3 ms·
This is something I've wanted to do for a long time-- and they've taken a particularly simple approach where the extrudate volume doesn't vary wildly over the n
by mlyle 7y ago
This is something I've wanted to do for a long time-- and they've taken a particularly simple approach where the extrudate volume doesn't vary wildly over the nonplanar layers.
One potential shortcoming is it looks like their model of nozzle geometry (they need to be able to detect interference) assumes it can be modeled with an angle plus a distance where there's bigger things. But real nozzles are more complicated than that.
The worst thing is that the bottom of the nozzle is flat, and any Z movement downwards is going to smush the just extruded trace.
- ricardobeat 7y agoThe video and pictures show real prints from an Ultimaker.
- mlyle 7y agoYes. I'm saying they treat the nozzle like it is a cone to determine whether it'll interfere with the previous layer's top surface. But this is a little optimistic because the bottom of the nozzle is flat, so you get variable "smush" based on convexity. You can see this a bit in their pictures of prints where the surface is steep along the print line.
- nickparker 7y agoYup, I did research on this with my own little slicer [0] back in 2014. With conventional nozzles your surface finish goes to crap past about 20 degrees. If you really want conformal layers you need a five axis platform. The flat tip of FDM nozzles is an important part of layer adhesion. I've seen a little bit of experimentation with pointier nozzles and it went very poorly. Nowadays I'm building the five axis version and packaging it up in a service [1], along with a bunch of other improvements that are only feasible when you stop trying to build a machine lay-people can operate. [0]: https://github.com/nick-parker/bread https://github.com/nick-parker/bread [1]: https://www.praxismfg.com/ https://www.praxismfg.com/
- Ccecil 7y agoNice to see you are still at it. I just posted a video above from 4 years ago when I was testing bread in #reprap. Can't wait to see more of what you are doing soon.
- nickparker 7y agoHey ccecil, long time no see! I was just checking on Continuous Composites' website the other day and thought of you. I should have some fancy demo prints online in a few weeks here, keep an eye on the website!