3 ms·
At the end of the day, Google has a fundamental crisis. Their entire business depends on your lack of privacy from them. They would be happy to help keep you pr
by jedberg 7y ago
At the end of the day, Google has a fundamental crisis. Their entire business depends on your lack of privacy from them. They would be happy to help keep you private from everyone else but they definitely need to invade your privacy to keep their business alive.
- ProAm 7y agoTo be fair this is a project that will be cancelled in 18 months anyways.
- mav3rick 7y agoJust like Search was cancelled after 2000 or Maps or Youtube or Android ? Keep peddling the HN narrative.
- pessimizer 7y agoMaybe find an example too young to be in high school?
- joshuamorton 7y agoWhat's the exact age range you're looking for? 13 years is too old, its high school aged, but 3-5 years is too young? So we're looking what, only for products released from '07-'12? Drive fits the bill.
- ehnto 7y agoI wonder if they could survive off of search page ads and website contextual ads? No user targeted ads. If they could, they could squash the invasive marketing advertisers with lobbying for privacy policy and then regain a total monopoly as no other tracking adtech is viable anymore. I personally believe fingerprinting should be illegal, and that any company that relies on it is inherently unethical. I think Google could survive without it. I am by no means a Google fan either, just recognizing they have some power here and that fighting for ethical policy might actually be a good business move.
- ocdtrekkie 7y agoContextual ads would be perfectly fine and unlikely to be any less relevant than user targeted ads. However, any ad company can easily offer this. Google's raisin-d'etre is that they track everyone on the Internet, and that they claim by doing so, can offer the best ads. If they admit that's not true, you might as well go with any other ad company.
- ehnto 7y agoIn my read of the situation, Google's ads dominate because of their network. Other ad suppliers can't put their ads into Google search results, and it would be hard to build a network of display advertisers as big as Google's. I wouldn't mind a shake up in the display network side of things. "Carbon" ad network is a great example of what can come out of a niche, well managed ad network and people choose them because they are present where the eyeballs for their demographic are. Like putting motor oil adverts on a racetrack. You don't have to track people around for those types of networks to work.
- floatboth 7y agoOh yeah, there were multiple networks like Carbon, The Deck, etc. The only kind that doesn't suck. It's weird that tracking-based ads have taken over. Logically, contextual makes a lot more sense. But apparently statistical data is telling ad companies that tracking is worth it :(