3 ms·
But pipelines still are better than trucks. The alternate to the pipeline wasn’t no gas at all.
by kortilla 7y ago
But pipelines still are better than trucks. The alternate to the pipeline wasn’t no gas at all.
- metamet 7y agoPipeline is an investment in infrastructure that sets up a sunk cost argument against moving away from oil as a driving source of energy. "Why would we invest in more clean/green energy sources when we have this brand new pipeline?" It essentially hardens the argument (and subsequent lobbying) for these industries. I get that it is a huge source of income for folks who travel to and live in these areas. However, it's not a forward looking path--particularly when the environmental impact and costs are so high up front. In that respect, using trucks--while theoretically having a larger short term impact on emissions--allows for future flexibility and doesn't break into the earth in such a permanent and invasive way.
- pwinnski 7y ago"Better" in what sense? A tanker truck that spills its entire load might spill 3,000 gallons or 11,600 gallons[0], a far cry from the 11,000,000 gallons with which this story is concerned. On that measure, trucks are clearly lower-risk. On other measures, they fare worse. There was also the option of running the pipeline through a different area, but the government claimed that wasn't worth the extra expense, and that there would definitely be no spills like the one there obviously was. [0] https://www.reference.com/business-finance/many-gallons-tanker-truck-hold-98cd8f85aa0d92b4 https://www.reference.com/business-finance/many-gallons-tank...
- ticmasta 7y agoThe alternative to pipelines is not trucks, it's rail, and the impact x frequency of rail-based spills is larger than pipelines.
- ilikehurdles 7y agoNo, it isn’t. Pipelines spill far more than rail.