2 ms·
You write "because of the Gold Rush". Please do not exclude "and genocide of the Indigenous peoples of California". https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/California_In
by eesmith 7y ago
You write "because of the Gold Rush".
Please do not exclude "and genocide of the Indigenous peoples of California". https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/California_Indian_Wars https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/California_Indian_Wars
Your hypothetical analogy to Quebec of two centuries ago fails because the white population of the US would likely not have killed off 90% of the French-speaking population. As it was, we know that the population influx of the Great Migration of Canada of 200 years ago didn't cause the Quebecois to disappear.
You write "In both cases, English-speaking, common-law government institutions were immediately established upon US annexation"
Right, but earlier you wrote "English-speaking US territory", not "English-speaking government institutions". I was objecting to your earlier characterization. NM was not primarily an English-speaking territory.
Now you add "common-law" to the mix. Why is that relevant? Louisiana has a civil-law legal system, not have a common-law one, so it isn't like common-law-only is an essential part of the "unified American culture" you mentioned.