3 ms·
That is a subtle misreading of Rand; and all the more interesting because it precisely misses what she was trying to say. The sort of people who cook in return
by roenxi 7y ago
That is a subtle misreading of Rand; and all the more interesting because it precisely misses what she was trying to say. The sort of people who cook in return for pay or who operates machinery to till soil were the core of the world that Rand was envisioning. The vision wasn't anti-labour, it was anti-redistributive-policies. Philosophically there was a great deal of support for people who worked hard and earned a wage. If I recall correctly, its been a while, the condemnation was for the sort of people who said "I don't think you need this, so I'm going to take it and do a better job with it because you aren't moral enough".
Obviously Atlas Shrugged is a work of fiction, a community as small as was in the book couldn't match the productive output of city with a large labour force and not everyone is going to buy in to a capitalistic utopia. But the idea was never that the rich should dominate by virtue of being rich; the philosophy was that people should become rich because others agree that they are creating wealth. And the method for determining what people think should be a free market, and everyone should be left alone apart from that.
- Applejinx 7y agoI'm gonna have to correct you there: Rand famously was not interested in 'others', much less a suggestion that people's success should be in any way conditional upon 'others agree' in any sense. Perhaps you have an economic philosophy which I still wouldn't like, but which is nevertheless way better than what Rand was considering.
- entwife 7y agoAt the end of Atlas Shrugged, one laborer with a name (Eddie Willers) is left abandoned on the tracks, presumably left to die in the collapse.
- roenxi 7y agoYes, but not because he was a labourer. Rand was pretty hamfisted with that sort of thing, it was clearly intended to represent that he was devoting all he had to the redistributive types and that they were unable to give him anything meaningful in return. If he'd been labouring for the people Ayn liked instead of the ones she didn't he'd have lived to a happy and ripe old age. Which is the point of the book - what determined people's fate in the story was largely how they interacted with the people who wanted redistributive policies.
- apocalypstyx 7y agoI'll argue that textual evidence supports the opposite conclusion. Look at when Rearden finally decides to bail of society. He takes his top / mangers / engineers with him. What about all those other workers in Rearden Metal? The most of them are shown as hard working. But that's not enough. They (along with the d'Anconia's employees, etc, in a more explicitly cruel fashion) get left in a society that is purposefully being put into apocalypse mode in order to prove why certain people should get what they want. They get left there because they have to be. The Randian-moochers, would probably never humble themselves to ever invite the exceptional back. It's only going to be the impoverished workers who are going to have to throw off the yoke of the moochers and acknowledge how the world should be. So without the honest hard workers of the novel in such a position, the central conceit doesn't work. People like Galt start as mere workers but only so their exceptionality can be established by their ascendancy. The common worker is cannon fodder. In the world of Ayn Rand, the worker only exists to acknowledge the superiority of the exceptional.
- roenxi 7y agoSome of these points are convincing, so I shall slightly modify my argument. If Galt's Gulch had taken in the hardworking labourers as well as the management Ayn would have basically been writing a parable of the US vs the USSR. She might have been happy to do that too, but with Atlas Shrugged she clearly wasn't satisfied saying "Capitalism is better". She wanted to say "Communism doesn't work, and the driving idea here is really bad and should be rejected". So although horrible things did happen to the workers in the story of Atlas Shrugged, it wasn't at all because Ayn's message was anti-labour. Her point was that if the power of labour was being directed by people who wanted to redistribute capital based on need/fairness/something-other-than-ability-to-use-capital then the story would not go to a good place. Her philosophy had nothing bad to say about people who worked hard and earned money. It had a lot of unkind things to say about people who worked hard to support involuntary redistribution, and stood idly by without understanding that power was shifting away from the capable people. > In the world of Ayn Rand, the worker only exists to acknowledge the superiority of the exceptional. If I look around my room, I can't really name a person who could create any item in it except some of the technical writings. If I could, it would be the very small fraction of my acquaintances who are not clerks, office workers, administrative types or in the health or service sector. I rely pretty heavily on exceptional people of superior creativity to myself. I suspect most of the people on this forum do too.
- kerkeslager 7y agoI think you're misreading critics of Rand. Please don't assume that people only disagree with Rand because they don't understand Rand. > The vision wasn't anti-labour, it was anti-redistributive-policies. I won't comment on whether Rand's intentions are anti-labor, but intentions are irrelevant. Her vision was anti-labor because her vision is harmful to laborers, regardless of intentions. The problems were fairly obvious even at Rands time, and have continued to be borne out since. > But the idea was never that the rich should dominate by virtue of being rich; the philosophy was that people should become rich because others agree that they are creating wealth. You're conflating wealth with value. Rand believed that people should become rich (obtain wealth) because others agree that they are creating value. The problem is, Rand deliberately eschewed all attempts to ensure that this system actually works, ignoring the problem with the free market which was well-known even at that time: Some means of producing value (land, machinery, institutional knowledge) have a high entry cost, so only those with wealth can obtain those means. In this case, those without wealth are robbed twice: 1. If the poor wish to produce value they must go to those with the means of production. This means that only the rich get to participate in the agreement of who is creating value, and the poor must accept whatever wealth the rich say the value produced by the poor is worth. Of course the poor can find another wealthy person to produce value for, but the wealthy have no incentive to give up more wealth than their competitors as long as there is enough value being produced by the poor to go around. It should be no surprise that the wealthy choose to reward the poor with as little wealth as they can, no matter how much value the poor are actually producing. 2. If the poor wish to obtain value they must go to those with the means of production. This means that only the rich get to participate in the agreement of what value is worth, and the poor must give up whatever wealth the rich say their value is worth. Of course, the poor can find another wealthy person to obtain value from, but the wealthy have no incentive to accept less wealth than their competitors as long as there's enough wealth from the poor to go around. It should be no surprise that the wealthy choose to reward themselves with as much wealth as they can, no matter how much value they are actually producing. All this means that once a person has obtained adequate ownership of some means of production, that person no longer needs to produce value in order to obtain wealth. Rather than those who produce value being rewarded with wealth as Rand idealized, the poor produce the majority of the value and the rich are rewarded with majority of the wealth. Redistribution of wealth isn't based on the belief that the rich are less moral than the poor. On the contrary, the reason so many poor are on board with Randian economics is that they believe they can obtain wealth and then behave the same way as the wealthy. Redistribution of wealth is based on two beliefs: 1. Those who produce value should be rewarded with wealth, and 2. Those who wish to produce value should be enabled to do so. "Free" markets oppose both these beliefs, because 1. They allow those with wealth to amass more wealth without producing value, and 2. They allow those with wealth to determine who is allowed to produce value.