cities. Maybe only new York, Philadelphia, washington DC, San Francisco, Chicago, and Boston, and even some of those are a stretch.
- baby 7y agoDensity is a bad metric because it will always be low in the US due to how cities are built.
- tathougies 7y agoBut that's the ultimate problem to solve. Build dense cities, and people will (a) want to live there and (b) will want to use transit and (c) transit will make the most sense. The city density issue is one completely controlled by the government. Developers are incentivized to produce high-density housing, because it yields more money. Cities don't want it.
- rootusrootus 7y agoDo people who don't own or have interest in owning a car really get that upset about other people's choices? The way you've worded those makes it sounds like they're feeling pretty judgemental.
- pornel 7y agoIt's your personal choice only if you don't expect to have (non-congested) public roads and parking spaces for your car. Space in cities is shared and finite, so something has to give. When I visit U.S. I'm shocked how much of city space is sacrificed to seas of asphalt and mountains of dull concrete. Multiple very wide lanes cutting cities into inaccessible islands, making everything spaced further apart. Where I'd expect to have a 5-minute stroll by a park to a local cafe, it turns out to be a dangerous 30-minute walk through viaducts and parking lots to a mall.
- jcranmer 7y agoIt depends a lot on where you go to. The cities of the NEC (Boston-Washington axis), along with Chicago and (to a lesser degree) San Francisco are generally pretty hostile to cars and have dense and compact cores. There's a tranche of cities that are trying to develop more towards that transit-heavy/car-lite scenario, which includes Seattle and Portland (and surprisingly, Los Angeles, but they have a long way to go). Then there's the cities that embraced the automobile and have blocks of nothing but parking in their downtown--Kansas City is one of the worst offenders here. And of course the suburbs tend to lean heavily into the space-wasting, automobile-centric design. It's quite striking just how compact things are in the first set of cities compared to the automobile-centered places elsewhere in the US. Apple's spaceship campus is about the size of downtown Providence. Or, if you impose it on Midtown Manhattan, it would cover the entire area between Penn Station, Grand Central, Broadway, and the Empire State Building (which incidentally houses more employees by itself than Apple's campus does).
- baby 7y agoI live in SF, previously Chicago, and I'm annoyed everyday at: * I have to cross large streets that have been built for cars all the time * Public transport sucks * The city is against other modes of transportation like kick scooters and people comolain about how much space they take when you have large cars parked everywhere * Because people move in cars, no area is really densed. Restaurants and bars are miles apart. * Because few people take the bus, there are all sorts of crazies there. I took the bus twice when I moved here and almost got beatten up the first time, witnessed someone getting mugged the second time. I'll never take the bus again here. * When I'm in the shuttle, and the traffic is freaking slow, I look outside the window and see one person per car. Why don't more people take shuttles instead of taking so much space on the road? Well there is no public transport. * Noise, noise, noise * The roads are all broken. Shuttle rides are uber bumpy.