3 ms·
I think this is both a dumb move and unconstitutional. Present day politics aside, allowing for pure demographic voting in this day and age is even more danger
by Spooky23 7y ago
I think this is both a dumb move and unconstitutional.
Present day politics aside, allowing for pure demographic voting in this day and age is even more dangerous than it was in the early days of the republic.
States and regions have different needs that need to be considered in the governance of the nation. You can already see warning signs, the Democratic Party platform has been so brain dead, they even managed to marginalize union voters. Kansas and Wisconsin were progressive strongholds.
Changing the way we count isn’t a fix for that issue — fixing how candidates and parties approach the people is. A more productive approach would be to reduce the carnival nature of the election process... candidates shouldn’t be picked based on their ability to shuck and jive in Iowa and New Hampshire.
Direct popular vote is basically a beacon for reactionary politics. It’s easy to churn out old people to vote.
- lonelappde 7y agoWhat is unconstitutional about a state using its constitutional authority to cast its votes for President? Why should fictional state borders take precedence over actual humans when allocating voting blocs? If different states have difference needs, then those states residents will vote for leaders who serve them. Your problem seems to be that that giving supreme power to an arbitrary majority is flawed. And it surely is. But giving supreme power to an arbitrary minority is surely as bad or worse. Old people live in every state. If you have a problem with old people exercising their sacred voting right too much, surely the solution is to enable young people to vote, not give rural state citizens extra vote weight?
- Spooky23 7y agoDon’t put words in my mouth. My problem is that this is a solution looking for a problem. In fact, it’s a solution that will make the problem that some people want to solve far worse.