4 ms·
I've been hearing about the return of Zeppelins since the 1980s. Still hasn't happened. > But for all their high-tech advances, Hunt said, the new airships wou
by eesmith 7y ago
I've been hearing about the return of Zeppelins since the 1980s. Still hasn't happened.
> But for all their high-tech advances, Hunt said, the new airships would still get their buoyancy from hydrogen, a highly flammable gas that is 14 times lighter than air. It’s the same gas the Hindenburg and the other big zeppelins used in the 1930s.
As a reminder, the Hindenburg was originally designed for helium. They were unable to get the US to lift its ban on the export of helium under the Helium Control Act of 1927.
> As an additional bonus, Hunt said, the fuel cell would generate as a byproduct water that could be released as the craft passed over regions hit by drought.
That's isn't much amount of water, and certainly not enough to affect a drought.
Figuring 2km long x 200m x 200m that's about 3E9 mol of gas. You need some lifting gas for the vehicle weight - call it 1E9 mol or 5E8 mol of water, which is 30K tons. That's 27 acre feet, which appears to be enough for about 15 acres of potatoes for a growing season, using numbers from https://www.ardentmills.com/media/1725/colorado-quinoa-sustainability-story.pdf https://www.ardentmills.com/media/1725/colorado-quinoa-susta... .
And I think I'm highly over-estimating.
- gus_massa 7y agoNote that 15 acres ~= 2km x 30m, i.e. if the ship in 200m ~= 600ft tall, then the area that can be irrigated is only 1/6 of the shadow.
- jsilence 7y agoWell at least for now we are not running out of Helium: www.ox.ac.uk/news/2016-06-28-huge-helium-discovery-life-saving-find
- input_sh 7y agoBut... we are. We're using it at a rate that's faster than the rate it is produced in. Just because we find a pocket or two that we haven't found before doesn't mean that the problem is gone. The new pockets are usually more difficult to extract helium from, and storing it and transporting it is a painful process to say the least. The problem won't be truly gone until we find a way to gather it from outer space.
- zihotki 7y agoBut still there is only a finite amount of it and with each use it disappears into the sky. It's not sustainable and not renewable so it's use must be limited and controlled if we want to leave some of it for future humanity.
- thombat 7y agoPresumably the generated water will be released immediately rather than being condensed to a holding tank, since weight is the enemy of all aircraft (c.f. airliners, which jettison condensate and "grey water" from sinks but hold the foul water from toilets). So there will be a continuous low-volume release of steam/warm water some hundreds of metres above the ground - in dry conditions it doesn't seem likely it will even reach the ground.
- mannykannot 7y agoeesmith is right; the amount of water is utterly negligible in this context. As it happens, however, the helium airships USS Akron and USS Macon had large condensers to recover the water from the exhaust, to reduce the amount of helium needed to be vented to compensate for the reduction in fuel weight. They can be seen as vertical stripes above the propellers. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/USS_Akron#/media/File:USS_Akron_in_flight,_nov_1931.jpg https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/USS_Akron#/media/File:USS_Akro... Venting hydrogen is not nearly as expensive a proposition as venting helium. Nevertheless, the Graf Zeppelin was fueled by blau gas, which has a density almost the same as air, to avoid the issue. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blau_gas https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blau_gas
- DrScump 7y agoFun fact: the original hangar at Moffett Field in Sunnyvale was built for the U.S.S. Macon.
- thombat 7y agoInteresting! I guess that's cheaper/lighter than compressing the helium back to storage tanks. I remember reading that one of the "new Zeppelin" firms planned to rotate the propulsion thrusters to create a downwards thrust when berthing, I think also to reduce problems with excess buoyancy when handling cargo.
- PietdeVries 7y agoWhat would the force of the wind be on a structure 2 km long and 200 meter wide? Just a little breeze will require an amazing force just to keep the thing docked. Think that you have to maneuvre the thing into position...
- eesmith 7y agoIt's 2+ km long when at elevation. From the paper at https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S2590174519300145?via=ihub https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S259017451... : > Docking airships is challenging due to their large size, limited control mechanisms, and high wind drag. Another particular issue is to keep the airship attached to the ground during windy episodes. The diameter of the airship hydrogen carrier (Fig. 2) is similar to the height of the Empire State Building in New York. It would be very challenging to keep such large airship from collapsing under strong superficial winds. On the other hand, balloon hydrogen carriers are not rigid and vary in size. Their volume on the ground is around seven times smaller than in the stratosphere (assuming a maximum operation height of 15 km). This is convenient because the size of the balloon hydrogen carrier on the ground is only 58% larger than the Hindenburg class airship