3 ms·
I'm a strong opponent of WASM because I think that WASM will break the internet the very same way and same reason ActiveX and Java applets broke it over 20 yea
by baybal2 7y ago
I'm a strong opponent of WASM because I think that WASM will break the internet the very same way and same reason ActiveX and Java applets broke it over 20 years ago.
An untrusted executable code, no matter how much sandboxed, virtualised, and isolated it is, would never be a good thing. It wasn't 20 years ago, and would never be, invariably of what "tech sauce" it is served with.
I advocate for proactive removal of WASM lobbyists from standard setting bodies, and countering their promotion of WASM.
- omn1 7y agoActiveX and Java applets were proprietary when they got introduced. WASM is an open standard that it supported by all browser vendors and already integrated without any third-party plugins. There is a spec for it that you can contribute to.
- baybal2 7y agoIt doesn't change a thing. Both ax and java were quite well documented and free for everybody to use, but they definitely broke the Internet for everybody without any exaggeration. I'll explain you why in the most neutral tone I can. Do you understand that biggest peddlers of inscrutinable executable format on the web are people who are not fine with the open nature of the Internet, and who can not make their business when all code available through the browser is available to at least minimal form of inspection? In other words, the people who are mad because they can't run business in the web because their business model depends on their code being closed, they WANT THIS big time. Their business thrives off non-interoperability and brokennes of software at large. Their success comes at the detriment of the Internet ecosystem at large. The more they brake the Internet for the rest of its users, the more money they can make, and this is why there can not be reconciliation with them and, us, the wider and more sane part of software developer community. And we, the engineering cadres, the most influential class of people in the new tech driven world, have all the influence needed to deny WASM adoption.
- AlexanderDhoore 7y agoModern minified javascript is just as inscrutable as anything else. For example, please try to read this code: https://apis.google.com/js/client.js https://apis.google.com/js/client.js You would need a "decompiler" to make anything out of that.
- Ajedi32 7y agoJavaScript is also "untrusted executable code". How is WASM any worse than JS? Do you also advocate for removing ECMAScript lobbyists from standards bodies, and countering their promotion of JavaScript?
- 6gvONxR4sf7o 7y agoThe very first sentence in the article is >People are excited about running WebAssembly outside the browser. This article isn't about the internet. Read through it with a mindset of webassembly outside of web. It's an interesting article.