5 ms·
I've always wondered if the government could defray the cost of HS2 by buying some blocks of cheap farmland in the middle of nowhere, adding a HS2 station so th
by michaelt 7y ago
I've always wondered if the government could defray the cost of HS2 by buying some blocks of cheap farmland in the middle of nowhere, adding a HS2 station so the land was 20 minutes from central London, then selling the land to property developers. Obviously you could only add one or two towns, to avoid creating slow stopping services.
Seems to me that could increase the housing supply and offset the costs of HS2 at the same time - and most governments have had plans for new towns, new garden cities and suchlike.
- heavenlyblue 7y agoProbably because “20 minutes from central London” is too short even for high-speed trains to reach any cheap farmland. That’s like... Croydon distance from London Bridge?
- petercooper 7y agoSo this thread got me thinking about the practicalities.. the HS1 speed to Ebbsfleet (25 miles out of London and outside the M25) is 18 minutes which includes a stop at Stratford. HS2 is designed to run a little faster and if you nixed the stop I think 30-35 miles could realistically be 20 minutes out of London on HS2. That sticks you right in the middle of the Chilterns if you follow HS2's rough direction.. probably not ideal for a town. Add another 5 minutes, though, and there's a lot of open land just south-east of Oxford and just off of the M40 too..
- tialaramex 7y agoSo you're correct that the Chilterns aren't ideal - those are dormitory villages, already very expensive, I grew up there. The open land near Oxford will be open because it's a swamp. If you could build on it cheaply somebody would.
- chrisseaton 7y ago> buying some blocks of cheap farmland in the middle of nowhere, adding a HS2 station so the land was 20 minutes from central London, then selling the land to property developers. Obviously you could only add one or two towns, to avoid creating slow stopping services I don't think any such land ('cheap', 'middle of nowhere', '20 mins from central London') exists in the UK.
- djmobley 7y agoIt’s called the Green Belt https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Metropolitan_Green_Belt https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Metropolitan_Green_Belt
- chrisseaton 7y agoNone of that land is remotely cheap, in the middle of nowhere, nor probably twenty minutes away even for a fast train.
- isostatic 7y ago20 minutes from Old Oak Common / Crossrail, based on HS1 timings from Ebbsfleet (140mph), you'd be able to get out to around Quainton in 20 minutes.
- michaelt 7y agoWhat I mean is they could buy land somewhere like the outskirts of Quainton [1] at the current "much more than 20 minutes from Euston" land price, then add a HS2 station that turns it into "20 minutes from Euston" land. Or if Quainton is too expensive/green-belt-y, do the same at Wormleighton or Newton Purnell or somewhere else along the line. [1] https://goo.gl/maps/idx4iCxQjVjEU5WCA https://goo.gl/maps/idx4iCxQjVjEU5WCA
- LiamPa 7y ago20 minutes from London you are looking at about 5-10m per hectare and as mentioned good luck finding an empty square meter let alone a hectare.
- isostatic 7y ago£10k an acre, or £30k a heactare https://www.rightmove.co.uk/commercial-property-for-sale/property-73434841.html https://www.rightmove.co.uk/commercial-property-for-sale/pro... Once close to a HS2 station yes it would be £5m a hectare
- isostatic 7y agoCrossrail was funded by me and other tax payers. It's cost about £20b. House prices near crossrail have risen an extra £133k each (above similar houses in similar places that don't get crossrail). That's somewhere in the region of £100b. Crossrail is a massive transfer of wealth from working people to wealthy land owners. It should have been funded entirely by a windfall levy on the increase land value near the stations.
- Reason077 7y ago> "Crossrail was funded by me and other tax payers." A significant portion (over 30% of the original £17.8b budget) of Crossrail's funding has actually come from land owners and businesses, in the form of: - Business rate supplements - Property developer contributions - Community infrastructure levy - Sale of surplus property along the route - Contributions from other non-taxpayer funded entities like Heathrow and the City of London corporation Much of the rest of the funding is from TfL and loans backed by the DfT, which should eventually be payed back from ticket revenue.
- crdoconnor 7y ago30% is not nearly enough. It's still a free lunch for property/landowners.
- pjc50 7y agoIf only the UK had a real property tax.
- detritus 7y ago> Crossrail is a massive transfer of wealth from working people to wealthy land owners. Not that I particularly disagree with you, but I have two friends I'd consider 'working people' rather than 'land owners' who potentially benefit from increases in the value of their homes nearby the Crossrail improvements.