5 ms·
Also, according to RMS, CLISP is a derivative work of readline because of the optional dependency on it. (CLISP is now GNU CLISP, but was not originally part o
by aidenn0 7y ago
Also, according to RMS, CLISP is a derivative work of readline because of the optional dependency on it. (CLISP is now GNU CLISP, but was not originally part of the gnu project).
- mikekchar 7y agoImagine you are a photographer. You take a photo of something. The photo is covered by copyright. I can't use it without your permission. Now imagine that I write a book and I include your photo in it. This is an infringement of copyright. I can't distribute my book, containing your photo, without infringing copyright. It doesn't matter how much your photo contributes to my book -- including it in my book and distributing it is infringement. You might even be able to get an injunction to stop me from distributing my book without removing your photo. Now imagine that you put your photo under a CC "share alike" license. What it says is that, while I don't generally have the right to use your photo in my book, if I decide to license my book using a CC "share alike" license, then you will give me permission to use your photo. To make things simple, you give blanket permission to anyone to use the photo as long as whatever is including the photo is licensed as CC "share alike" -- in that case it is not necessary to get specific permission to use it. Finally, let's say that you make the offer that if I infringe your copyright by including the photo in my project that you will forgive that infringement if I agree to re-license the project under CC "share alike". Exactly same thing.
- sokoloff 7y agoImagine instead that you sold a book of pictures with a few blank spaces/pages where a book owner could optionally put other pictures in that space. That book, standing alone, does not infringe on others' copyright, which (IMO) is closer to "exactly the same thing".
- mikekchar 7y agoYeah... I realised that later. I've added my opinion on that situation in a sibling post.
- mikekchar 7y agoI was on my walk and I realised that I completely missed the interesting part of this discussion (which was hinted at by the OP). So I'll do my best now (with the caveat that this is a very complex legal issue and I am not a lawyer). One of the most crucial things about the GPL is that it is only triggered on distribution. You are specifically granted permission to use the software for any purpose (freedom 0). This includes embedding it in another piece of software. As long as you don't distribute the result, then you are 100% OK ("distribution" has a specific definition which is stated in the license, so refer to that if you have any questions about how that works). The "anti-GPL hack" that some people use is that they say, "Well, if I don't distribute a library that I use, then I am not infringing on the license -- because the license only kicks in on distribution. If the user links the software, then it's 100% OK because they are specifically given permission to use the software for any purpose in the license. Whoo hoo!" This is where the argument of "derived work" comes in. Imagine that you write a poem. I then write a critique of that poem. I don't include the poem in my critique because I don't have the right to distribute it. Just referencing your poem is not an infringement of copyright. Just because I describe your poem doesn't mean it's a derived work. However, imagine that I decide to distribute my critique in a web page. Many of the things I say depend on the actual text of the poem, so I'd really like to add it to my text. But I can't distribute the poem. What to do? You are distributing your poem on the internet too, but you have a license that doesn't allow me to use it directly. Maybe I can be a bit clever here. What I'll do is write a web page that deep-links to the poem. I'll write some javascript that allows the user to press a button and it will copy the text of the poem into my document. That way I can refer to the poem without actually distributing it. My document won't make any sense if the user doesn't press the button to link to the original text, but the user will be doing that, not me. Is my website a derived work of the poem? This is a good question. I think it probably is. My document does not "work" without the original poem. It depends on the actual structure of the poem in non-trivial ways. However, I am sure there are also good arguments for the opposite. Given the outcome of Oracle vs Google where the judge decided that APIs are copyrightable, I feel fairly comfortable in my position, but as far as I know it has never been decided in court. Your guess is as good as mine (and better if you are a lawyer ;-) ). But just to reiterate -- it does not matter how much of the program infringes. If any of the program infringes than it all infringes. You can't legally distribute it. So while it might seem weird that a very small part of your code might be deemed to be a derived work of some other code and therefore you can't distribute it -- that's how it works (and, to be honest, I can't see a reasonable way of proceeding if it didn't work that way).
- emilfihlman 7y agoNow imagine I go there and take the exact same photo myself, and replace the original. Which is exactly why license tainting like that is not a thing and never been proven to be. If I break rules, I don't lose rights to my own works, I just pay with money and paying reparations is an entirely different thing.
- mikekchar 7y agoYes, you are correct. Infringement is infringement. Keep in mind that you are never compelled to license your work under the GPL even if you infringe the copyright of GPL code. It is an offer to remedy the infringement. You can accept the offer or you can decide not to accept the offer. It's your choice. However, even if you replace the infringing use with a non-infringing use, you still have to deal with the original infringement. You can't really escape that.
- lwf 7y agoCC does allow for "collections"[1]: > All Creative Commons licenses (including the version 4.0 licenses) allow licensed material to be included in collections such as anthologies, encyclopedias, and broadcasts. You may choose a license for the collection, however this does not change the license applicable to the original material. IANAL, so whether a book using a photo as an illustration would count as a collection is beyond me, but e.g. an encyclopedia or photo book seems to be within scope. https://creativecommons.org/faq/#if-i-create-a-collection-that-includes-a-work-offered-under-a-cc-license-which-licenses-may-i-choose-for-the-collection https://creativecommons.org/faq/#if-i-create-a-collection-th...
- williamstein 7y agoSimilarly, according to Henri Cohen (personal communication), the leading number theory program GP/PARI was licensed under the GPL because of the dependency on Readline. RMS personally requested that Cohen change the license of GP/PARI to the GPL when visiting France long ago. I licensed SageMath under the GPL initially, since it heavily depended on GP/PARI, so I didn't have a choice. That said, the GPL makes a lot of sense for software such as Pari and SageMath.
- gumby 7y agoRMS wouldn't put readline under the library license because it thought it was too useful. He was really upset when I wrote the library license (LGPL) in the first place, though eventually the FSF embraced it, though calling it the "lesser license".
- kazinator 7y agoI believe they could easily have wriggled out of it. You can't infringe on the GNU license of something that is 1) not shipped with your program and 2) your program runs fine without. CLISP has a very good FFI which could be used to attach to a user's readline installation dynamically, if so configured by the end user. This be packaged up in .lisp file that is not even officially bundled with CLISP. Thus if there was any shred of a basis for infringment, the only offender would be that file, which anyone could share over obvious channels. (Good luck suing a file circulating on the Internet, or having all copies of it taken down ...) If I have a proprietary or otherwise GNU-incompatible program, and some GNU library, and as user (not redistributing anything!) want to put that together with the help of some config file on the Internet, what is the basis for stopping me? And would RMS even support a state with the level of surveillance required to catch people in such acts ...
- admax88q 7y agoOr just don't be a prick and write your own readline if the terms of the GNU version are not to your liking. HN is a strange place where people will bemoan piracy but salivate at ways to workaround the GPL.
- cat199 7y agoor, do! https://github.com/NetBSD/src/tree/trunk/lib/libedit https://github.com/NetBSD/src/tree/trunk/lib/libedit also: isn't the entire GNU project itself someone 'being a prick and writing their own unix because the terms of the AT&T one were not to their liking'? (pay no attention to the Berkely UNIX behind the curtain) also also: isn't this hacker news?
- gwd 7y agoNitpick: "Being a prick" in the parent was "trying to work around the license". "Writing your own alternative" was the "don't be a prick" option. Of course, just because you write your own alternative doesn't mean you can't be a prick if you want. :-)
- tzs 7y agoFor work Y to be a derivative work of X, some copyrighted elements of X must be included in Y, as is or in modified form (such as in a translation). Y merely depending on X is not sufficient to make Y a derivative work. Did RMS mean that if someone configured CLISP to actually build with readline the resulting binary was a derivative work of readline? If so, he was correct. Or did he mean that the CLISP source code and build system itself is a derivative work of readline? There was a similar situation back in the early '90s, concerning RIPEM (Riordan's Internet Privacy Enhanced Mail). RIPEM was distributed in source form. The source was public domain. To build it, though, you had to link the free-as-in-beer-but-not-as-in-speech RSAREF library from RSA Data Security. To build RIPEM you needed a big integer math library. The RIPEM source could be built to use either libmp, the big integer library on most BSD systems then, or libgmp, the GNU big integer library that was on most Linux systems. RMS got upset over this, claiming that RIPEM violated GPL. I seem to recall him acknowledging that RIPEM contained no copyrightable elements of libgmp, but rather arguing that because some people who downloaded the source would combine it with libgmp, distributing RIPEM induced this combination, and so counted as distributing libgmp. Eventually, people on whatever mailing list or usenet group this was being discussed on (I don't remember which it was) got tired of trying to explain that there was nothing like this in US copyright law, and someone (I think it might have been the RIPEM author) wrote a new public domain library that provided the same interface as gmp for all the functions RIPEM needed, but was not gmp. It just provided the simple O(N^2) algorithms for everything, but you could link RIPEM with it instead of libgmp on Linux and it worked. That made RMS happy, because after that someone downloading a building RIPEM on Linux was not implicitly going to build with gmp. That was kind of a ridiculous solution, but also brilliant. It was ridiculous because whether or not Y is infringing X's copyright cannot be affected by any work, Z, that is created after X and Y, at least without access to Pym particles or the Time Stone. So all of us who were arguing over the legal issues were pretty much just wasting time and missing the point. It was brilliant because whoever thought of it saw that the rest of us were missing the point, and saw that with a day or two of hacking he could address RMS' objection, regardless of whether or not that objection actually had any legal merit, and make the issue go away.