4 ms·
Firstly, there isn't all that much of anything in Birmingham that makes this worthwhile. At best there might be some new business development in 10-20 years, bu
by TheOtherHobbes 7y ago
Firstly, there isn't all that much of anything in Birmingham that makes this worthwhile. At best there might be some new business development in 10-20 years, but it's not at all obvious that Birmingham is somehow going to become London's second business centre because of HS2.
Most of the claims in this piece are simply nonsense. The Euston to Crewe train that's mentioned doesn't go anywhere near Birmingham, so it's not obvious that HS2 would make much of a difference to traffic on it.
And even if it did, it's merely one of a large number of routes heading out of London in all directions that are ridiculously overcrowded. At best, HS2 might reduce a small proportion of that overcrowding, but it's certainly not going to eliminate it.
The idea that HS2 can make Birmingham airport competitive with Heathrow for Londoners is clearly wrong. Birmingham doesn't have the flights, the destinations, or the capacity. London also has Heathrow Express for quick train journeys from Paddington to Heathrow - concourse to concourse. Even with a shorter journey time, HS2 can't match that.
And HS2 doesn't start to make sense until Phase 2 is built, linking Sheffield, Manchester and Leeds. You might see some benefits then - but the realistic total cost is likely to be the far side of £100bn. Which is madness.
It's actually five years of the total NASA budget, which is supposed to pay for development of the next Lunar program, as well as everything else NASA does.
It would be much better to spend a much smaller sum making the UK's broadband the best in Europe, set up a world-leading incubator fund for digital startups outside of London, with next-generation training and education, and try to persuade existing corporates to consider home working options. The return on that would be huge.
This is just a giant train set for rail nostalgists.
- tonyedgecombe 7y agoFirstly, there isn't all that much of anything in Birmingham that makes this worthwhile. If you let that be a guide then you wouldn't invest in anything outside of London.
- DanBC 7y ago> there isn't all that much of anything in Birmingham that makes this worthwhile. The UK has a weird chicken and egg thing going on. Everything is in London because everything is in London. HS2 is an attempt to break out of that. By developing better rail links across England we allow companies to start moving out of London. > The idea that HS2 can make Birmingham airport competitive with Heathrow for Londoners is clearly wrong. But that's not the aim. The aim is that we shouldn't have everyone in the country using Heathrow for all journeys. Currently we have about 80 million people going through Heathrow which is stupid if a chunk of them are only using it to get into the UK. London doesn't just have Heathrow and Gatwick. London has six international airports. Heathrow alone at 80m people currently carries the equivalent of Manchester, Edinburgh, Birmingham, Glasgow, and Bristol combined. We urgently need to fix this.
- growlist 7y ago> The UK has a weird chicken and egg thing going on. Everything is in London because everything is in London. HS2 is an attempt to break out of that. One of the criticisms of HS2 is that it will just facilitate centralisation in London, by helping people get there more quickly!
- isostatic 7y agoIt means that a business that needs to occasionally meet people face to face in London can instead be based in Crewe, saving £10k a month in rent and saving in salaries.
- jbb123 7y agoExcept that it's more likely to have people saying why do we need a crewe office at all when people can be at the main office in an hour anyway. It will just drag even more resources to london
- isostatic 7y agoWhy would I, a business owner, want to pay extortionate rents for floor space in London when I could instead have an office in Crewe for 1/10th the price and still reach my clients when I need to?
- makomk 7y agoNow what happens when the business needs to meet someone face to face in say Cambridge, home to a growing number of tech companies? Our current rail network is so London-centric that the fastest way to do that from Crewe is to go all the way south to central London, turn around, and head north again in almost the same direction you came from. One of the big advantages of being based in London is that you can get to nearly any major city in the country quickly and directly by rail, and HS2 just strengthens that advantage.
- isostatic 7y ago
- youngtaff 7y agoEconomically Birmingham is growing faster than anywhere else in the UK except London - https://www.ft.com/content/f53b6ab0-b905-11e9-8a88-aa6628ac896c https://www.ft.com/content/f53b6ab0-b905-11e9-8a88-aa6628ac8... (subs required) H2 increases capacity for commuter lines out of London, and one of the reasons it's so f'ing expensive is people in Tory Shires demanding the line is placed in a tunnel
- growlist 7y agoIt's a shame tunnels are so expensive! I dream of a day when motorways are buried out of sight.