3 ms·
>> Furthermore, even knowledge of something does not necessarily entail ability to reproduce something. Well, since we're on a philosophical footing, I'll say
by YeGoblynQueenne 7y ago
>> Furthermore, even knowledge of something does not necessarily entail ability to reproduce something.
Well, since we're on a philosophical footing, I'll say that knowledge of what intelligence is does not entail the ability to reproduce it, but the ability to reproduce intelligence entails knowledge of what it is.
(A |= B means that, whenever A is true, B is true, but not necessarily v.v.)
You are right to say that knowledge of what intelligence is does not entail the ability to reproduce it, since for example there may be hard practical obstacles to realising the necessary technologies etc. But I would think the ability to reproduce intelligence entails knowledge of what it is, assuming intelligence is something very complex that we will not just spontaneously obtain by chance, for example by a lucky combination of various random elements. We have certainly been trying to reproduce intelligence on computers for a while now- and failed. So it doesn't seem to be something in the order of, say, coming up with a cure for some ailment by trying things that we believe "should work" and that works in a way we don't quite understand etc.
All of which, given it's true, implies that we will not reproduce intelligence until we understand it.