3 ms·
I've never understood why iOS isn't more like macOS. There aren't really any technical reasons why this couldn't be. It's common for the security argument to b
by pier25 7y ago
I've never understood why iOS isn't more like macOS. There aren't really any technical reasons why this couldn't be.
It's common for the security argument to be used to justify Apple's practices, but Mac users have been perfectly fine installing third party apps such as Transmit, Adobe Photoshop, or even Google Chrome from outside of Apple's walled garden. I've been using macOS since 2007 and I've never had a virus or any security problem, nor anyone else I know using a Mac. From my dev colleagues to my 70 year old mother in law or my 15 year old nephew.
It seems to me the only real arguments for Apple's walled garden are economical.
- kgwxd 7y agoThere will likely be a day when it's very difficult to install anything you want on macOS. Same with Windows. They keep trying really hard to make it happen but, for now, people keep pushing back even harder. For me, the fact that they're even trying is enough to leave.
- TacticalTable 7y agoMarket share is an appreciable concern here. Macs haven't been more than 20% of the market for a long time. iPhones are a much larger market share, especially among affluent users. I don't think we'd see any widespread viruses, but there would certainly be a ton of people losing their financial info from their own irresponsibility.
- pier25 7y agoSo your argument is that because there are more users it needs to be more secure?
- mattdanger 7y agoI think the argument is that if an OS has a tiny market share then it tends to be more open to 3rd party developers as a way to increase market share. MacOS used to be a more developer friendly.
- TacticalTable 7y agoMy argument is primarily that if somebody is looking to infect users, are they going to target the 86%, or the 13%? Macs have benefited for years by largely not being targeted by the majority of malware developers. If mobile devices open the walled garden, you get something similar to android's malware issues at best.
- pier25 7y agoiOS does not have a 86% market share. Not even close. Globally it's closer to 15%. In the US it's closer to 55%. If you argue that the 86% is the case on certain demographics, then the same can be argued about macOS.
- TacticalTable 7y agoThe demographic argument is what I'm going with. MacOS is 18%, compared to Windows at 74% [1]. When comparing the mobile statistics, they're bouncing around 50%. The iOS pool would be a much larger pool to attack than MacOS, and for little financial benefit for Apple. My prediction: If Apple opened the garden, even for a 'developer only' mode, I would imagine unregulated app stores would go up overnight, with wikihow articles on how to enable and install them, followed by a large amount of the technically illiterate (speaking from experience) trying to get free games, or 'add new emojis'. Users can't be trusted, and if consumer desktop operating systems were designed today, they wouldn't have the freedom they currently have. [1]: https://gs.statcounter.com/os-market-share/desktop/united-states-of-america https://gs.statcounter.com/os-market-share/desktop/united-st... (Not entirely sure on the accuracy/gathering of this data, but it had the easy filtering and seems to line up with both of our data points)
- pier25 7y ago> followed by a large amount of the technically illiterate (speaking from experience) trying to get free games, or 'add new emojis' I agree some people would do it... but I doubt it would be such a large number. Do you have any data about this? Users can already do that in Windows, macOS, and Android. From my anecdotal experience very few do it.