4 ms·
I think a GUI app in 6MB is hugely impressive. Windows 3.11 required 4MB of RAM and the whole install took <20MB of disk space, and that's the entire OS with a
by userbinator 7y ago
I think a GUI app in 6MB is hugely impressive.
Windows 3.11 required 4MB of RAM and the whole install took <20MB of disk space, and that's the entire OS with all of its utilities and libraries.
A typical smartphone ships with around 10,000 times this much storage capacity and enough RAM to hold it 100 times over.
The fact that it can hold that much does not make it right to waste resources. To contrast, video or audio is a good use of the space it takes up in general, because there has been and continues to be research in compressing that data, and it's pretty close to being as small as it can practically be. Apps are not a good use of space because we know roughly what the lower limit is --- and the current average is a few orders of magnitude more than that.
- orf 7y ago> Windows 3.11 required 4MB of RAM and the whole install took <20MB of disk space, and that's the entire OS with all of its utilities and libraries. Sure, and the moon landing used computers with less processing power than your kids calculator. That doesn't mean we should use those to put people on the moon over faster hardware. Does the fact that older, slower and smaller hardware and software once existed mean we should spend time, resources and potentially sacrifice features to... what? Hark back to the old days where we had 128kb of memory and hard disks the size of vinyl records? A 6mb GUI app _is_ impressive for right now. At some point in time it would have been absolutely massive, and the way it's going, at some point in the future it may well be absolutely minuscule. And that's not a bad thing.
- mwcampbell 7y agoBut what if GUI applications that were considered lean and mean in the 90s were common on today's hardware? Wouldn't those applications be really fast and light on resources?
- littlestymaar 7y agoFast and light on resources isn't the same thing: a GPU-accelerated GUI toolkit is going to be bigger than a full software one, but also much faster on modern hardware.
- doboyy 7y agoI'm constantly torn between these two perspectives. Practically speaking, 6mb is fine. Ideologically, not as much. In general, complexity is indicative of a poorer design, and the fact that an entire operating system + utilities can be delivered in a comparable size to a gui app is hard to look away from. The author says, "Once you accept bloat, it’s very hard to claw it back". The fear is that bloat increases at higher rate in proportion to its capability and computing power. I'm cognizant that I'm very much in the minimalist camp with regard to computers, so I do make sure to peek outside and remind myself that stressing about an executable size is a bit unwarranted. But that being said, we must remain vigilant!
- adrianN 7y agoIf today's computers did things a million times better, or did a million more things than 25 years ago, I'd agree with you, but from a user perspective a modern computer is not really all that different from a Windows 3.11 machine. The screens are bigger and we have Internet now, but the experience of, e.g., writing a letter in Word is basically the same.
- floatboth 7y agoThe screens alone are responsible for a lot of size increases (framebuffers in RAM, high res media) but also, unlike in Windows 3.11, modern Word allows you to mix English, Japanese and Arabic in a document, allows use of a screen reader, and has a thousand features that you personally don't need but everyone has some set of features that they use, and taking away any of them would offend someone.
- pjmlp 7y agoAnd me thinking I already was able to do that with Word on NT 4.0 and Dragon NaturallySpeaking.
- leshow 7y agoIt's an apples to oranges comparison, you can't really say that one is "wasting" resources or not. If you want to use windows as an example. Why not take the current version? It uses what like 16GB for a basic install (I wouldn't know, I don't use it)? Compare the 6Mb GUI framework to that.