3 ms·
> I don't think that they have to be part of the USA if they don't want to belong! I merely don't want them to be disenfranchised. Right, but what if they want
by eesmith 7y ago
> I don't think that they have to be part of the USA if they don't want to belong! I merely don't want them to be disenfranchised.
Right, but what if they want to stay as a dependent? Your original statement was that we owe statehood (and, now, independence) to them, not, we should let them decide if they want statehood. While the wording seems like a minor change, I think it's an important distinction.
> let's remember the history of Hawaii
As I understand it, one of the arguments in American Samoa against statehood is to avoid being like modern Hawaii. Eg, land ownership restrictions to native Samoans means that American Samoa, unlike Hawaii, is predominately populated by the indigenous people.
https://www.quora.com/Why-doesnt-American-Samoa-want-independence https://www.quora.com/Why-doesnt-American-Samoa-want-indepen...
> what about Puerto Rico
I'm all for P.R. statehood. And D.C. statehood. Should the population decide. And with clear, solid restrictions on outsider influence in the debate and discussion elections. And a firm commitment to support the Puerto Rico no matter what happens - unlike the dire lack of commitment we have now.
> When Arizona and New Mexico first came into the Union
Note that NM's 1912 statehood did not result a "strong tradition of spending public funds on preserving and understanding the history of" New Mexico.
- lidHanteyk 7y agoThere is a curious paradox here: Because American Samoans aren't legally self-determining, they're unable to become legally self-determining. We have to interpret their desires for them, and we have to resist the urge to allow them to be less-than-citizens or to have diminished rights. New Mexico has a Department of Cultural Affairs. They have a budget of around $45mil/yr [0]. The Department was set up by the New Mexico Legislature. Puerto Rico has an Institute of Puerto Rican Culture ("Instituto de Cultura Puertorriqueña"). They are a government-owned corporation. They seem constantly stressed by their budget [2]. They have a budget of around $17mil/yr [1]. [0] http://www.newmexicoculture.org/about http://www.newmexicoculture.org/about [1] http://www.presupuesto.pr.gov/presupuestoRecomendado2018-2019/PresupuestosAgencias/Instituto%20de%20Cultura%20Puertorriquena.htm http://www.presupuesto.pr.gov/presupuestoRecomendado2018-201... [2] https://nasaa-arts.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/05/PR_2013-2017-Strategic-Plan.pdf https://nasaa-arts.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/05/PR_2013-20...
- eesmith 7y ago"We have to interpret their desires for them" is very easily re-interpreted as just another expression of paternal colonialism. Remember, and I quote now from the Samoa Historic Preservation Office document at http://www.ashpo.org/attachments/article/94/2017%20FIVE%20YEAR%20PLAN.pdf http://www.ashpo.org/attachments/article/94/2017%20FIVE%20YE... : "American Samoa has remained an “unorganized” territory, with its own Constitution but under direct Federal government supervision delegated by the President to the Department of the Interior. This unique status is not accidental. It is the result of decisions consciously taken by the American Samoan leaders—not to obtain citizenship nor acquire an organic act—in order to keep their traditional land tenure system, whose racial preferences would make it unconstitutional under Federal law." Your statement rejects the validity of their conscious decision. "Kill the Indian, and Save the Man" said Pratt. A policy of enforced statehood against their will would surely be characterized as "Kill the Samoan, and Save the American." Well, it wouldn't be the first time we broke agreements with indigenous peoples. You earlier wrote "It's only with statehood that Hawaii gained a strong tradition of spending public funds on preserving and understanding the history of the Hawaiians". The implication I read was that 1) a strong tradition could not start without statehood, and 2) that strong tradition is a natural consequence of statehood. I believe both are wrong. 1) Do the people of American Samoa not have a sufficiently strong tradition of funding the preservation and understanding of their own history? They certainly spend public funds on it, like http://www.ashpo.org/ http://www.ashpo.org/ . What else would come with statehood? Remember, the - for lack of a better term - white population of Hawaii dominated local politics until statehood. The political power of the Big Five, who backed the Hawaiian Republican Party, didn't want statehood because they thought territorial status was better for the sugar companies. And they wanted a subordinate plantation population. American Samoa is 89% Samoan, and political power is held by the Samoans. This is a very different situation. 2) It took 19 years of statehood before the 1978 Hawaii State Constitutional Convention which established Hawaiian as the second official language, and created the Office of Hawaiian Affairs. By comparison, the NM Department of Cultural Affairs started 15 years ago, which is nearly a century after statehood, and it is nowhere equivalent to the Office of Hawaiian Affairs in terms of effect. Now, it's true that the department consolidated many functions which were present earlier. But the Territory of Hawaii might well have had a 'farm and ranch heritage museum' (which is part of what the NM Department of Cultural Affairs overseas - https://laws.nmonesource.com/w/nmos/Laws-2004#!fragment/zoupio-_Toc972018/BQCwhgziBcwMYgK4DsDWszIQewE4BUBTADwBdoAvbRABwEtsBaAfX2zgE4B2AJgAYAjAA4AlABpk2UoQgBFRIVwBPaAHJVYiHFzYANroDCSNNACEyTYTC4E8xSvWXrCAMp5SAIRUAlAKIAZXwA1AEEAOQNfMVIwACNoUnYRESA https://laws.nmonesource.com/w/nmos/Laws-2004#!fragment/zoup... ). So, what's special about statehood how it preserves and helps understand history? And how does it follow directly from statehood, since I think the stronger influence in Hawaii is as a consequence of increasing awareness caused by the civil rights movement of the 1960s and onward.