3 ms·
To amplify what vinceguidry said: A government has sovereign rights... within that country. Not outside, though. Why should Mozilla (which is not a Kazakhsta
by AnimalMuppet 7y ago
To amplify what vinceguidry said:
A government has sovereign rights... within that country. Not outside, though. Why should Mozilla (which is not a Kazakhstan entity) be subject to the laws of Kazakhstan? Should it not be subject to the laws of the US (presuming it is a US entity)?
> I am surprised there are no US laws that would adversley affect Mozilla.
Why should US law be subject to the law of Kazakhstan? That would kind of be a limit on US sovereignty, wouldn't it?
> But to actively work in hostility ti a foreign government is criminal.
No, it's only criminal within that country. If it's a foreign country, then you're not within that country - that's kind of what "foreign" means. I do what I do, paying attention to the laws of my country. I don't pay attention to the laws of other countries, because I'm not subject to them. They can pass all the laws they want. I don't care. I'm not following them, because I'm not there.
(Kazakhstan can, of course, freely prohibit Mozilla within its borders. It certainly has the right to do so.)
- dragonwriter 7y ago> A government has sovereign rights... within that country. Sovereignty doesn't have bounds on scope, only on applicability. That is, it applies to actions anywhere, by only to things brought within the practical power (which isn’t the same thing as territorial boundaries) of the sovereign. > Why should Mozilla (which is not a Kazakhstan entity) be subject to the laws of Kazakhstan? Because there is no superior sovereign over Kazakhstan to say no. That's what sovereignty is ultimately about. > That would kind of be a limit on US sovereignty, wouldn't it? That sovereign entities are in a state of perpetual conflict, and hat this conflict is the only limit on the power of sovereigns, is a very old and well-known observation about sovereignty. > No, it's only criminal within that country. Very few, if any, countries actually only criminalize conduct within their own territory. Most criminalize some conduct whether or not it's within their own territory, and some (including the US) criminalize certain conduct only if it is outside their own territory. In fact, in some cases there is broad international consensus that nations should criminalize certain conduct even when committed by foreigners in foreign lands.
- AnimalMuppet 7y ago> > Why should Mozilla (which is not a Kazakhstan entity) be subject to the laws of Kazakhstan? > Because there is no superior sovereign over Kazakhstan to say no. That's what sovereignty is ultimately about. But Mozilla doesn't reside in Kazakhstan. So what are you saying? That Kazakhstan can make a rule that has zero real-world effect because they can't enforce it, and because nobody can make them change their rule, they are therefore sovereign?
- dragonwriter 7y ago> But Mozilla doesn't reside in Kazakhstan Which would be relevant if there were a global sovereign and the government of Kazakhstan merely the regional administration beneath it of a particular territory, and if that sovereign made it relevant. Foreign residency alone doesn't immunize one from the rules of a sovereign either in theory or with a sufficiently capable and motivated one, in practice. > That Kazakhstan can make a rule that has zero real-world effect because they can't enforce it, and because nobody can make them change their rule, they are therefore sovereign? Close, but not quite. Rather, Kazakhstan, being sovereign, can make whatever rules it wants and is limited in applying them only by practical constraints, mostly those applied by other sovereigns. It may or may not be able to effectively apply it's laws to some conduct beyond it's borders; certainly other sovereign entities have done quite a bit of that.
- badrabbit 7y ago+1 This is why the US gets to invade random countries as a pre-emptive measure (e.g.:iraq)
- bscphil 7y ago> Close, but not quite. Rather, Kazakhstan, being sovereign, can make whatever rules it wants and is limited in applying them only by practical constraints, mostly those applied by other sovereigns. And absent any practical way for them to enforce their rules, no one has any good reason to respect them. Nor does their claim to "sovereignty" give them any kind of moral imperative over the actions of people who do not reside in that country on any philosophical theory of law that I am aware of. So without a practical reason (the threat of force) or a moral imperative (patently non-existent), why should Mozilla comply with their wishes? If the smallest sovereign state in the world passed a law that said that marriages in the United States were invalid if they were between two people of the same gender, would anyone care? Should they?
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]