3 ms·
For work Y to be a derivative work of X, some copyrighted elements of X must be included in Y, as is or in modified form (such as in a translation). Y merely d
by tzs 7y ago
For work Y to be a derivative work of X, some copyrighted elements of X must be included in Y, as is or in modified form (such as in a translation).
Y merely depending on X is not sufficient to make Y a derivative work.
Did RMS mean that if someone configured CLISP to actually build with readline the resulting binary was a derivative work of readline? If so, he was correct.
Or did he mean that the CLISP source code and build system itself is a derivative work of readline?
There was a similar situation back in the early '90s, concerning RIPEM (Riordan's Internet Privacy Enhanced Mail). RIPEM was distributed in source form. The source was public domain. To build it, though, you had to link the free-as-in-beer-but-not-as-in-speech RSAREF library from RSA Data Security. To build RIPEM you needed a big integer math library.
The RIPEM source could be built to use either libmp, the big integer library on most BSD systems then, or libgmp, the GNU big integer library that was on most Linux systems.
RMS got upset over this, claiming that RIPEM violated GPL. I seem to recall him acknowledging that RIPEM contained no copyrightable elements of libgmp, but rather arguing that because some people who downloaded the source would combine it with libgmp, distributing RIPEM induced this combination, and so counted as distributing libgmp.
Eventually, people on whatever mailing list or usenet group this was being discussed on (I don't remember which it was) got tired of trying to explain that there was nothing like this in US copyright law, and someone (I think it might have been the RIPEM author) wrote a new public domain library that provided the same interface as gmp for all the functions RIPEM needed, but was not gmp. It just provided the simple O(N^2) algorithms for everything, but you could link RIPEM with it instead of libgmp on Linux and it worked.
That made RMS happy, because after that someone downloading a building RIPEM on Linux was not implicitly going to build with gmp.
That was kind of a ridiculous solution, but also brilliant. It was ridiculous because whether or not Y is infringing X's copyright cannot be affected by any work, Z, that is created after X and Y, at least without access to Pym particles or the Time Stone. So all of us who were arguing over the legal issues were pretty much just wasting time and missing the point.
It was brilliant because whoever thought of it saw that the rest of us were missing the point, and saw that with a day or two of hacking he could address RMS' objection, regardless of whether or not that objection actually had any legal merit, and make the issue go away.