9 ms·
Electronic voting and vote counting machines pose one of the greatest threats to democracy. We should really just go back to paper ballots, which are not perfe
by pmoriarty 7y ago
Electronic voting and vote counting machines pose one of the greatest threats to democracy.
We should really just go back to paper ballots, which are not perfect but are a lots less hackable at scale and are much more trackable than electronic machines are.
- LocalPCGuy 7y agoOr if we do use machines, we should use hand-marked paper ballots for the act of voting and just use machines to count up the results.
- sli 7y agoThis is how I've always voted in Florida.
- tunesmith 7y agoThe really dumb problem with those is that the vote counts are stored in removable media - back in 2000 they were often referred to as "cartridges", and when mandated to do a recount, certain election officials choose to interpret it as just checking again what vote counts were reported by the cartridges. Or worse, just checking their Access database again that they put the vote count into, to re-read the vote totals there. This is some of what happened during the 2000 recounts. Ballots that were supposed to be recounted were never actually physically recounted. Still, better than touchscreens, if you can mandate audits and that recounts actually mean counting the physical ballots themselves.
- runako 7y ago> in Florida This is not a vote of confidence for this particular method.
- Someone1234 7y agoWhich combines the best of both (speed and audit-ability). But you'd need mandatory random audits, and a legal requirement to keep the paper originals for up to years. There's been cases of the paper ballots being destroyed while legal action was ongoing, and a never audited system cannot be trusted (because there's implied trust, not tested trust).
- pmoriarty 7y agoRelying on randomness is not good enough, not for voting. A chance, no matter how small, of a different candidate than the one actually voted in by the people getting in to office is not worth the risk.
- mikeash 7y agoThat chance always exists. Your choices are to minimize it or pretend it doesn’t exist, but there’s no way to actually eliminate it.
- gbrown 7y agoNo matter how small? What about one in a million? One in ten million? This is literally what statistics is for - randomness is a powerful tool against fraud, not some weak cop-out.
- Someone1234 7y agoI was talking about random audits on top of targeted audits if suspicious activity exists just to be clear. Routine double counting all votes would be controversial due to the high cost.
- greglindahl 7y agoI've never seen anyone advocate abolishing recounts for close races. Random audits all of the time is an addition to current procedures, not a replacement.
- rhinoceraptor 7y agoWe already have an 11% failure rate for the presidency, and it has nothing to do with recording votes accurately.
- umanwizard 7y agoWhy? If the result is 49.999% vs. 50.001%, you cannot conclude anything meaningful about the will of the people. Maybe the weather was just slightly worse in a neighborhood supporting the losing candidate and it tipped the result slightly. So even if the voting process is perfect, that close of a result is totally random for other reasons. Most people don't seem to be capable of thinking about non-determinism like this, though. Witness the huge number of Americans who think the presidential election is illegitimate because Trump got 46% of the vote to Clinton's 48%, when honestly 46 vs. 48 is very little difference in terms of what they mean about the general will about Americans. On the other end of the political spectrum, witness the amount of Brits who think a 52-48 vote to leave the EU is somehow relevant. In calculus/analysis terms: this is why proportional representation parliamentary systems are better -- because the function from "how many people support which parties" to "what policies you end up with" is not discontinuous. If the UK ran on a proportional system, they'd be getting some sort of very soft, Norway model Brexit. If the US did, a center-right Democrat like Clinton or Biden would be PM.
- munk-a 7y agoI'm also okay with a recipe based system, where a snazzy machine UI is used to produce a paper record of the vote.
- isostatic 7y agoWhy does America have problems counting? I went to watch a count for the local elections in May in the UK (I was a candidate) The papers were counted in front of me and dozens of other people from the various parties. I could see each one going into each pile of ten, each pile of ten being bundled as a pile of 100 and put into a basket, the ambiguous ones (blank, voting for multiple candidates, writing "WANK" next to all candidates but one (which had "NOT WANK" written next to it), went into a separate pile. At the end of the counting the returning officer went through the ambiguous ones with the candidate or agent and explained if he would accept it or not. This doesn't take long - it scales, and is fully repeatable by completely different people if needed. The problems that seem to occur are not in the count, but in the returning officers (who tend to be doddery old men) writing the wrong result down, and for some reason this result is final, but that's the same whatever the counting method.
- komali2 7y agoWas not wank counted as a vote? Reminds me of the line from some American tv show where one character says "I don't vote, I just write down Jesus," and another says "we count that as a Republican vote."
- isostatic 7y agoYup (although that wasn't at my count, or indeed election - there are rules about secrecy so I couldn't possibly comment on some of the actual comments) https://www.joe.co.uk/politics/voter-writes-wnk-all-over-ballot-paper-puts-not-wnk-next-to-greens-deemed-acceptable-as-a-vote-233070 https://www.joe.co.uk/politics/voter-writes-wnk-all-over-bal...
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 7y agoSince a lot of the ways we do things in the states are pretty ridiculous, I feel the need to clarify for foreigners that this does not actually fly. As I recall, it was only a few election cycles ago someone in my state had been convicted of vote fraud for for filling in the republican candidate option on votes that were left blank on ballots which had otherwise voted republican on every other vote. This amounted to two modified ballots.
- ascagnel_ 7y agoI'd go the other way -- use machines to mark ballots in a human-readable way, so that manual processes can be used to validate the machine processes be questioned. The whole electronic voting movement started because people had difficulty with ballots in Florida; a _good_ UI would help alleviate this.
- nerdponx 7y agoThis is how New York does it.
- skrowl 7y agoPaper ballot tied to a voter via a strong voter ID + electronic counting is the best of both worlds. You get the speed of automation with a paper trail in case you have to go back and audit. EDIT for those replying that you feel voting should be anonymous. With anonymous voting, how do you stop the "hey we just found this box of filled in ballots" ala Broward County Florida every election? If you can't tie a ballot back to a voter, how do you know the ballot is legitimate?
- mffnbs 7y agoDepends on what you mean by voter ID.
- cryptoz 7y agoWhat is a "strong voter ID"? This sounds like voter disenfranchisement or a poll tax, or both (and both are unconstitutional). Voters are not required to have ID, nor should they be. Not everyone has an ID, and many states have specifically passed laws to make it more expensive and more difficult for some people to get government-issued photo ID. Without a massive outreach program intended to reach all voters and supply them with convenient, free of charge voter IDs, and a system that can continuously and quickly resolve errors, such a "strong voter ID" would be unconstitutional (for good reason).
- blackflame7000 7y agoThen we need to fix the problem of people not getting ID instead of using it as an excuse not to secure out elections
- mikeash 7y agoIt solves a problem that doesn’t exist in practice and is impossible to exploit at scale even in theory. It would be good, but it’s not terribly important.
- blackflame7001 7y ago
- sbmthakur 7y agoMaybe yes. But in a populous country like India there were lot of issues when we used to vote with ballot paper: https://www.quora.com/Why-does-India-not-use-ballot-papers-for-voting/answer/Arup-Saha https://www.quora.com/Why-does-India-not-use-ballot-papers-f...
- tdcbfdct3 7y agoNearly every demonstration of voting machine hacking has required unrestricted physical access to the machine and tools/keys. Paper ballot boxes are just as hackable at scale with those requirements.
- cf498 7y ago>Paper ballot boxes are just as hackable at scale with those requirements. No they arent. You need one guy with physical access to to a machine, at any time, to screw an election, with manual counting you need everyone in the room conspiring to rig the election during the voting hours. With the possibility to volunteer to count votes and publishing the voting numbers for each voting station, you just dont get those situations. I know its an unpopular statement, but having a democratic election is not a new problem to solve. Most western countries do it just fine. This is not a problem with the concept of paper ballots but a absurdly broken system.
- dheera 7y agoNot only that, but paper ballots are a threat to the species, which IMO is a bigger threat than a threat to democracy. I think we should be asking ourselves how to make electronic voting feasible and secure, NOT dismissing it blindly as not possible and refusing to even try.
- lucasmullens 7y ago> paper ballots are a threat to the species What? How?
- bjornjaja 7y agoPretty sure this would be a good application for blockchain technology, which would work better than pen and paper and open to the public!
- bduerst 7y agoIs this satire? https://xkcd.com/2030/ https://xkcd.com/2030/
- dwheeler 7y agoI hope it's satire. Anyone who thinks that paperless voting machines are acceptable for non-trivial elections should first see https://www.xkcd.com/2030/ https://www.xkcd.com/2030/ , and then look at https://www.verifiedvoting.org/ https://www.verifiedvoting.org/
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- uncletaco 7y agoThe problem with "open to the public" is it opens up an avenue of reprisal. Let's say your parks department were headed by a libertarian guy who vehemently opposes using public funds to fill a landfill and turn it into a park and he finds out his deputy voted for the ordinance to spend the money on said park. He could retaliate. Another hypothetical could involve your local councilman finding out which members of his district voted for him and which didn't, and using that knowledge to influence who's streets get priority when plowing snow this winter and which don't. Any voting system, including those based on blockchain, should be designed in such a way that disclosure of someone's vote is entirely up to them.
- tangent128 7y agoAdditionally, disclosure of one's vote can't be provable, or the failure to prove you voted "correctly" can itself invite retaliation.
- Alupis 7y agoPaper and mail-in ballots aren't without their problems too - vote harvesting comes to mind.
- Klathmon 7y agovote harvesting is only an issue with mail-in or absentee ballots. in-person paper voting doesn't suffer from that problem, because you walk into the voting area, write your vote on a piece of paper, then you yourself place it into the box, and you can then stand there and watch the ballot box with your own eyes until they are counted, at which point you can count along.
- JSavageReal 7y agoLuddite. Electronic voting is inevitable, and far superior if done in a transparent untamperable way (eg. utilizing a publicly verifiable blockchain). I don't know why you guys have so much faith in paper voting when there are many instances of it being tampered with in even first world countries.