44 ms·
I mean, you can't have your cake and eat it too - if you claim that a particular issue is not a bug and you won't fix it, then you have no ethical grounds to sa
by PeterisP 7y ago
I mean, you can't have your cake and eat it too - if you claim that a particular issue is not a bug and you won't fix it, then you have no ethical grounds to say that it shouldn't be disclosed.
Responsible disclosure expects delaying public disclosure to protect the users while the vendor prepares a fix. If the vendor says that they won't fix it, then it's not only a right, but a moral duty to disclose that vulnerability to the users.
- WrtCdEvrydy 7y agoI had the same argument with Coinbase about this one... Ended up naming it 'Bad QR', putting this page together and sending them a private link (https://writecodeeveryday.github.io/projects/badqr/ https://writecodeeveryday.github.io/projects/badqr/)
- joshstrange 7y agoPlease fix your jquery import, it's being blocked b/c it's coming over http not https
- WrtCdEvrydy 7y agoSorry about that, probably gonna switch to VanillaJS.
- dopamean 7y agoa great library.
- _coveredInBees 7y agoI couldn't find/install it via npm or yarn :-( ;-)
- wlesieutre 7y agoYou should consider The JAMstack, a new web paradigm where a user requests an HTML file and the server gives it to them.
- NullPrefix 7y agoTLS errors are out of scope. #WONTFIX. Don't you dare to talk about this publically. http://writecodeeveryday.github.io/projects/badqr/ http://writecodeeveryday.github.io/projects/badqr/
- WrtCdEvrydy 7y agoLOL. Banned from HackerOne.
- EnFinlay 7y agoThe researcher can still disclose it, they just aren't going to get permission to disclose it on the Hackerone program. Most things out of scope don't get publicly disclosed as far as I know. Doesn't seem too unreasonable.
- hitekker 7y ago> Kravets said he was banned from the platform following the public disclosure of the first zero-day. His bug report was heavily covered in the media, and Valve did eventually ship a fix, more as a reaction to all the bad press the company was getting. > The patch was almost immediately proved to be insufficient, and another security researcher found an easy way to go around it almost right away. You might want to read the article.
- EnFinlay 7y agoI was responding to a comment that (I interpreted) to be talking in more general terms than the scope of the article.
- danShumway 7y agoEven in the scope of the original comment, doesn't it create a pretty perverse incentive to allow companies to mark HackerOne bugs as WONTFIX and then ban researchers who disclose them? Isn't security through obscurity largely to be avoided? I thought the working model for most security researchers was: if it's not worth fixing, it's not worth hiding. More to the point, I thought that responsible disclosure always came with an expectation of public disclosure. The advice I've always been given is that you should never disclose with conditions -- ie. "fix this and I won't tell anyone." It should always be, "I am going to tell everyone, but I'm telling you first so you can push a fix before I do." Does HackerOne operate under different rules?
- fencepost 7y agoWithout seeing the communications it's hard to say, but "When the security researcher -- named Vasily Kravets-- wanted to publicly disclose the vulnerability, a HackerOne staff member forbade him from doing so, even if Valve had no intention of fixing the issue" sounds like more than just not being able to disclose on the H1 program.
- Mindless2112 7y agoFrankly, I think HackerOne deserves a bit of blame for that. Any WONTFIX ought to be made public automatically unless there are extenuating circumstances (like the vulnerability being reported against the wrong product).
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- daeken 7y agoH1 itself has no WONTFIX status, FYI. A bug that's not considered to be a bug by the program will either be closed N/A or informative. Ultimately, disclosures are handled and controlled by the program, not by H1; this is both a good and bad thing (and I say that as both a HackerOne employee and a hacker on the platform -- it's a complicated issue from both sides).
- kop316 7y agoIt's complicated on both sides means there is politics involved. Being blunt, that sounds like a cop out to me. This sounds to me like an edge case that H1 should address if it really wants to be taken seriously.
- daeken 7y agoThere is definitely politics involved, but not H1 internal. The issue is that every program handles disclosure itself, so H1 itself doesn't really have the power. That could be changed at a policy level, but I'm not sure that'll happen (or should happen, honestly; I don't really know where I land on it).
- chris_wot 7y agoH1 could make it a proviso if using their service that rejected but reports are automatically disclosed.
- 7y ago
- abtinf 7y agoI uninstalled Steam the moment I read the previous disclosure and Valve's approach to it. Any company that treats security as it used to be in the 90s ought to be shunned.
- babuskov 7y agoIf you don't need it, why did you have it installed in the first place?
- p1necone 7y agoNot sure what you're getting at. There's very few things we need, sounds like they're sacrificing a little to avoid giving a company they deem unethical any money.
- abtinf 7y agoI love games and can’t play my steam collection now. But if I have to give that up so that some silly bug elsewhere in my system doesn’t expose me to a ransomware attack (or worse), so be it. I’ll find another way.
- jay_kyburz 7y agoYou should be able to play games in your steam library. Just open your Steam\steamapps\common\ folder and find the exe for the game you want to play.
- cprecioso 7y agoSteam's DRM (CEG) customizes the executables so it won't play without the Steam client running and logged in to the correct account. There are lots of not-DRM-enabled games on Steam, but they're decidedly in the minority.
- StavrosK 7y agoThat's why GOG.com is my first choice. They even provide a nice Steam-like installer (unfortunately, no Linux version of the installer), while letting you download your games DRM-free, archivable and standalone.
- one2zero 7y agoYou would think that any platform/app that actually contains the ability to load currency into itself would take any security threat seriously regardless of the scope.