11 ms·
A Look at HS2's Old Oak Common Station
- Neil44 7y agoI don't like the soundbite about it only shaving X minutes off the trip to Birmingham. That's practically the first stop. The thing goes all the way to Leeds. It's a disingenuous soundbite. I realise the authour here is using it as a construct to argue against but I head this soundbite a lot.
- growlist 7y agoHSTs are cool, but I think it's a valid criticism - would it really make so much difference to run at 125mph and the journey take a little longer? And would the project be cheaper if it didn't need to be so super-straight in order to be able to achieve the high speeds? If they were proposing express trains that would really gain the benefit of the line I could see the justification, but they're not are they?
- jnty 7y agoYes - the speed is required for capacity, to minimise journey times to Scotland and ensure competitiveness with air travel and other existing links. Even for closer destinations like Birmingham 35 minutes is a huge improvement on a ~1h20m journey.
- TheOtherHobbes 7y agoFirstly, there isn't all that much of anything in Birmingham that makes this worthwhile. At best there might be some new business development in 10-20 years, but it's not at all obvious that Birmingham is somehow going to become London's second business centre because of HS2. Most of the claims in this piece are simply nonsense. The Euston to Crewe train that's mentioned doesn't go anywhere near Birmingham, so it's not obvious that HS2 would make much of a difference to traffic on it. And even if it did, it's merely one of a large number of routes heading out of London in all directions that are ridiculously overcrowded. At best, HS2 might reduce a small proportion of that overcrowding, but it's certainly not going to eliminate it. The idea that HS2 can make Birmingham airport competitive with Heathrow for Londoners is clearly wrong. Birmingham doesn't have the flights, the destinations, or the capacity. London also has Heathrow Express for quick train journeys from Paddington to Heathrow - concourse to concourse. Even with a shorter journey time, HS2 can't match that. And HS2 doesn't start to make sense until Phase 2 is built, linking Sheffield, Manchester and Leeds. You might see some benefits then - but the realistic total cost is likely to be the far side of £100bn. Which is madness. It's actually five years of the total NASA budget, which is supposed to pay for development of the next Lunar program, as well as everything else NASA does. It would be much better to spend a much smaller sum making the UK's broadband the best in Europe, set up a world-leading incubator fund for digital startups outside of London, with next-generation training and education, and try to persuade existing corporates to consider home working options. The return on that would be huge. This is just a giant train set for rail nostalgists.
- tonyedgecombe 7y agoFirstly, there isn't all that much of anything in Birmingham that makes this worthwhile. If you let that be a guide then you wouldn't invest in anything outside of London.
- DanBC 7y ago> there isn't all that much of anything in Birmingham that makes this worthwhile. The UK has a weird chicken and egg thing going on. Everything is in London because everything is in London. HS2 is an attempt to break out of that. By developing better rail links across England we allow companies to start moving out of London. > The idea that HS2 can make Birmingham airport competitive with Heathrow for Londoners is clearly wrong. But that's not the aim. The aim is that we shouldn't have everyone in the country using Heathrow for all journeys. Currently we have about 80 million people going through Heathrow which is stupid if a chunk of them are only using it to get into the UK. London doesn't just have Heathrow and Gatwick. London has six international airports. Heathrow alone at 80m people currently carries the equivalent of Manchester, Edinburgh, Birmingham, Glasgow, and Bristol combined. We urgently need to fix this.
- growlist 7y ago> The UK has a weird chicken and egg thing going on. Everything is in London because everything is in London. HS2 is an attempt to break out of that. One of the criticisms of HS2 is that it will just facilitate centralisation in London, by helping people get there more quickly!
- isostatic 7y agoIt means that a business that needs to occasionally meet people face to face in London can instead be based in Crewe, saving £10k a month in rent and saving in salaries.
- jbb123 7y agoExcept that it's more likely to have people saying why do we need a crewe office at all when people can be at the main office in an hour anyway. It will just drag even more resources to london
- deadbunny 7y ago> and ensure competitiveness with air travel Good one. I can hop on a plane from London to Edinburgh tomorrow for £35 and be there in an hour and a half, call it 3 hours all in. By comparison I can hop on a train and it'll cost me £146 and take about 5 hours. Hell, just last week I hopped on a ferry to France and back on a whim for less than it would have cost to go 20 miles by train.
- jnty 7y agoCost is a different issue - I'd be very surprised if the subsidy profile of planes vs. trains vs. motoring stays the same over the coming decade. Unless you live airside at Heathrow and your destination is the Edinburgh duty free shop, I sincerely doubt your journey will take 1.5 hours total. More realistic timings allowing for 30mins travel either end and arriving an hour early for your flight bring it up to 3.5h - the fastest current London-Edinburgh expresses are just over 4 hours. At those timings, high speed rail starts to look quite attractive, considering it's much easier to work and relax on a train and you don't have to waste time shuffling through the airport and waiting in queues.
- isostatic 7y agoI used to fly regularly from Manchester (Near Altrincham) to London (Near Hammersmith) t+0 leave office t+45 arrive Heathrow t+90 wheels up t+145 wheels down t+150 in taxi t+160 home Compare to t+0 leave office t+45 arrive Euston t+60 train departs t+170 arrive Wilmslow t+175 in taxi t+195 home On the way down it was even quicker by plane t+0 leave home t+7 arrive manchester t+10 arrive gate t+25 wheels up t+85 wheels down t+145 arrive office
- smcl 7y agoIf it took you 15 minutes from the plane hitting the ground in Manchester to get to your house, I think that says more that you live really near to (or next to? inside?) Manchester airport. And 10 minutes between leaving your front door to arriving at the gate!? That's either a slight exaggeration or an impressive feat
- growlist 7y agoWill there be any true express trains though? Surely the stops along the way reduce the reduction in travel time significantly. If there are going to be non-stop trains from London to Scotland it's a different proposition.
- isostatic 7y agoCurrently the trains out of euston to use HS2 are typically (there's occasional extra stops in the peak) 1tph First Stop Warrington (2h20) 1tph First Stop Crewe (1h40) 1tph First Stop Stafford (1h20) 1tph First Stop Stoke (1h30) 2tph First Stop Rugby (1h) 1tph First stop Coventry (1h10) There's other trains that stop at Milton Keynes that will move too (Wales, Manchester), with far more additional trains stopping at MKC Some make additional stops in the peak, but that won't happen with HS Typical HS2 service will be Euston (for Crossrail2/Northern Line) OOC (for Crossrail/GWR/Heathrow) -- 5 miles Birmingham Interchange -- 100 miles Crewe -- 160 miles Or Euston (for Crossrail2/Northern Line) OOC (for Crossrail/GWR/Heathrow) -- 5 miles Birmingham Interchange -- 100 miles Birmingham Central -- 150 miles With some trains non stop from OOC to Manchester Airport (175m)
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- isostatic 7y ago> would it really make so much difference to run at 125mph and the journey take a little longer? It's halving the time from Crewe to London from 100m to 50m, so that's a big plus. Every train going to Manchester, Liverpool, North Wales, North West England and Scotland will be an hour quicker - that's a 2 hour saving on a day trip. > And would the project be cheaper if it didn't need to be so super-straight in order to be able to achieve the high speeds No, the extra cost for high speed is negligable in the open country. If it's not straight it's using more land.
- pjc50 7y agoWhat people keep overlooking is that HS2 is not a replacement for the existing line, but will run along side it. It's a capacity doubler as much as anything else. Some people will get faster trips to Birmingham, but a lot more people will get to make that trip - and also to the commuter stops along the existing line, as all the direct-to-Birmingham people take HS2.
- afarrell 7y agoIt also means that the smaller trips in the midlands and north don't need to get out of the way of a direct line from Manchester->London.
- switch007 7y agoThere is a lot of North north of Manchester and Leeds
- detritus 7y agoAs someone from the North who considers themself ‘British’ rather than Scottish or English, I've always viewed Yorkshire as the ‘midlands’ :) Joking aside, if Britain is every to grow beyond being quite so London-centric, we do really have to focus on the belt from Manchester to Hull more, North East too.
- sweeneyrod 7y agoThe question is to what extent increasing capacity like this will actually be useful. Trains from regional cities to/from London at non-peak times usually don't run at capacity in my experience, so they shouldn't be affected. For peak times, I'm not sure there are many people who would travel at approximately the current prices (this may be changed by HS2 but not immediately). Therefore assuming an efficient market I would expect the main benefit of increasing supply to be a drop in price at peak times. But assuming anything about British public transport is efficient is a risky bet.
- 7y ago
- C1sc0cat 7y agoIts a massive Saving in time
- arethuza 7y ago"And as it’s going to last 200+ years, let’s do it properly." And the day after this article was written the UK government announces a review of HS2 - probably for rather short term political reasons: https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-politics-49420332 https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-politics-49420332
- benj111 7y agoRemind me again how that fits in with the Brexit narrative? I thought we were going to be standing tall, thrusting forward, open for business. Or does that mean tall ships plying their trade in Boris Johnsons mind???
- agent008t 7y agoMaking Britain more attractive for business than the EU does not sound that difficult, to be fair.
- TheOtherHobbes 7y agoApparently more difficult than making the UK less attractive for business - which seems to be the current plan.
- smcl 7y agoIt's a cute remark and I certainly don't disagree that the government (hell, even the opposition) are handling the situation horribly. But the sad reality is that post-Brexit the UK government is free to be more business friendly. I say "sad reality" because this is not necessarily good for the general public - we could see healthcare opened up to private US companies, we could see workers rights eroded, reduced responsibilities for companies, emissions standards relaxed, food standards relaxed ... Tories whine about Brussels forcing all of this stuff onto the UK, they'll gleefully strip it away at the first opportunity. It might turn out to be good for business after all, but in the same way the Iraq war was.
- philpem 7y agoCan't see why this has hit the front page. It's not really a look at Old Oak Common so much as a long spiel about why HS2 is Gonna Be Great (tm).
- arethuza 7y agoBecause people voted for it as it is quite interesting?
- vidarh 7y agoAnd likely because it's hit during the morning in the UK and there's just been articles about a review of HS2 potentially putting it at risk due to large cost overruns.
- philpem 7y agoI was thinking more along the lines that I was expecting something about the station itself, engineering challenges and so forth -- not a thinly-veiled puff piece for HS2.
- peteretep 7y agoSomeone at HS2 PR needs to hire this man and then connect him to a subeditor
- isostatic 7y agoInt he last few months HS2 has swung it's PR to emphasise the capacity -- although they still aren't giving concrete or even example figures of what that means (12tph from Milton Keynes for example)
- UglyToad 7y agoA good summary of the main points in favour of HS2 that almost no-one in English media or politics is making. This article, which is unfortunately now paywalled, covers a lot of the same ground: https://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/home-news/hs2-logistics-financial-benefit-controversy-a8937936.html https://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/home-news/hs2-logistic... HS2 is one of those projects that's unpopular across the political spectrum and unfortunately seems like it's under threat, but the arguments in this post make a lot of sense and they're just not being made more broadly.
- Catsandkites 7y agoAs someone who spent a lot of time in London I hope he is correct about the track capacity released for local trains once the intercity move to the new lines. Two stopping trains per hour between local stations is not enough and if any were cancelled or delayed it created hell. I left partly because the commute to work sometimes took 2.5 hours each way and was ultimately draining. And that was living on the outskirts.
- isostatic 7y ago> As someone who spent a lot of time in London I hope he is correct about the track capacity released for local trains once the intercity move to the new lines. Well of course there is. There's currently 10 trains an hour in each direction that run non-stop through Milton Keynes. There could easily be an initial service along the lines of Slow lines 6tph London-Harrow-Watford-Stations to MKC 6tph London-Watford-Hemel-Leighton-Bletchley-MKC Fast lines 6tph London-Watford-MKC-Northampton 4pth London-Watford-MKC-Rugby-All_stops_TrentValley-Stafford 4pth London-Watford-MKC-Rugby-Coventry-Airport-Birmingham And I suspect stops at OOC will come too.
- makomk 7y agoHe's correct that there will be more track capacity. The question is whether it'll be used if a significant chunk of passenger traffic ends up getting moved to HS2. It might be that because the loss of traffic makes it less economically viable to operate trains on the existing routes, some stations actually end up getting served less frequently.
- avianlyric 7y agoI don’t see how HS2 can move significant amounts of local traffic off local lines. It’s a high speed intercity line that only has a few stops (compared to a local or commuter service). It can’t provide local services, it doesn’t have the stations or the track to do so. It also won’t be high speed of it stopped every 10miles.
- stordoff 7y ago
- growlist 7y agoGreat piece. But if our goal is increased capacity, perhaps HS2 isn't the best way to do it - are there cheaper and slower alternatives? And if this is an either/or decision, there are alternative proposals that are absolutely worth of consideration - some scandalously poor situations up North for example. I just can't help feeling this is yet another example of the public being stitched up by their taxes being funnelled to a financial bonanza for the politicians' chums.
- jnty 7y agoBasically, no - upgrades to the existing rail network are exceedingly expensive and disruptive (the whole East Coast Mainline is basically closing this weekend because a single junction needs to be renewed.) HS2 provide lots of fast intercity capacity meaning existing lines can be freed up for a massive enhancement to local services. The high speed also helps reduce demand for domestic air travel which is vital for combating the climate emergency. This map shows where capacity will be unlocked: https://twitter.com/HS2ltd/status/1158403767756316672 https://twitter.com/HS2ltd/status/1158403767756316672 And this comprehensively explains why more capacity is needed and a new high speed railway is the solution: https://medium.com/@garethdennis/high-speed-two-and-the-need-for-speed-91d8c68c5d80 https://medium.com/@garethdennis/high-speed-two-and-the-need...
- tempguy9999 7y agoAs it stands I don't believe this. I'll happily accept that new tracks need to be built, and to support higher speed, but going up to "400 km/h (250 mph)" (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/High_Speed_2 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/High_Speed_2) seems pure dickwaving. From your article "Yet the story doesn’t seem to be getting through. As engineers, it is not just our duty to create new infrastructure, it is also our duty to communicate its purpose. Helping the British public to get behind High Speed 2 must be a priority for our industry if we are to truly make this megaproject a success." Translation: shut up and swallow, plebs. I'd like to know what incremental cost there is for an increment of higher speed - I bet I know the shape of that graph. If you want higher capacity, let me know why longer trains don't work. New line yes, gouging expense for national vanity, no.
- agent008t 7y agoMy concern is that it will cost a lot of money but ultimately not deliver a reliable, fast, comfortable service. For some reasons Brits seem incapable of delivering great railway services. The Calendonian Express fiasco is just the latest example - an amazing idea that could have been absolutely fantastic, completely ruined by the awful implementation. As a taxpayer, I would much rather the work was contracted out to the Japanese that built the Shinkansen services. But for some strange reason that seems politically unpopular.
- tobylane 7y agoIt will be reliable and fast because it's on its own tracks. It'll be comfortable because those tracks are new, and the high ticket price requires decent seats. I'm surprised by your concerns. Try out HS1. Like with Hinckley and various other grand projects I'd rather we taught ourselves how to do it. Only HS2a has passed into law, b&c, HS3 and Crossrail2 are still to come.
- agent008t 7y ago1. Are constant delays and signal failures on existing tracks because the tracks are old, and so new tracks would not have these problems? 2. The Caledonian Express also has high ticket prices, yet the service is completely shambolic.
- pjc50 7y ago> Are constant delays and signal failures on existing tracks because the tracks are old, and so new tracks would not have these problems? Yes. This is also why the Tube and the NYC metro have such big problems compared to more recently built systems.
- NikkiA 7y agoIt's not the 'tracks' per se, as in the lumps of metal on the ground, but more frequently it's the design of the segment of the route. A piece of route might have been designed in the 1800s, possibly to a speed limit of 20 or 30mph, then been rationalised and 'upgraded' over the years to a higher speed, but that section of track will still carry limitations that are implied by the way it was initially designed to be, signalling may be too close together, or too far apart, junctions that are rarely used but remain for whatever reason add complexity and potential failure sites, tracks. There are of course some physical aspects of physically old track - shorter (~100m) sections of rail joined together have a higher risk of failure than the newer techniques of long (0.5km to 1km or more) single track pieces welded together, old wooden sleepers allow track movement that can result in delays and maintenance issues, whereas relative-new concrete sleepers, and really-new split-concrete sleepers are more reliable and permit faster and more reliable train operation. Tearing routes apart and redesigning the sections from scratch is difficult politically, so the UK's railway network tends to suffer from the fact that 99% of it was designed and built before 1880.
- michaelt 7y agoI've always wondered if the government could defray the cost of HS2 by buying some blocks of cheap farmland in the middle of nowhere, adding a HS2 station so the land was 20 minutes from central London, then selling the land to property developers. Obviously you could only add one or two towns, to avoid creating slow stopping services. Seems to me that could increase the housing supply and offset the costs of HS2 at the same time - and most governments have had plans for new towns, new garden cities and suchlike.
- heavenlyblue 7y agoProbably because “20 minutes from central London” is too short even for high-speed trains to reach any cheap farmland. That’s like... Croydon distance from London Bridge?
- petercooper 7y agoSo this thread got me thinking about the practicalities.. the HS1 speed to Ebbsfleet (25 miles out of London and outside the M25) is 18 minutes which includes a stop at Stratford. HS2 is designed to run a little faster and if you nixed the stop I think 30-35 miles could realistically be 20 minutes out of London on HS2. That sticks you right in the middle of the Chilterns if you follow HS2's rough direction.. probably not ideal for a town. Add another 5 minutes, though, and there's a lot of open land just south-east of Oxford and just off of the M40 too..
- tialaramex 7y agoSo you're correct that the Chilterns aren't ideal - those are dormitory villages, already very expensive, I grew up there. The open land near Oxford will be open because it's a swamp. If you could build on it cheaply somebody would.
- chrisseaton 7y ago> buying some blocks of cheap farmland in the middle of nowhere, adding a HS2 station so the land was 20 minutes from central London, then selling the land to property developers. Obviously you could only add one or two towns, to avoid creating slow stopping services I don't think any such land ('cheap', 'middle of nowhere', '20 mins from central London') exists in the UK.
- Theodores 7y agoIf you have a 'tube level' map of London in your head it is not obvious why HS2 goes through Old Oak Common. Euston is North and Paddington (which Old Oak Common traditionally services) is West of the capital. Some commentators in this post have questioned why the article is called what it is when it is just about HS2. For me I think that the title is apt and I now have so much more clarified. This is a really good article and I finally understand and like the project. Before I didn't give a damn about it.
- Tsiklon 7y agoThe majority of stuff leaving Euston leaves on the West Coast Main Line. This nearly touches the Great Western Main Line near Old Oak Common - with just Kensal Green Cemetery separating the two. Having a large junction with GWML, Crossrail and Overground traffic would appear to be very appealing when it comes to giving additional choice to travellers. As for not planning another exit route out of Euston, I'd imagine that there's a significant planning headache in routing new tunnels around the existing infrastructure in and around Euston, and that having the line shadow the existing WCML is much less painful to both plan and develop. Paddington has had a significant amount of work done to it recently with the Crossrail work going into it. Though it doesn't appear to suffer the access issues that Euston has it may prove to be a headache if HS2 traffic was supposed to arrive alongside GWML traffic.
- Animats 7y agoAw, high speed rail to Birmingham. "Let's go to Birmingham".[1] [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NmPzB0qTy4M https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NmPzB0qTy4M
- mothsonasloth 7y agoAs a Scot, I am skeptical how HS2 is going to improve the Edinburgh and Glasgow lines to London. Considering they don't go via Birmingham (they go Warrington, Stoke, Milton Keynes)
- arethuza 7y agoIt looks like trains could switch to HS2 tracks just south of York - which is about half way between London and Edinburgh: https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-scotland-scotland-business-47412170 https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-scotland-scotland-business-474... What effect a detour via Birmingham on HS2 has on times to/from Scotland is another question!
- pmyteh 7y agoThe west coast HS2 route threads between Birmingham and the existing West Coast Main Line, with a branch to Birmingham and a branch to join up with the WCML at (IIRC) around Crewe. It's a little less direct than the existing route, but engineered a lot faster. The other dirty not-quite-secret about HS2 is that it's not mainly about high speed. The WCML is full to bursting in some sections, and putting freight, long distance passenger, and stopping trains on the same tracks reduces capacity further. So it's mostly about building a new line. And once you're doing that, it makes sense to make it high speed and passenger only.
- stewdellow 7y agoI really wish the powers-at-be would look at Hyperloop as a serious alternative to HS2. While it seems so futuristic it's well within our technological abilities, just seems to be health and safety / legislature restrictions. Potentially far cheaper to build and maintain, modern, environmentally better and quicker amongst a host of other benefits and would help make Britain a global leader in transportation. The Danny in the Valley podcast episode with Dirk Ahlborn was eye opening on the potential benefits and briefly mentions HS2 and Crossrail along with the current SF to LA High Speed rail project.
- alexisread 7y agoThe best transport option might be smartrail (similar to http://openprtspecs.blogspot.com/2011/11/climbing-chain.html http://openprtspecs.blogspot.com/2011/11/climbing-chain.html but steel wheel/LIM and faster). Smartrail and PRT are designed as a point to point separated-grade network carrying on av. 1 person or a pallette of goods. With a hanging rail you don't need heavy batteries, parking for the vehicles, you can run a pod straight into the factory to pickup goods, and large/rich places can pay to have track straight to their door. You can prefab the rail and as land usage is just poles in the ground it can be rolled out over fields etc quickly. Track is one-way to eliminate junctions. Pods are on-demand ie. No waiting. Accessibility improves, you can use the top of the rail to generate (solar) power, run highspeed internet cables in the rail to improve comms across a country, and save on distribution center logistics as you're going point to point. The last mile may possibly be an issue, but forklift drones and bicycles can take most of the load I feel. Drivers for this are that it would go fast (200mph+ as light pods so little wear), can go overnight (sleeper pods), you could buy track to your door, personal transport (like a cinema room if you want). The main real issue with cars is that there's a large lobby behind what is a legacy transport solution... By way of example, UltraPRT has been running flawlessly at Heathrow airport for 10 years, was built on time, on budget, and performs exactly as predicted/modelled. For more info checkout http://faculty.washington.edu/jbs/itrans/ http://faculty.washington.edu/jbs/itrans/ in particular Swedetrack (https://web.archive.org/web/20060202013014/http://www.swedetrack.com/ https://web.archive.org/web/20060202013014/http://www.swedet...)