6 ms·
There will always be an audience for a MMO that walks the fine line between too punishing, and not punishing enough. It is, however, a niche genre, and the feel
by falcolas 7y ago
There will always be an audience for a MMO that walks the fine line between too punishing, and not punishing enough. It is, however, a niche genre, and the feeling that many are hoping to recapture with the release of classic will not exist anymore.
The game is, for the serious raiders, too simple. For the casual crowd, it’s going to be slow and comparatively unrewarding. The nostalgia hit for people who have played it before will wear off fairly quickly, leaving only those for whom classic WoW hits their sweet spot. At least for a year or two. What will happen once those niche players hit max level and run out of content to do?
- bocklund 7y agoMake new content à la Old School RuneScape?
- falcolas 7y agoThey did. They made enough content that it’s currently at “Modern WoW”. All the changes were incremental. So, do they just re-release the same content again (and where do they stop)? Any attempt to release new “old school” content would be immediately compared to the original expansions (considered some of the best expansions of the game), and most likely not welcomed by the community.
- vanterdon 7y agoEh, that's not what he's asking for. Runescape 3 has been on its own development path since 2007. In 2013 they released OSRS, which has its own development path that sticks to the old design philosophy rather than the one that they took in Runescape 3 following the evolution of combat update. Content in Modern WoW has an entirely different design philosophy than Vanilla. If they added to Classic, say 6 months to a year after Phase 6/Naxxramas has been released, that new content could stick to the Vanilla design philosophy and be totally warranted. They could even implement horizontal progression paths that don't invalidate Naxxramas as a source of powerful gear. If necessary, they could also leave up a museum server up for certain players who just want to relive 1.13 over and over again.
- falcolas 7y agoNone of the people who really drove the creation of WoW back in the day exist at Blizzard anymore. They don’t play WoW, they don’t even play computer games primarily (at least, that’s what they say). There’s nobody to really lead the charge to create “old school” content for WoW.
- vanterdon 7y agoPlenty of them are still at Blizzard, though OSRS did a good enough job of having new staff and still sticking to the original game's design philosophy. It's really not an issue, it's easy to see the bounds of how the game could expand within the original design philosophy. For example, no LFG, keep the level cap, no transmog, no multi-server sharding, no removing RPG elements like hunter ammo, things of that sort.
- PeterStuer 7y agoI think the person you are responding though means adding more content without changing the gameplay mechanics that later patches and expansions brought. Also not every evolution means going down the paths previously taken. Old School Runescape has been developing continuously without turning into modern Runescape. AFAIK Blizzard has stated that if successfull (udefined criteria) they want to expand on the Classic release, but they have not decided wether they want that to be releasing ports of the next exansions (The Burning Crusade etc., 'vertical expansion'), or more content but still in the Classic game ('horizonal expansion'), or both etc.
- falcolas 7y agoAny expansion path they take will divide an already niche community. There’s a set of people who have expressed a desire to go through the expansions again (up to a point, which is also a divisive point in the community), and there’s another set of poeple who don’t want any new releases, and a final group who wants new “old school” content. In short, a small niche set of gamers is split in three on where they want Class WoW to go, promising no real value to Blizzard (especially since they are not being independently monetized).
- PeterStuer 7y agoRe-masters/releases are some of the cheapest games to produce. Therefore my money would be on them most certainly releasing the next expansions in the series remastered as well. Whether the customer-base for such a remake game series is primarily predatory on the current 'modern' game remains to be seen. Some retakes have been far more successful than their original bloodlines. Everyone always references OSRS, as that is also an MMO and therefore the most comparable, but think about the successes of the 'Age of Empires II' series still going strong where AoE3 was not longlived.
- lugg 7y agoHad similar thoughts. I think a lot of people have rose tinted glasses on and simply don't remember how simple the game used to be and how far it's evolved since. I am curious what they've done with the mechanics though. Some were broken by expacs, some were fixed, wonder what they rolled back and what they left.
- vbezhenar 7y agoThey rolled back everything except obvious exploits like wall jumping or macroses automating your rotation in one button. It's not pixel-perfect remake, but it's very close to it.
- pythonaut_16 7y agoSeems a little disappointing if they disabled wall jumps. Were there any wall jumps that were actually exploitable (i.e. let you do bad things)? Most of the ones I remember just let you get to weird spots in the environment.
- plopz 7y agoTheres still plenty of wall jumps, you can find videos of people testing all the classic WSG jumps on youtube. The classic wall-walking doesn't work, but that was changed during vanilla so its to be expected.
- vbezhenar 7y agoYep, that's a controversal point. I think that they still consider weird spots to be bugs and you should not be there. You can definitely abuse it on battlegrounds to hide flag where you could not be reached. Also I won't be surprised if there would be a ways to skip some bosses in dungeons.
- plopz 7y agoI'm sure for some people its rose tinted glasses. But I would think the consistent popularity of private servers over such a long time shows the real non-nostalgia based demand for the game.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- ubermonkey 7y agoThey'll stop playing?
- bluntfang 7y ago>What will happen once those niche players hit max level and run out of content to do? Check out Project 1999 [0] for an example of what happens. It's a classic Everquest server that only plans to ever release the first 3 expansions and has been running for almost decade now. [0] https://www.project1999.com/ https://www.project1999.com/