4 ms·
The US assassinates its own citizens without trial occasionally. Don't judge by the anomalies, judge by the everyday life for regular people.
by BurningFrog 7y ago
The US assassinates its own citizens without trial occasionally.
Don't judge by the anomalies, judge by the everyday life for regular people.
- Alupis 7y agoIt's a little bit different when the person had taken up arms against the nation, no? Should they get a court hearing? Probably. Is that practical, in some cases, if the person could be apprehended. Otherwise it would just be a pony show with a predetermined outcome, making no difference.
- thereare5lights 7y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Abdulrahman_al-Awlaki https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Abdulrahman_al-Awlaki Sometimes, they kill citizens and then effectively say shit happens.
- cc81 7y agoThe US also assassinates non citizens in other countries without trial that generally would not be accepted if other countries did the same in the US. i.e. China sending a drone and blowing up a US citizens car, killing him and his family, somewhere in the middle of US and just saying that they were terrorists and a threat to China's security; but not not providing any evidence as that is classified.
- chopin 7y agoThe right to a fair trial should not depend on whether it is practical.
- Alupis 7y agoThe thought was - without the individual at the trial with their own legal counsel - is it a fair trail anyway? If it's a military tribunal that rubber-stamps everything - does that improve the process any? Perhaps it would have been better in the specific case to first revoke the person's citizenship?
- chopin 7y agoMy thought was: Either the person is present and represented or there be no trial. This must not depend on whether presence is hard to achieve. Revoking citizenship or at least leaving persons stateless is not allowed under UN-Charta afaik. Even then, would you blatantly kill (or better, murder) people? That's not rule of law, but rule of jungle. And as uncivilized as it gets.
- Alupis 7y agoSpecifically, the known cases of this are people which have taken up arms against the nation, and joined a known terrorist organization. Potentially, even killing citizens of their former country. I don't see a way to capture and try such an individual without having more citizens put in harm's way, or killed too. If the individual is in a training camp that is targeted and happens to be killed as well - I personally don't think anything of it. But that is starkly different than assassinating some individual in their apartment or hotel, or whatever. To me, one is warfare, and the other is murder - I do make that distinction. Perhaps we must agree to disagree.
- roboys 7y agoUS police are the 6th leading cause of African American deaths. I watched an HK detainee get tortured in a hospital in horror, then remembered we kill thousands of unarmed people every couple years without any trial (many of whom are innocent) and 50-60% of victims are either mentally or physically disabled in some way. Many of them get tortured in similar ways if they make it to prison. In a different framing, the US looks pretty horrible in comparison to China. It's just that we have gotten used to our own brand of stink.
- BurningFrog 7y agoGeneral apolitical point: Phrases like "6th leading cause" contain no information. Is that 5% or 0.01%? There is no way of knowing, and depends entirely on how deaths are categorized in some unknown underlying classification system.
- whatshisface 7y agoYou don't think Chinese police have brutality incidents?
- lunchables 7y ago>US police are the 6th leading cause of African American deaths. No it's not. https://www.statista.com/statistics/233310/distribution-of-the-10-leading-causes-of-death-among-african-americans/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/233310/distribution-of-t... Only 215 black people were killed by police last year. >https://www.theroot.com/here-s-how-many-people-police-killed-in-2018-1831469528 https://www.theroot.com/here-s-how-many-people-police-killed...