4 ms·
Looking at the example screenshot makes me realize that the hard part of programming is not the syntax, the hard part is breaking a "simple" task down into step
by jrockway 16y ago
Looking at the example screenshot makes me realize that the hard part of programming is not the syntax, the hard part is breaking a "simple" task down into steps. Even with a GUI, loops and if/then are not immediately intuitive and will require training, and by the time you've taught someone to think like a programmer, the syntax won't matter anymore.
(One counter-example is AppleScript. That lets you perform the action, and then it makes the script for you. You can then tweak and see what happens, which lets you experiment and learn. Tweaking is easier than starting from nothing.)
- JonnieCache 16y agoThe hard part is coping with the ramifications of turing completeness. Doesn't look like they want that far here.
- wiredfool 16y agoThe hard part doing this is not the programming side, it's the physical interface side, and doing it in a useful and cost effective manner. I'd love to have whole house lighting control, but at $20/node, it's not going to happen. I'd love to have some sort of datalogging and computer control of my 6 thermostats and the wood stove. My research was showing something like $100/node for the thermostats, and less than that for the thermocouples for the stove, but then I'd need a datalogger for them. I'd love to have killawatt meters in all my sockets, with wireless reporting. Etc Etc Etc. Their system is a usb->xbee, and then xbee->arduino on the other end. That's like $100 of control systems, and you still don't actually have interfaces to anything, you have a low power board that needs a driver to even drive a reasonable relay. (but, there are easy driver circuits for that, even $20 pigtails with embedded relays)
- samdk 16y agoOnce you get to doing real tasks, I think that this is very definitely true. However, from my experience TAing intro programming classes (2 of them, both targeted at non-CS majors) the syntax is still a huge roadblock for a lot of people when they're learning to program. When they're learning, a lot of people spend so much time worrying about the syntax ("how do I write it?") that they don't get to the much more important "how do I solve the problem?" without a lot of prompting.