3 ms·
The Connecticut Compromise is good and all, but I think it's about time we discard it as an artifact of the days when communication was difficult and states had
by munk-a 7y ago
The Connecticut Compromise is good and all, but I think it's about time we discard it as an artifact of the days when communication was difficult and states had expectations around operating as semi-autonomous bodies. States used to be a strong identity tie than the nation but our general mindset has shifted toward identifying as Americans before Delawareans.
- thwythwy 7y agoLong live Delaware! You otherins shant try to come on err land and regalate err corporate forms.
- human20190310 7y agoIn a related anachronism... > In [Republican CO State Senator Sonnenberg's] view, the Electoral College was created so that “people in rural areas did not get overrun by the masses.” This can't be true since in 1790 (roughly the same time period the EC was created), "the masses" were rural; at that point only about 5% of the population was urban[0]. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Urbanization_in_the_United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Urbanization_in_the_United_Sta...
- Scramblejams 7y agoIn the US they were rural. The founders and early lawmakers took much inspiration from the histories and travails of other governments around the world.
- hannasanarion 7y agoWhich were also predominantly rural. There was no country on earth with a majority urban population until well into the 20th century.
- Scramblejams 7y agoNobody said cities needed a majority to inspire fear of the way they concentrated political power. The founders’ concerns about that are well-documented. A cursory search yielded a decent starting point: https://www.planetizen.com/node/18841 https://www.planetizen.com/node/18841
- hannasanarion 7y agoAnd nowhere did the founders say that the electoral college was intended to counteract it. Unlike most people today trying to come up with justifications for an obviously broken system, the founders knew that minority rule is worse than majority rule. In every document where the framers discuss "tyranny of the majority", it is clear that their solution is not minority rule, it is CONSENSUS. That is why the most important functions of government: constitutional changes, impeachments, censorship, rule changes, and veto overrides, require supermajorities. You don't overcome tyranny of the majority by letting minorities win. That's just regular tyranny.
- lonelappde 7y agoThe electoral college was created to protect Southern slavery. The "masses" he is speaking of were slaves, whose bodies were used to give voting power to their oppressors.
- _bxg1 7y agoFor some states - mostly red ones - that isn't true. Texans still identify primarily with their state. That said, it's still a stupid reason for giving fewer people more votes. There is no reasonable argument for that, no matter which way you slice it.
- munk-a 7y agoEeeeh... Texan's have a lot of state pride - but try confusing a Texan for a Delawarean vs. confusing a Texan with a Canadian or Kiwi - pretty sure the Texan will be more offended with either of those later confusions if they've got that weird patriotism streak.
- _bxg1 7y agoNot if you confuse them with a Californian.
- giggles_giggles 7y agoI think it's weird that you think patriotism is weird.
- s_y_n_t_a_x 7y agoAs an American and a Texan, I find it sad you think patriotism is weird.
- munk-a 7y agoI find patriotism to be weird because it's so arbitrary - patriotic immigrants get a pass, but natural born citizens didn't ever make an active choice or put in the effort to become a citizen. I also fail to see why people in one country should be inherently given benefits that people in another country lack... Patriotism to me boils down to a weird form of elitism.
- salawat 7y agoSuch an odd sentiment. It's not elitism in the conventional sense. It's an investment in the System passed down to you by your forebearers, and faith in it being something of value to maintain and eventually pass down to your descendants. >I also fail to see why people in one country should be inherently given benefits that people in another country lack... Do you understand the underlying driving concept behind the concept of a country's sovereignty? It's an understanding that the people of a certain geographical region are free to establish their own political systems of governance to get stuff done. It's kind of complicated now, because of the whole corpus of International recognition and that whole jazz, but the fundamentals remain the same. If you don't connect how patriotism comes out as a natural extension of investment with regards to the resulting structure that allows for the flexing of the country in question's capabilities to become greater than the sum of its parts...well... I can understand it to a point, but it strikes me as folding ones arms, sitting on a fence, and declaring everywhere is terrible. Which is okay too I suppose. Though, it likely won't ingratiate you to anyone. Especially considering it demonstrates an unwillingness to make any type of fundamental value judgement or to accept a particular corpus or ideal of government as being the yard stick you measure with. I.e. as an American, I measure other non-U.S. countries vs. how well their system guarantees freedoms enshrined in the national Bill of Rights . Heck, I judge my own country, and the various States that compose it at different time periods via how well it stays true to it's Constitutional intent, and the ideal of a government as laid out in the Declaration of Independence. Common Law divergence from Constitutional statute all have an impact, but I believe the system is about as good as it's going to get. Anyway. Not sure if I've done anything to clear it up. Just... Didn't want to scroll by without leaving something in response to such a solitary viewpoint.
- huffmsa 7y agoGreat, get your Article 5 wheels rolling.
- golemiprague 7y agoCommunication is good but the control of the communication and the media is in the coasts. All the media organisations and all the social networks are sitting in the coasts and run by people with a certain political agendas. I am actually amazed how relevant the idea of electoral college is even today. It gives people with no voice the power they deserve as it did 200 years ago.
- invalidOrTaken 7y agoThere's some impressive logical bootstrapping here. "States aren't autonomous anymore, so let's make the legal situation match that." Except, wait, why are you even spending your time talking about this? Because it impacts federal elections, right? Seems like some states are still autonomous, you just don't think they're legitimately so. https://dilbert.com/strip/1994-03-04 https://dilbert.com/strip/1994-03-04